10 ms·
The question I’m interested in: How do we unlock maximum human potential? Last I checked, welfare does the opposite of this. It helps people merely subsist, no
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
The question I’m interested in: How do we unlock maximum human potential?
Last I checked, welfare does the opposite of this. It helps people merely subsist, not strive for greatness.
Then he goes on to compare YC to basic income. Seriously? They take a share in your company and help you develop it. That isn't money for nothing.
If he weren't a millionaire and the current president of YC, would we keep seeing articles about his vision on the front page of HN? I don't think so. I don't believe his arguments are that cogent or compelling.
I find it increasingly sad and frustrating to see yet another Sam Altman on UBI piece here. The mantra on HN is that ideas matter and that HN wants to deemphasize names and avoid promoting pieces being posted merely because they are about some celebrity. I think these articles fail that test.
If you take Sam Altman out of this article, would we discuss it at all? If the answer to that is no, then why are we discussing it?
- mrob 9y agoWelfare discourages striving for greatness, because as soon as you show any sign of success it's taken away from you. The "universal" in UBI means it's paid to everybody, rich and poor. It lacks the weird breakpoints and perverse incentives of welfare. You are always better off working.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoPrior to Sam Altman re-envisioning YC as a form of UBI, Paul Graham talked a lot about the idea that the money they gave was insignificant. The real value was in connecting you with movers and shakers and educating you about business creation. Last I checked, UBI does not come with built in business education or introductions to movers and shakers. I was homeless for nearly six years and actively trying to make business connections on HN, largely to no avail. No one wanted to take me seriously. Unsurprisingly, my income grew extremely slowly. If I had a choice between UBI or connections, I would take connections in a heart beat. They are potentially worth millions.
- contingencies 9y agoFWIW I have noticed your posts and your arguments are lucid. A well-worn path to higher income as a communications professional is corporate PR and media management. You could consider developing an offering here for startups, either a course or a book or (preferably) a business, since we now see so many PR hacks for startups type articles yet as an actual founder I can tell you I don't have time to manually research hitlists for general PR nor source professional imagery, newswire services or upcoming conference/event/speaking/interview opportunities, etc. I think there is definitely room for a paid service in this space with a human touch and it won't take much to stand out, eg. professional translation and redistribution to specific language media of PR announcements as a default service. Good luck on your journey!
- acjohnson55 9y agoGreat point. Or perhaps a PR firm. If you're near NYC, SF or Boston, my wife works at a firm she loves and I'd be glad to intro you (Doreen) to her.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI am in a small town in Southwest Coastal Washington.
- danenania 9y agoI think the idea of the YC money being insignificant comes from its roots as a program for college students. When you're still mostly supported by your parents, the money isn't as big of a deal since you have basically no expenses and endless runway anyway. But when you've got rent, bills, a family, etc., the money is a very big deal and can easily be the difference between having the runway to make it vs. needing to quit and get a job prematurely. The parallels with basic income are clear. How many people are out there with the potential to be one of the best in the world at something important, yet aren't able to develop themselves because they started with nothing and are 100% focused on making ends meet? We won't find out until we give all those people a chance.
- dahdum 9y agoMost discussions I've seen of UBI recently have shifted from universal to means tested. Regardless, wouldn't UBI need to be higher for the sick, elderly, and disabled? Either it's high enough for them and too much for everyone else, or it's too low for them. Keep adjusting and you end up with a means tested welfare system like today.
- mrob 9y agoIf it's means tested then it's not UBI. Sickness/disability might indeed be a problem, but it's better to address that specific problem, eg. with health care subsidies, rather than reintroducing means testing. Means testing has three major problems: 1. Incentive to game the system. 2. Social stigma to receiving benefits. 3. High administration cost. UBI is the only welfare system that eliminates all three.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Most discussions I've seen of UBI recently have shifted from universal to means tested. If it's means-tested, it's not a UBI; the “U” is ”Unconditional” (less often “Universal”, with the same meaning) indicating that everyone in some defined population gets it without means, needs, or behavior-testing, specifically. > Regardless, wouldn't UBI need to be higher for the sick, elderly, and disabled? With a UBI, existing benefit or social insurance programs that aren't primarily means tested but address other special needs might need to be maintained, including programs offering special support for the aged, blind, and disabled. This is different than a means-tested safety nets, though.
- gaius 9y agoIt can't be means tested, both philosophically - the U - and practically, since to make the numbers work (in the UK at least) you need to also ditch the expensive bureaucracy.
