4 ms·
If you going to build the same exact spec it's not that far off from the actual BOM for the parts, in fact going for the exact same build will cost you more tha
by dogma1138 9y ago
If you going to build the same exact spec it's not that far off from the actual BOM for the parts, in fact going for the exact same build will cost you more that that what Apple is charging.
So Vega Pro 64 (Vega FE equivalent) 8 core Xeon-W build from Apple is $5599
If you would build the same PC it would be:
~$1200 for the CPU (Xeon W-2145, not available to the public yet)
~$400 for 32GB ECC 2666mhz RAM from a good vendor
~$500 for a Xeon-W workstation motherboard
~$480 for 1 TB PCIE SSD like the Samsung 960 Pro
~$1000 for VEGA Frontier Edition
~$250 for a good case
~$220 for a good power supply
~$120 for CLC water cooling for the CPU
~$100 for case fans
~$1300 for a professional 4K monitor
This comes out to the total of ~$6870
Sure you can build an almost comparable PC from other parts at a fraction of the price but if you want to replicate the build in the iMac it will cost you much more.
Also AFAIK you can connect a second screen the TB ports do support Thunderbolt displays and DisplayPort.
- ekianjo 9y ago> This comes out to the total of ~$6370 Except that you don't have to throw it up when you want to upgrade a couple of parts.
- roryisok 9y agoThis. I'm not going to shell out $3k for a desktop computer that can't be upgraded. That's just stupid, even if it does look nice.
- dogma1138 9y agoI didn't said you should, but in all honesty upgrade-ability is so overrated in the PC world. Other than storage I haven't upgraded a single PC I've owned in the past decade if not more simply because at the point when upgrade was needed it was pointless. Don't get me wrong I wouldn't buy this iMac, I don't need it, and I don't want it, and I would buy a PC, but Apple is pretty far from skinning people on prices this time around.
- roryisok 9y ago> I haven't upgraded a single PC I've owned in the past decade if not more simply because at the point when upgrade was needed it was pointless. Maybe it's becoming less common to upgrade, but it doesn't mean people don't still do it. I've upgraded several machines in the last decade, for myself and others. Not everyone can afford to just chuck out an upgradeable PC and buy a new one.
- ionised 9y agoGuessing you don't play a lot of PC games?
- oneeyedpigeon 9y ago> Other than storage I haven't upgraded a single PC I've owned in the past decade if not more simply because at the point when upgrade was needed it was pointless. Me neither, but for a different reason: I moved over to the Mac ecosystem 6 years ago, and haven't been able to upgrade since then. Except for adding some memory to a mac mini. I'm holding out for the new Mac Pro. If it's upgradable in a meaningful way, I'll snap one up.
- ekianjo 9y ago> I didn't said you should, but in all honesty upgrade-ability is so overrated in the PC world. You can keep a screen for example longer than the internals of the PC. Macs are just a waste in general because they are not made to be taken apart and to be serviced. And certainly NOT by the user.
- freehunter 9y agoIsn't that offset by the fact that you can resell a Mac for a decent amount of return, versus reselling a PC for pennies on the dollar?
- edu 9y agoI think you're inflating prices. You can get a really good 4k 27" monitor for about $500,
- wlesieutre 9y agoMaybe they meant "5K monitor" which is what the iMac Pro has and would fit this price range better.
- dogma1138 9y agoNope, the closest thing you can get to the iMac Pro display is likely something like a the Dell PrimeColor UP2718Q which costs about $1500 or the UP2715K which goes for around $1300.
- alkonaut 9y agoIsn't the closest thing just any other monitor with the exact same panel? The panel isn't everything - but it's a lot. https://www.amazon.com/LG-27MD5KA-UltraFine-International-Version/dp/B06XH8XBMR https://www.amazon.com/LG-27MD5KA-UltraFine-International-Ve... In any case: you'll need to put up $1500 to get this. Either a "better" Pro 4K or the equivalent 5K.
- dogma1138 9y agoI specifically didn't suggest it because you can't connect it to anything that doesn't supports Thunderbolt 3 monitors since it doesn't have a display port connection, so you can't use that with a PC in any reliable way.
- PascLeRasc 9y agoWait, so my 2014 13" rMBP won't be able to connect to it? A coworker has one and it looks amazing, I had it on my "if I win the lottery" list.
- gruez 9y ago>~$250 for a good case what? $250 is really overpriced for a case. it will get you a really good case (see: https://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductList.aspx?Submit=ENE&IsNodeId=1&N=100007583%204802%204018&cm_sp=Cat_Computer-Cases_6-_-VisNav-_-Best-Sellers https://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductList.aspx?Submit=ENE&I...) >~$220 for a good power supply that's definitely overkill. >~$120 for CLC water cooling for the CPU >~$100 for case fans that's like, at least 6 really expensive case fans + watercooling. does the mac pro even have that good of a cooling system?
- dogma1138 9y agoHigh end case which is similarly visually pleasing, $250 is actually fairly cheap I could've suggested a custom case :) With a Xeon-W and a Vega64 ~200$ for a decent power supply isn't that far fetched, you'll be looking at 850W with preferably 1000W+ PSU so it could stay cool under pressure. And no the iMac doesn't have a CLC but it has a cooling system you cannot replicate, and if you haven't noticed an air cooler that can keep a socket 2066 CPU sufficiently cool would cost you about as much as a CLC $100 buys you a few maglev low noise fans nothing too fancy.
- FireBeyond 9y ago> you'll be looking at 850W with preferably 1000W+ PSU I will eat my hat if the iMac Pro comes with a kilowatt PSU.
- dogma1138 9y agoVEGA64 has a 300W TDP and can pull over 400W underload. The Xeon-W has a TDP of 140W and can pull 200W under load. Add in cooling, most radial fans are 4-6A @ 12V which means they can pull upto 80W.... The Delta radial fan on the Vega 64/56 air pulls 60W on it's own at full speed. High end motherboards consume 40-80W, memory also will consume about 5W per DIMM. And you have the built in screen which can easily consume 200W or more at peak brightness. So I hope you have a tasty hat, because there is no way that the iMac Pro isn't coming with a near 1kW PSU.
- noxToken 9y agoYour prices are really inflated. Here's a smattering of parts from PCPP: https://pcpartpicker.com/list/tRW3VY https://pcpartpicker.com/list/tRW3VY Note the memory is 2133. This total comes out to ~$2300. Add a mobo, the cpu, and a monitor, you're looking at a grand total of about $4500.
- dogma1138 9y agoI actually forgot the motherboard in my build that’s another $500 since Xeon-W is only supported on the workstation chipsets. The cooler won’t be enough, the case is pretty low end and the PSU isn’t something you want to touch the EVGA G2 line is pretty bad. You can easily do 70% for 50% of the cost but that isn’t the point.
- dewiz 9y ago> you can connect a second screen the TB ports do support Thunderbolt displays and DisplayPort. OP meant something different, which I agree with: > If you want to run 2 screens, then they won’t match. when working with multiple monitors most prefer having equal sized/looking ones