4 ms·
Why should American corporations pay both foreign and US corporate tax on income made overseas? They don't. They pay the highest rate in either jurisdiction, s
by gamblor956 9y ago
Why should American corporations pay both foreign and US corporate tax on income made overseas?
They don't. They pay the highest rate in either jurisdiction, so either the US or the foreign rate. In the US, they get a tax credit for the amount of taxes paid to a foreign tax authority so that they are never double-taxed on their corporate income. Note that every country in the world of significant economic size taxes corporate income.
Dividends are taxed twice, as corporate profits and again when received by the shareholders as dividends, but they should be. Dividend taxes are the price shareholders pay for getting limited liability and all sorts of government protections and incentives.
- marcoperaza 9y ago>Dividend taxes are the price shareholders pay for getting limited liability and all sorts of government protections and incentives. We provide for limited liability because we think it is beneficial to society in encouraging investment and risk-taking; it is not a sacrifice or expense we expect compensation for.
- cbzbc 9y agoIt's both/and, there are costs associated both with the laws around llcs and providing the need to play the of liability holder of last resort in certain circumstances.
- josephagoss 9y agoI agree with everything you said except the double taxation of dividends. Australia has probably the best system in the world for dividends. We use a franking credit to offset the tax paid by the corporation so effectively we have no double taxation of dividends. I've never seen the point to any double taxation and I applaud any government willing to help citizens and business work around double taxation.
- valuearb 9y agoForeign cooroate income is triple taxed, foreign income taxes, then us repatraition taxes, the state income taxes. Then on what’s left sgarehokders pay dividend and state taxes. That’s sextuple taxed.
- gamblor956 9y agoMost of what you said isn't true. Foreign subsidiary gets taxed by, say, Australia at 25%. It pays dividend to US parent, 0% withholding tax. But the US parent gets an "indirect foreign tax credit" for the taxes its subsidiary pays. (The IFTC is only available to corporations, not individuals, partnerships, or non-corporate LLCs.) It's complicated, but the IFTC can include prior-year foreign taxes paid by Australia Sub, and correspondingly the total IFTC sent up to US Parent is proportional to the total amount of foreign earnings remaining in Australia being dividended up. If that's 100%, then USParent gets a full credit of 25% for the Aussie tax paid by the subsidiary. Note that the US Parent will also pay state taxes on the dividend, and will thus get a SALT deduction for those taxes (but not a credit, so not a dollar-for-dollar reduction). The dividend, paid out to US shareholders, is subject to reduced rates, so it's actually taxes less than normal income. Exact rate depends on your bracket. Recipients will get taxed by their home states as well, but will also get a state tax deduction (at least through 2017...2018 onward depends on the GOP tax bill). The effective rate of tax on foreign earnings from foreign subsidiary to ultimate shareholder thus becomes roughly 50% or less...cheaper than in every other economically relevant nation (meaning 1st and 2nd world countries) after all taxes and credits and deductions are taken into account. The US has the highest "statutory" tax rates but the lowest effective tax rates in the first world for business income.
- opo 9y ago>...The US has the highest "statutory" tax rates but the lowest effective tax rates in the first world for business income. Lots of people claim this, but it doesn't appear to be true: >...The U.S. effective corporate tax rate consistently ranks among the five highest of nations considered. The only nation with a higher ETR in each study is Japan, which not by coincidence is the only developed nation with a higher statutory rate than the U.S. Other major nations found to possess a higher ETR than the U.S. in at least one study include France, Italy, and Germany, but no clear patterns emerge; the U.S. outranks this sample more often than not. Significantly, both Italy and Germany have enacted rate cuts since many of these studies were conducted. https://files.taxfoundation.org/legacy/docs/sr195.pdf https://files.taxfoundation.org/legacy/docs/sr195.pdf
- 9y ago
- stevep98 9y agoDividends, especially qualified dividends are taxed way below regular income though, to reflect this.