- gehwartzen 9y agoThere is still at least one break point with a UBI since it is payed for by money gained through taxation. While in theory everyone 'gets' the UBI those that pay more than the UBI in taxes effectively just get taxed that amount less. There is a break point where the money you pay in taxes matches the UBI.
- DougWebb 9y agoThat's not a breakpoint, it's a smooth transition. A breakpoint is when you earn $X, and that's low enough to get $Y in welfare. But if you work longer/harder the total amount you get is still $X+$Y because your welfare amount is reduced dollar-for-dollar with your earnings above $X. You don't start to increase your income unless you manage to earn more than $X+$Y entirely on your own. This creates a huge disincentive to earn more than $X, because for most people at that income level the jump to earning $X+$Y seems insurmountable.
- Suncho 9y ago> The question I’m interested in: How do we unlock maximum human potential? > Last I checked, welfare does the opposite of this. It helps people merely subsist, not strive for greatness. It depends what you mean by "human potential." I agree with you that "human potential" is not the right way to frame what basic income unlocks. By giving people money to spend, it unlocks the economy's potential to produce wealth for the people. We won't produce wealth that people won't buy and basic income allows more people to buy more wealth. It also gives people the freedom to choose how they spend their time. We have a lot of pointless jobs in the economy that really only exist as an excuse to provide people incomes. A basic income can allow us to eliminate those jobs. The people who aren't working at those useless jobs anymore are now free to do something useful with their time. So in that sense, basic income does unlock human potential. But by boosting demand and by doing it in a way that flattens out the demand curve, it unlocks resources in general, not just labor. > If he weren't a millionaire and the current president of YC, would we keep seeing articles about his vision on the front page of HN? I don't think so. I don't believe his arguments are that cogent or compelling. I agree with you that his arguments could certainly be more compelling. But he's not wrong that basic income would be a good thing. > If you take Sam Altman out of this article, would we discuss it at all? If the answer to that is no, then why are we discussing it? I would certainly be discussing it. Maybe nobody would be listening to me. But I've been involved with basic income since 2011 and I think it's hugely important.
- disc 9y agoDo you have any links I could peruse that explain how UBI would flatten the demand curve, rather than just shifting it?
- Suncho 9y agoHmm. Not off the top of my head. The intuition is pretty straightforward though. Imagine the difference between doubling total amount of money in the economy by either: a. doubling the amount of money each individual person has. b. distributing that new money evenly across every person. In the former case, the demand curve would get steeper, no? And in the latter case, it would get flatter. In case a, you'd decrease the price elasticity of demand and people would have an incentive to raise prices. You'd have inflation. In case b, you'd increase the price elasticity of demand providing an incentive for producers to keep their prices lower and compete with each other on price. Of course it all depends on where on the demand curve we're talking about. But for many of the goods we produce, their market-clearing prices are at a quantity such that they would benefit from an additional even distribution of income to every person.
- stevens32 9y ago>Last I checked, welfare does the opposite of this. It helps people merely subsist, not strive for greatness. You're not wrong, but UBI isn't exactly welfare - it's more like a blanket grant to pursue whatever it is you'd like. If that's sitting on a couch watching tv - fine, but most everyone would likely bore of that very quickly.
- condercet 9y agoWe're discussing it because many of us think that basic income is one of our best bets to survive the oncoming storm. Sam Altman talking about it is one of the most interesting developments towards actually implementing basic income. Whether this would be good or bad should be open to debate (preferably with evidence), but only two lines in your comment address this.
- crdoconnor 9y agoWhat storm? We're constantly being told that robots can do work better than workers on low wages but evidence presented to support this is very thin.
- condercet 9y ago"evidence presented to support this is very thin" Autonomous cars are on the roads today. They're a ways off from serving as reliable truckers or taxis, but that's in our future. We're seeing rapid advancements in machine learning, especially in computer vision and abstract strategy games. Trucking alone accounts for 5% of the US GDP [1], and employs 1.7 million Americans annually [2]. That's about 1/10 of the total US workforce. Taxi drivers and support staff for trucking are smaller occupations that are also at risk. What happens if all those jobs disappear overnight? Hopefully the people in those jobs will successfully transition to other careers, as many did after the industrial revolution. But it might not be pretty in the short-term. I don't think it's irrational to be concerned about this. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trucking_industry_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trucking_industry_in_the_Unite... 2. https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes533032.htm https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes533032.htm aside: Wikipedia has some nice graphs, but shouldn't be considered reliable. What's the best source of economic and labor data in the US (or other advanced economies), aside from Bureau of Labor Statistics?
