5 ms·
> I wonder how much of this is an outgrowth of the current university campus climate where opinions that don't fit into the predominant liberal worldview can't
by geofft 9y ago
> I wonder how much of this is an outgrowth of the current university campus climate where opinions that don't fit into the predominant liberal worldview can't be voiced.
This does not seem to match the reality at university campuses - only the caricature by people who find it politically expedient to be seen as persecuted.
- dominotw 9y agoResults of this debate disagree with you https://www.intelligencesquaredus.org/debates/free-speech-threatened-campus https://www.intelligencesquaredus.org/debates/free-speech-th...
- geofft 9y ago... pardon my assumption, but those four people don't look like college students. Are they?
- pmyteh 9y agoThe results of a straw poll after a debate are not evidence for anything beyond what the people who saw the debate thought of the debaters. People vote for all kinds of reasons - the underlying merits of the case, the impressiveness of the speakers that they've found to present it, even sympathy for someone who got obviously crushed by their opponent. When I was a debater I've seen some truly outrageous motions get passed simply because one side was funnier.
- dominotw 9y agoI understand. I was responding to comment that said its totally baseless caricature. I think debaters did a good job of presenting evidence for their case. Why not give it a chance instead of saying its "staw poll", isn't any poll "straw poll" by that account? Also I never said it evidence of anything. What is an example of "evidence" in this particular case for you?
- pmyteh 9y agoAh, sorry. You said "results of this debate disagree with you", so I took that to be the debate's results (the vote), not the debate itself. (And as a side point, no to the straw poll question - there are certain statistical guarantees on the representativeness of polls as long as they're drawn from a random sample of the public, with debates about how far you can deviate from a random sample and still have results that are useful. Self-selected polls, on the other hand, pretty much mean nothing.)
- dominotw 9y ago> Self-selected polls, on the other hand, pretty much mean nothing. Isn't our democracy built upon "self selected polling" , people who chose to go excesrice their right to vote. Its all meaningless?
- pmyteh 9y agoIf few enough people vote, arguably yes (though that's a fairly complex question and depends a lot on what your conception of democracy is). But in essence, an election is a full-population poll: like a random sample with probability 1 of being chosen. So it's statistically maximally valid. We (political scientists) tend to squint a bit and say the opportunity to vote is equivalent to actually voting, so non-voting doesn't harm the legitimacy of elections. I don't personally buy that, but it's a tricky problem to fix.
- dominotw 9y agoSo if am I reading this correctly. Previously you said "any self selected polling is meaningless" Now you are saying "Self selected polling is meaningful when people who didn't self select had the opportunity to do so" . Ok. So by that definition the poll I linked, everyone had the opportunity to participate in the debate, theoretically. What makes it meaningless ? PS: Fixing democracy ect is not interesting to me in this context, I want to focus your claim self-selected = meaningless.
- workthrowaway27 9y agoSee my reply to ak_yo.
- AlwaysBCoding 9y agoJust off the top of my head in the last year or so: Social scientist Charles Murray was censored then physically assaulted at Middlebury because he wrote a book about the correlation between intelligence and success [https://youtu.be/a6EASuhefeI?t=19m25s https://youtu.be/a6EASuhefeI?t=19m25s] Biology professor Bret Weinstein at Evergreen State College had himself and his family physically threatened because he refused to participate in a protest that asked all white people to leave campus for a day [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xq4Y87idawk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xq4Y87idawk] A professor at Diablo Valley College smashed a dude with a bike lock just because he was on the different side of the political spectrum as he was. [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ug34vogS3Fw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ug34vogS3Fw] Everything that Jordan Peterson had to go through at University of Toronto because he publicly opposed a draconian bill to forces professors to use specific pronouns when referring to students [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RsG71YrB_Nw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RsG71YrB_Nw] Lindsay Shepard at Laurier University had to face a star chamber from a 'diversity committee' because she showed a video clip of Jordan Peterson in class [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vpFUvfAvKs4&t=1m18s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vpFUvfAvKs4&t=1m18s] And then there were the psychos that literally lit University of Berkeley on fire when Milo Yiannopoulos went to give a talk there [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pi_vX0tknJM&t=4m45s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pi_vX0tknJM&t=4m45s] etc... etc...
- geofft 9y agoPlease see my other reply in this thread about censoring people vs. censoring ideas. The only one on this list that's somewhat convincing is the Laurier one, since that was in the course of an academic class. Milo isn't an academic. A professor beating someone with a bike lock might be inappropriate and criminal but isn't about academic discourse unless the other person is a professor, and it seems this person was a former professor, anyway. Jordan Peterson himself has been able to spread his ideas far and wide via his YouTube channel, which as far as I know is not censored on any campus network. etc.
- workthrowaway27 9y agoThey're being censored because of their ideas though... I'm not sure how you can draw that distinction.