4 ms·
>> Finally, he overstates how hard it is to customise the engine (Markov algorithm + AI) to a game. I think you're imagining some setup in which a neural net i
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
>> Finally, he overstates how hard it is to customise the engine (Markov algorithm + AI) to a game.
I think you're imagining some setup in which a neural net is directly
communicating with an external rule engine that generates a set of legal
moves for each piece in each board configuration. That's not how it works. You
know how people say that Neural Nets are "black boxes"? That's what they mean.
You can't just plug into arbitrary steps of their training with arbitrary
external processes. You have to setup everything right at the input and then
wait patiently at the output, until what you want comes out. Then you can plug
that in to whatever reasoning loop you want to set up.
So like I say, it's not a trivial thing and it doesn't generalise very well to
arbitrary problems. You need to match the architecture to the problem. For
example, that's why ConvNets have been studied extensively for vision- their
architecture is specifically tailored to vision problems.
Hence also the doubts expressed in the article about the claims to general
game-playing ability. Yeah, you might imagine that it's possible to create a
specialised architecture to play any particular game (or even sets of games
with similar setups, like chess and shogi)- but it's not clear how exactly
you'd do that automatically. Handcrafting a thousand architectures for a
thousand different games is not very "general purpose", is it?
- amarkov 9y agoThe question is how much those architectures encode insights about how to play the game well, vs just how to play the game at all. After all, you have to teach general-purpose humans the rules of each specific game.