- njarboe 9y agoOnly 17 million US workers with a population of 320 million. That can't be right. Maybe 1/100?
- neo4sure 9y ago"Last I checked, welfare does the opposite of this. It helps people merely subsist, not strive for greatness." Do you have an alternative for UBI? If so please provide you theory and factual data to support that will help people "strive for greatness"?
- DoreenMichele 9y agoRather than trying to turn the 99 percent into charity cases and sheeple, I would like to try to foster the next step in the evolution of work so that it is lighter and more flexible and so forth. This is a compendium of some of my previous writings on an alternative to UBI, which boils down to seeing this as the Second Industrial Revolution: http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/p/ir2.html http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/p/ir2.html I am not looking to help people strive for greatness. That is Sam Altman's goal. But what I do try to do is preserve freedom and agency for the poorest of the poor. My first attempt to do that is here: http://sandiegohomelesssurvivalguide.blogspot.com/ http://sandiegohomelesssurvivalguide.blogspot.com/ My current project for trying to help the most vulnerable people around me take control of their lives is here: http://independentdigitalworkers.blogspot.com/ http://independentdigitalworkers.blogspot.com/
- Alex3917 9y ago> Welfare does the opposite of this. It helps people merely subsist, not strive for greatness. I mean the entire United States was founded on the belief that welfare unlocks greatness, because the founding fathers all believed that citizens wouldn't contribute to having a republic unless they shared in the ownership of the means of production. It's not like this is some crazy new experiment, we've been doing this for hundreds of years with everything from cod fisheries in the 1700s, the homestead act in the 1800s, ESOPs in the 1900s, tech startups in the 2000s, etc. Source: https://www.amazon.com/Citizens-Share-Reducing-Inequality-Century/dp/0300209339/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1513212932&sr=8-1&keywords=The+Citizens+Share https://www.amazon.com/Citizens-Share-Reducing-Inequality-Ce...
- ameister14 9y agoRepresentation based on land ownership is close to the opposite of UBI
- Alex3917 9y agoIn the 1700s capital was considered to be land, because owning land was how you made money — either by working the land or by renting it to others to work. Whereas today capital is considered to be mainly money, because owning money is how you make more money. E.g. by investing in Google in the 90s, Bitcoin in the 2000s, etc. So giving people money today is basically the equivalent of giving people land in the 1700 and 1800s.
- ameister14 9y agoSure, if the us govt said "only land owners should vote, so were giving everyone land" you might have a point.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoWhereas today capital is considered to be mainly money No. While money is used simply to purchase goods and services for consumption, capital is more durable and is used to generate wealth through investment. Examples of capital include automobiles, patents, software and brand names. All of these items are inputs that can be used to create wealth. Besides being used in production, capital can be rented out for a monthly or annual fee to create wealth, or it can be sold when it is no longer required. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/capital.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/capital.asp
- danielvf 9y agoThe country of Nauru has had universal income since the 1970’s funded by mining resources. Unfortunately, it has not resulted in human potential being unlocked. Outside the mining, run by foreigners and with foreign works, economic activity in the country has gone down. Nauru now has the highest obesity rate in the world. 94.5% of the population is overweight, 71% obese, and 31% diabetic. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obesity_in_Nauru https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obesity_in_Nauru I agree that some form of UBI looks to be better in many ways to what we have now, we can’t be blind that one actual historical outcome is a nation chronically ill, obese, and unemployed. https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/06/meet-nauru-once-the-worlds-richest-island-now-with-90-unemployment/240639/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/06/meet-na... (2011)
- minikites 9y agoIt's more likely that colonial-style abuses are to blame, here's what happens in a developed nation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mincome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mincome >Mincome was an experimental Canadian guaranteed annual income project that was held in Manitoba, during the 1970s. >University of Manitoba economists Derek Hum and Wayne Simpson analyzed labour supply or work disincentive issues in Mincome during the 1980s and published their results in a series of papers and a monograph.[2][3][4][5] Their results showed a small impact on labour markets, with working hours dropping one percent for men, three percent for married women, and five percent for unmarried women.
- ericd 9y agoCould you please expand on how you think colonialism is to blame? I don't see any suggestion of that in the Wikipedia article.
- bobthechef 9y agoYes, I, too, would be curious. Seems fabricated.
