5 ms·
It's 2017, and my social media account is protected by a tamper-proof phish-resistant embedded-encryption U2F microcontroller dongle, in addition to a password
by exabrial 9y ago
It's 2017, and my social media account is protected by a tamper-proof phish-resistant embedded-encryption U2F microcontroller dongle, in addition to a password of virtually unlimited length and charset. Meanwhile, my bank has a max password length of 12 and I can only use an alphabet of roughly 64 characters.
The future is here folks. And it sucks.
- morinted 9y agoBMO in Canada forces 6 digits or alphanumerics as your account password. No more, no less. What's worse, because it can be entered on the phone, aAbBcC are all == 1. So it's really just 6 digits.
- toomanybeersies 9y agoSomewhere, in the background, there's a poor old unix mainframe running Cobol, unaware that the world around it has changed, and that it should put to pasture, where it can live out the rest of its days in peace.
- bigiain 9y agoWorse, it's probably an emulation of a Unix mainframe running the original Cobol code - with the emulator running in machine generated JavaScript in Nodejs on AWS... (Obligatory xkcd comic: https://xkcd.com/1926/ https://xkcd.com/1926/ )
- azernik 9y agoNo, more likely it's a newer IBM mainframe, as those are built to be backwards-compatible with software written back in the 60s.
- madaxe_again 9y agoA large bank in the uk runs their core software on AS400s emulating a 1401. Their ledger software is almost 60 years old.
- angry_octet 9y ago"Unix mainframe" is something that never really existed, mainframes run special operating systems like z/OS. (You can run SuSE on a virtual partition under z, but not natively, and it is a recent concept.)
- tzs 9y agoI've heard of a bank actually trying to use that excuse when asked why their online banking passwords were so limited. That is, of course, complete bullshit. Sure, it is plausible that a bank has an old mainframe handling their accounts. It is also plausible that user account passwords on that old mainframe are only 6 or 8 characters and from a limited alphabet. What does that have to do with customer online banking accounts? Nothing! When you open a bank account they don't make a user account for you on their mainframe. What they make for you is an entry in an application database that their banking applications use. The only mainframe user accounts involved are the account that the database runs under and the account that the banking application runs under, both of which are the same for all banking customers. Even if, for some strange reason, they do actually have to make a mainframe login account for each banking customer there is no reason for the banking customer to ever directly access that. Online banking is accessed through the web, so only the web server needs to access your banking account on the mainframe. They could make the website have its own password system, without the mainframe login restrictions. The restricted mainframe login information would only be known by the mainframe and the website back end. The banking customer should never deal with that.
- lionelione43 9y agoTo be fair though, at least they offer the guarantee that if your online banking is hacked they will reimburse 100%. Though not sure how truthful it is having never needed it. https://i.imgur.com/O2eOwLw.jpg https://i.imgur.com/O2eOwLw.jpg Edit: "You may be liable for all losses from unauthorized use of your Account if you: contributed to its unauthorized use; used a PIN combination selected from your name, telephone number, date of birth, address, or Social Insurance Number; did not use reasonable care to safeguard your Secret ID Code; did not keep your Secret ID Code separate from your Card; did not comply with your reporting obligations in Section 11 of this Agreement unless there were exceptional circumstances for your failure to do so; or shared a mobile device that you registered with us for Electronic Banking Services. In those cases, your liability may exceed the funds in an Account, your credit limit or any daily transaction limits. In other words, your liability will not be limited by your Account balance, your credit limit or any daily transaction limits. You must cooperate and assist in any investigation that we initiate into the unauthorized use you reported, which is a precondition to being reimbursed for any losses. This cooperation may include filing a report with law enforcement authorities." Overall seems fair enough protection.
- bowmessage 9y agoOk this sounds like a terrible question but how do they stop people from "hacking" themselves...
- lionelione43 9y agoYou basically need to file a police report about the theft, and the bank will probably know where the money was sent/spent, and the police ideally would investigate and subpoena the records of wherever the money went and presumably discover if it goes back to you somehow. The first liability thing says you cannot have "contributed to its unauthorized use". I mean realistically someone could possibly do it and get away with it, but I mean people could realistically do many types of fraud. Most could realistically probably get away with it. It's more a guarantee to people that if they get hacked somehow other then giving naughty little Johnny/vindictive ex Jane the bank card and pin, they can get their money back.
- 9y ago
- astura 9y agoI signed up for a US BMO account for the sign up bonus... Man is that bank's website bad. The version of jQuery they are using is from 2008 (1.3xx IIRC) and they give you a pop-up if you try to right click saying "right-click has been disabled for security purposes."
- teddyfrozevelt 9y agoIt just took my terrible python program 9 seconds to guess 999999.
- MiddleEndian 9y agoGuess what! If your financial service restricts your password to letters and numbers, it's most likely because they want you to be able to enter your password on the phone. So the passwords 'abc' 'ABC' and '222' are treated as equivalent. Try it out for fun!
- sunsetMurk 9y agothat's disgusting :-/
- ktta 9y agoWhat banks do this? AFAIK, Wells Fargo doesn't care about case-sensitivity but that's it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ozim 9y agoI don't want to enter my password on the phone, I have fingerprint or pin in mobile banking app.
- Frank2312 9y agoHe meant over the phone, not on a phone. Ex : I call my bank and I have to go through a menu leading me to the right agent. Eventually, it asks for my password over the phone that I need to type using the 10 numbers on a phone dial. Good luck using your fingerprint there :)
- ozim 9y agoFor that i have separate numeric only password in my bank which is different than my web login password. So bank is saving couple of bucks to reuse same weak password that can be stolen on web and then used by attacker to authenticate as me over the phone. What a crappy bank. I am just happy that bank that I use is having all set better.
- chrisshroba 9y ago
- jjeaff 9y agoMy bank only recently upgraded max password length from 8 to 12. Oh, and no special characters please.
- mathw 9y agoBy "special character", do they mean punctuation? Or the null byte?
- piinbinary 9y agoI know of at least one bank that requires your password to have exactly one digit. Not one or more, exactly one.
- artursapek 9y agohttp://password-shaming.tumblr.com/ http://password-shaming.tumblr.com/
- exabrial 9y agoThis is AWESOME!
- yosamino 9y ago> my bank has a max password length of 12 Look at Mr. PrivateBanking over there, my one is 5. Amount in words : Five. And that is after they updated all their software and moved to a new datacenter and everything recently. Granted I have a hardware dongle to authenticate any transactions, but to gain access to all my information, five characters is all the protection they wish to offer...
- astura 9y agoYour bank password is probably not even case sensitive: http://www.zdnet.com/article/surprise-online-bank-passwords-may-not-be-case-sensitive/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/surprise-online-bank-passwords-... Offenders: Wells Fargo, Chase, American Express, Fidelity, ....
- josefresco 9y ago"The future is already here — it's just not very evenly distributed." - William Gibson
- Macha 9y agoI played Eve online for a while. My corp (guild for non-Eve players) had a better and more secure login & SSO system than either my bank or my employer. My employer has replaced their SSO system by now, but my bank is still in the 90s.