3 ms·
> the stereotype "gypsy = criminal" is still incredibly harmful How so? You just state this as a given, and in fact, that also could be seen as a stereotype.
by mpweiher 9y ago
> the stereotype "gypsy = criminal" is still incredibly harmful
How so? You just state this as a given, and in fact, that also could be seen as a stereotype.
> people are ill-equipped to handle these thoughts in the brain simultaneously
Actually, the evidence is that people are very well equipped to handle these thoughts simultaneously: they use the stereotype only as long as they have no further evidence.
- virgilp 9y agoI actually explained "how so" in my post, not sure what extra details you want: A. At a personal level: do I need to go into details how being presumed "by default" to be non-trustworthy and potentially a criminal/thief can seriously impact your lifetime opportunities? B. At a group level: the instinctual response to criminals is to avoid &"isolate" them; this creates ghettos. It doesn't help that they also have a tendency to auto-isolate themselves. I fail to see how this response is any of help towards actually solving the problem (well, short of the "final solution", I guess, if you're willing to seriously consider that).
- mpweiher 9y agoYou "explained" nothing, you just asserted. >do I need to go into details how being presumed "by default" to be non-trustworthy and potentially a criminal/thief can seriously impact your lifetime opportunities? Yes, please do. When you do, take into account that "per default" means "as long as no other information is available", which only applies to people that you are completely unconnected to and have never interacted with. Also, please try to incorporate this into a model of the real world with tradeoffs. So for example weigh my/your/his/her right not to be victimized, and everyone's duty to take care of themselves and others, with the right of someone not to be viewed with suspicion. > the instinctual response to criminals is to avoid &"isolate" them Citation needed. > tendency to auto-isolate themselves Citation needed. Aren't you stereotyping here? > help towards actually solving the problem What is "the problem" you refer to? What would you see as a solution?
- virgilp 9y agoWhat did you last slave die of? I'm not sure whether there's something you actually disagree with - or you just want to "be right" by creating unreasonable burdens of proof. If so - here: you're right, I'm just a random dude making baseless affirmations, please ignore me. > Aren't you stereotyping here? Yes I am. I thought you're a supporter of the idea that stereotypes are true more often than not? [edit] And to clarify, because it seems to be needed: by 'harmful', I mean harmful to the victims of the stereotype. If you discriminate someone, you're not necessarily harmed - but the other one may be. This isn't a "slavery was harmful to ranch owners" argument - it's not even a "slavery was harmful for the US society" argument. It's just a "slavery was harmful for black people" argument. I'm honestly flabbergasted that someone would honestly demand proof for that sort of statement.
- mpweiher 9y ago> stereotypes are true more often than not Yes, more often than not. Sometimes they're wrong. For example, the now common stereotype that stereotypes are mostly wrong is wrong. > Slavery What does slavery have to do with it, except nothing? Let's give a more realistic example: Say there's a woman walking alone at night. She notices a large man walking behind her. She crosses the road. Now she knew nothing of this man, so she just used her stereotypes (large men=possibly dangerous) and the situation (late at night) to inform her decision. Evil stereotype or prudent decision? Has he been "victimized" by the (almost certainly) incorrect assumption of her's that he is a danger?
- virgilp 9y ago> What does slavery have to do with it Analogy - I was hoping that might help you understand what I meant by "harmful" (ie "who is the one being harmed?"). I didn't mean that you were harmed by it. > Let's give a more realistic example But I never stated that all stereotypes are harmful, or all create victims, or whatever. I stated that SOME do, and gave a specific example that you challenged. And now you move to a different example to prove.... what?