- minikites 9y ago
- guelo 9y ago> Last I checked How did you check? Most research I've seen shows that welfare reduces poverty but does not drag down gdp. Anti-welfare people tend to ignore the positive benefits of entrepreneurs being able to take more risks when they know that a bankruptcy won't be catastrophic and that they could still send their children to school and get treatment when they're sick.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoSuccessful entrepreneurs aren't usually on welfare, they come from great backgrounds (hi Sam, Mark, Bill, Donald...).
- somenewacc 9y agoBeing born on a rich family is akin to being on "welfare" through the years you need most.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoDo you see the difference between living off 1k a month (that's your welfare on BI) and being raised by parents making 150k+? One's a life of poverty and misery, the other is education, opportunity, social connections, etc. People can get the former already on welfare programs. Why don't we divert that 3 trillion we'd spend on BI and spend half of it in targeted ways that actually increase opportunity? ...all of this makes it weird that the biggest proponents of UBI are ultra wealthy. Or, in terms software engineers should understand: why a complete rewrite when there's lots of low hanging bugs that we all know about?
- jpindar 9y ago>the biggest proponents of UBI are ultra wealthy. How do you know? How many poor people have you asked? (P.S. Don't assume that everyone who reads HN is wealthy.)
- pkd 9y agoThis is a very misinformed opinion. Being a rich kid is not at all akin to being on welfare. A sibling comment pointed out the diffrence of money, but there's also a gap in the quality and quantity of opportunities to succeed.
- sjg007 9y ago>I don't think so. I don't believe his arguments are that cogent or compelling. Ok, so how about a counter argument then?
- DoreenMichele 9y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15918718 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15918718
- Diederich 9y ago> Last I checked, welfare does the opposite of this. It helps people merely subsist, not strive for greatness. Citation needed. EDIT: Provided by another comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15918968 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15918968
- csallen 9y ago> The mantra on HN is that ideas matter and that HN wants to deemphasize names and avoid promoting pieces being posted merely because they are about some celebrity. I think these articles fail that test. I disagree. Whatever you think about the quality of his arguments, the fact that the president of Y Combinator is writing about UBI makes it worth discussing for those who care about the topic, because he has significantly more leverage to affect things than most other people writing about it. Similarly, I'd be more interested in reading a poorly conceived piece on nuclear war written by Donald Trump than a brilliantly-crafted article from my nephew.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoDan Gackle, moderator of HN: For the most part, we keep author names out of HN titles. It's a trick I learned from PG for keeping the focus on the content. ---- Name recognition seems to encourage reflexive upvoting, which is one reason we often take names out of titles. We've removed "Alan Kay" from this one. (Nothing personal—we're fans.) ---- But mostly we take the author's/presenter's name out of titles, in keeping with HN's emphasis on content over personalities. https://hn.algolia.com/?query=dang%20names%20titles&sort=byPopularity&prefix&page=0&dateRange=all&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?query=dang%20names%20titles&sort=byP...
- csallen 9y agoI don't have any qualms around taking names out of titles.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoAnd yet here we are discussing an article with Sam Altman's name in the title, as is rather often the case on the topic of UBI, and you essentially arguing that this is a good thing.
- csallen 9y agoI suspect we'd be discussing this article even if Sam Altman's name wasn't in the title. EDIT: Also, I wouldn't say that it's necessarily a good thing that we're discussing this. Moreso, my point is that the value of a piece of writing isn't completely disconnected from who wrote it, nor should it be.
- ben_jones 9y agoI mean we shouldn't kid ourselves, this forum is maintained, and funded, because it is of financial benefit to YC (in many different ways). Not because of some higher ideal.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI have zero problem with HN being of financial benefit to YC. In fact, I have repeatedly said that I think this is exactly why it is able to sustain a standard of excellence. HN becoming the personal platform for the new YC president's political aspirations and personal pet social theories does not appear to me to be of any financial benefit to YC.
- alexasmyths 9y agoYou gotta understand - in tech - a company's brand value is important for early adopters and legitimacy. Part of that brand has to be 'benevolence'. In tech, it's important to be seen as 'the good guys'. 'We're on a cause to help, the money is secondary' - is the basis for a SV company brand. Understand that the materiality of the benevolence is irrelevant. Only the perception. The soon to be Princess Merkle (or whatever) and Angelina Jolie spend a little bit of time making speeches written for them - and all of a sudden they are 'amazing, altruistic people' - irrespective of their actual commitment. And it's bizarre how intelligent people eat it up and believe it. We ignore the middle aged lady down the street who volunteers at the Salvation Army two days a week about it and doesn't say a peep about it, doesn't put it on her resume. So the dissonance between the 'reality' of some way to help and the words of the auteur don't really matter that much. I don't entirely believe this is just all for show or disingenuous, but I do also believe that it's part of the resume building elements of individuals and organizations. Remember Google's original premise was to do something about 'ads that were destroying the internet' and to 'do no evil'. This PR and brand positioning - even if everyone on the inside has fully drunk the kool-aid and believes it to be true. In fact, it works better when founders drink their own kool-aid. But to say that YC is doing more good for humanity than Airbus ... is debatable. Just some very minor legislation that changed how drugs and medical services are priced ... could yield some pretty big social change in terms of quality of access etc.. So we don't want to be too cynical, just enough to recognize that public figures calling for some moral thing usually have something indirect to gain from it personally.
