8 ms·
Another lesson is to always host the login section on a sub domain of the company which website you visit. A prime example not to follow is Citibank in Europe.
by cm2187 9y ago
Another lesson is to always host the login section on a sub domain of the company which website you visit. A prime example not to follow is Citibank in Europe. My account is with citibank.co.uk, but when I login to my account I get redirected to online.citi.eu. How do I know that citi.eu belongs to Citibank? I have no relationship with citi.eu, that’s not the website I visited. How do I know I can trust it?
Microsoft is another major offender. When logging in, I get redirected 20 times between various domains, none of which in microsoft.com
- iaw 9y agoCiti has some really bad security practices, when I talked with them about it they mentioned some future changes they were planning that were even worse.
- nerdponx 9y agoWhat is the business reasoning behind this kind of domain name silliness?
- johnsoft 9y agoI assume one team is responsible for the home page, and another team is responsible for the banking portal, and they can't be bothered to coordinate with each other.
- gerdesj 9y agoI agree. There is no technical reason behind this sort of bollocks. One day S&M will catch up and have a fit at the fragmented "front face" - quite right too. To be honest the board should also give a shit about their org's outward appearance. Bit of a fail all 'round, really.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- OliverJones 9y agoTrue true true. I know of some banks where invest.examplebank.com and bank.examplebank.com are controlled by mutually distrustful organizations. They really should put their stuff into the public suffix list at https://publicsuffix.org/ https://publicsuffix.org/, because, session cookies. But that would assume they knew something about what they were doing.
- nerdponx 9y agoThis makes sense but it seems to be bigger than that. For example, most companies with a major internet presence have a CDN on a totally separate domain, like "twimg.com", "chasecdn.com", etc. there must be a good technical reason for this, because everybody does it. Or is that an unrelated thing?
- Klathmon 9y agoThat's an unrelated thing. By having CDN assets on a separate domain, you not only easily avoid accidentally sending any cookies along to the other domains (so if your CDN gets owned at least they aren't getting user credentials or session cookies), but it's also a small performance optimization as there are less things sent in the headers. The important distinction is that the user should never ENTER any information onto those domains directly. They should be for displaying static resources only, so there is no need to "build trust" for them.
- astura 9y agoCiti just had a terrible IT team. Their website is always broken and their back end computer systems, until recently, were filled with reward loopholes.
- toomanybeersies 9y agoMicrosoft's sign in is a real mess, I think in part due to having to make your hotmail login that you made 15 years ago still work, along with the dozens of other services that MS has acquired or integrated. I've had a real shitter of a time trying to login before, with redirect loops, or getting automatically signed out as soon as I sign in. Or accounts being a "games for Windows" account, but not an MS account, or an Xbox live account, so some other account. Often I've just found it easier to give up and make a new account.
- chrisparton1991 9y agoI hear you. I was pulling my hair out the other day trying to find my Microsoft credentials in LastPass. I was searching for "microsoft", "office", "outlook" etc. until I finally found them under "live.com".
- adameast9000 9y agoI also have an @live.com email. I think "live" was one of Microsoft's many failed services rebrands. Remember windows live messenger, windows live photo gallery? Lol
- nolok 9y agoAnd before that, the grandiose ".Net passport"
- JonathonW 9y agoMicrosoft's account system has had at least five different names; it's just "Microsoft account" right now, but it'll likely be called something different in a year or two the next time Microsoft does one of their gigantic "rebrand all the things" purges.
- AgentME 9y agoA ridiculous number of times that I've tried to go to xbox.com while previously signed in, the site redirects me around a bit before dropping me onto a blank page. Ugh.
- mattmanser 9y agoUgh, MS just seem to get worse too, "Try our new login experience, it logs you out every 15 minutes, so much fun!".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wepple 9y agoI was looking up details of the new Microsoft Surface recently, so hit the top link in a google search which was (supposedly) on Microsoft.com It wouldn’t load because Facebook.com was blocked and apparently they were doing a full redirect via fb. Crazy.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoThis may in fact be because Google lets advertisers set a totally different URL than the one that they actually direct you to, so that advertisers can implement various tracking schemes. This is also exploited by malicious actors to occasionally buy out fake ads for amazon.com or bestbuy.com (or even, hilariously, youtube.com) which actually direct you to support scam websites claiming your computer is infected. Google seems to have no desire to correct this by making their advertisements show you the actual URL are you going to be directed to. Verify that any link you click on is not an ad. Always look for the first native result. The policies permitted around ads make them simply a security risk to click on.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mevile 9y agoYou didn't click on a search result, you clicked on an advertisement.
