2 ms·
Too big because it is out of touch with its citizens, and a UBI would lead to a national ID. Look at China for what can happen from that. Also too large because
by EGreg 9y ago
Too big because it is out of touch with its citizens, and a UBI would lead to a national ID. Look at China for what can happen from that. Also too large because the cost of living varies from place to place, so no one amount of UBI can fit every citizen.
At the same time it's too small because Americans are already far better off than most of the world, so if anyone really needs UBI it should be the poorer per capita countries, funded by the richest in the world. In other words UBI for Americans only misses the point.
- tom_mellior 9y agoPlenty of countries have national ID systems, and they are not dictatorships. (But the IDs are easy to get for everyone, and we don't have discussions and "rumors" about fake voters, which is also nice.) On the other hand, I'm fairly sure China had a civil war that established a communist dictatorship before it had an efficient national ID system.