- lodi 9y ago> Remember Google's original premise was to do something about 'ads that were destroying the internet' and to 'do no evil'. Well, during that time they did replace the obnoxious flash/gif ads of the day with unobtrusive text ads, and iirc mostly did no evil. > We ignore the middle aged lady down the street who volunteers at the Salvation Army two days a week about it and doesn't say a peep about it, doesn't put it on her resume. The problem with silent altruism of this sort is that Angelina Jolie donating a few million to some cause will be less effective (in her particular situation) to that cause than Angelina Jolie donating a few million and also running a social media blitz to raise another few million from fans. I understand that as a side effect she might become more popular, which might lead to more lucrative movie contracts, etc. But I wouldn't even begin to be cynical about this until it was pretty conclusively demonstrated that her net benefit (from increased popularity, or whatever) actually exceeded her own interest (e.g. what some despicable televangelists do.)
- loceng 9y agoThe way I view something like YC similar to basic income is that equity or a dividend from equity owned is like taxes being paid. The important things have to be very clearly defined in order to make a fair judgement call on any plans/experiments that people want to try.
- Techn0logist 9y agoHow does welfare possibly hold people back when they're required to look for a job on it? Someone who risks homelessness may have more incentive to find a job, but they're also going to have more difficulties. It's easier to look for a job on a full stomach; it's easier to look for a job with a roof over your head; it's easier to look for a job with internet access; it's easier to look for a job when you're not constantly worried about losing it all. Welfare gives you a stable place from which to find employment. If your argument is that people abuse the position of welfare, and don't look for a job, then that's a criticism of its enforcement, not welfare itself.
- apatters 9y agoSeriously. Everything Sam says on this topic makes me question whether he actually knows any of the people that UBI supposedly would do the most good for -- the poor, the working class, people whose jobs have been automated away, etc. Does he have any friends from these walks of life? Drinking buddies down at the local pub maybe? How much of his time has he spent actually listening to them talk, befriending them, earning their trust? I have many friends and acquaintances who have nothing to do with the tech industry, come from meager means and never rose above those means (economically speaking). Many of these people just aren't ambitious. They have no interest in unlocking their "maximum potential." And there's nothing wrong with that. They're just not wired the way that tech industry hyperachievers are. Maybe they don't care a lot about money, maybe they're risk averse, maybe they don't understand how business works and find it boring. Some are stuck in a rut, but some have simply carved out a little routine which may seem unfulfilling to you but it works for them. These people will probably accept UBI if you offer it to them but UBI emphatically will not motivate the majority of them to become the next startup founder. Or anything other than what they are now. I'm guessing Sam (like many on HN) lives in a bubble of hyperachievers and the people in this bubble have a really hard time understanding that most of the world isn't like them, and doesn't want to be. YC applicants are nothing like the general population. A lot of people just want to coast. And there's nothing wrong with those people.
- GeneralMayhem 9y ago>Many of these people just aren't ambitious. They have no interest in unlocking their "maximum potential." Most people don't have time to be ambitious because they're too busy subsisting. If the subsistence were taken care of, wouldn't you expect them to do better? Not everyone will suddenly start a billion-dollar endeavor, but they'd have more time for recreation, learning, political engagement, and yes, maybe even economic entrepreneurship - in other words, being their best selves, even if for some individuals that still isn't all that impressive.
- isoskeles 9y ago> Not everyone will suddenly start a billion-dollar endeavor, but they'd have more time for recreation, learning, political engagement, and yes, maybe even economic entrepreneurship - in other words, being their best selves, even if for some individuals that still isn't all that impressive. Or they'd have more time for Call of Duty and Netflix. Seriously, not everyone aspires to be their "best" self per the definition here of overachiever in multiple endeavors. It might seem inconceivable, but there are many people who have no interest in being the best any of those things. Interestingly absent from these laundry lists of things to be best at: parent, friend, spouse.