- dawnerd 9y agoA good reason to use at the very least adblock.
- thanksgiving 9y agoAnd to avoid Microsoft edge. Why do I have to open Windows store for an add-on to my browser? Why can't I do it from the browser like in Mozilla Firefox or in Google Chrome?
- hug 9y agoMy citibank credit card redirects me to "cardservicesdirect.com.au" -- which reads like a phishing site if I've ever seen one. I confirmed over the phone with their support that was indeed the correct site before typing anything into it.
- snowwindwaves 9y agoBut did you call the support phone number shown on the dodgy domain?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thanksgiving 9y agoT-Mobile called me back one time instead of me waiting on hold. This was after I went through the song and dance of giving the automated system my details. The first thing this representative wanted to do was, again, confirm I am who I said I was. I said think about what you're asking for a second. Should I answer your questions? Couldn't get them to understand. Wound up hanging up and calling again and waiting on hold.
- ccozan 9y agoHa, same thing happened to me with Vodafone. Some guy called having some nice upgrade to my account. For some reason, to check something, he said, I need your online password. I said, wait, you call _me_ and want my password too? If I call you, tell I am from your bank and I need your PIN, would give it? Well no, came the reply. Then... Obviously I terminated the conversation.
- dingo_bat 9y agoI hate it when someone calls me and asks me who I am. You called, you tell me who you want to talk to.
- tialaramex 9y agoMy bank actually gets this right. They very, very rarely call me, but when they do it's "Hello, am I talking to Nick Lamb?" "Yes, this is me" "OK, I'm calling from Example Bank and our confirmatory password is Melons" [not the actual bank or password] "Thanks, that checks out, what can I do for you?" This happened because I had one of those conversations you're talking about, and they were like "Aha! We have something we can do for those situations, call us and set a password we can use" so I hung up and sure enough they've used that password ever since. I like it. It's not a _good_ password, but hey, how many times does anyone try the wrong one? Literally never. So it's good enough.
- jjeaff 9y agoOne of the worst I've seen is Franklin Templeton. They sent out snail mail telling everyone to go to a URL like "accountservices.biz" and reenter private information like your social security number in order to update your account records. The site itself is branded just like Templeton's own site. From what I could gather, it is actually their site but even the whois is something non descript. Quite ridiculous. And of course they don't have any way whatsoever that I could find to report things like vulnerabilities or phishing attempts.
- stuff4ben 9y agoThat would be a fascinating way to do a scam. Send snail mail to people directing them to a site that looks like a major company, ask them to enter in their PII and boom, there you go. Of course now you've committed untold amounts of federal crime by using the postal system and you'd definitely get sent to federal PMITA prison if you got caught. But I could definitely see this working on older people who, bless their little hearts, just don't know any better.
- JohnTHaller 9y agoMicrosoft's login experience has been generally broken for years. Multiple redirects through different domains. Heck it uses Javascript redirects. In 2017. So your back button won't work. And it has a habit of just not working. I went to visit a public page on docs.microsoft.com and wound up dead on a white page on login.live.com because it decided I needed to be redirected to login. Just to view a docs page.
- drchickensalad 9y agoWhat is the alternative to javascript redirecting when you can't do it as the http response?
- JohnTHaller 9y agoIt spits out an HTML page with no body that solely does a Javascript redirect. Put it in the http response.
- noxToken 9y agoI don't know if this is still the case, but you couldn't login if you had 3rd party cookies disabled. Somewhere in the authentication phase, it would silently fail. No error message like incorrect username/password. You'd get kicked back to the login screen as if you just got there. It was a hassle trying to find exactly which cookies were necessary.
- heywire 9y agoIt is even worse if you work for a large company with Office 365 that uses your organizations domain for authentication. I think there are about 6 redirects to get logged in. Even worse than that, they made us create a "personal" account with the exact same username for accessing MSDN because it wasn't compatible with our SSO at the time. So every time I log in, I have to type in my username, wait for the redirect, then choose personal account, wait for redirect, etc...
- einrealist 9y agoThat is typical for organizations, where a DNS change takes weeks or months or isn't even possible, because of different legal entities. "Lets just register our own domain. Its faster...." Having a bank as a current client, I am often joking about what would happen if Jeff Bezos takes control for a month. And when I am angry, I ask what would happen if Amazon or Google start selling credits or insurances, tomorrow.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]