4 ms·
Sam makes an interesting analogy with Y Combinator as providing a form of "basic income" to people trying to start startups. However, this analogy ignores a hug
by pdonis 9y ago
Sam makes an interesting analogy with Y Combinator as providing a form of "basic income" to people trying to start startups. However, this analogy ignores a huge difference in the two cases: the people who are trying to start startups with Y Combinator's help are a highly self-selected group. Giving them "basic income" often turns out to be highly productive, yes. But that does not imply that giving basic income to everybody would turn out to be highly productive.
To be fair, he does describe what he's attempting as an "experiment" and acknowledges that it might not work out the way he thinks.
- chrishacken 9y ago"Sam makes an interesting analogy with Y Combinator as providing a form of "basic income" to people trying to start startups. " These two things aren't even close to the same thing. If Y Combinator accepted every single applicant, than yes, it would be equivalent to UBI. They obviously do not.
- pdonis 9y ago> These two things aren't even close to the same thing. Tell that to Sam, not me. He made the analogy.
- chrishacken 9y agoI know, I was just agreeing with you.
- creaghpatr 9y agoAlso when a startup burns out their runway it dies and investors probably won't fund the same idea twice. What happens to the people who blow their UBI on drugs/gambling etc instead of healthcare and prosperity. Who will pay to re-fund them? (and fund them again?)
- skybrian 9y agoMy guess is that it would be handled the same as senior citizens who gamble or drink. Next month another check arrives, same as usual. But who worries about this, or would consider cutting social security due to drinking or gambling?
- pdonis 9y ago> who worries about this, or would consider cutting social security due to drinking or gambling? We don't consider that because we maintain the polite assumption that people get paid from social security after they retire because they paid into it while they were working. There are plenty of cases where that's not true, but we allow ourselves to treat them as outliers, and assume that the money people get from social security is basically "their" money; the government just saved it for them. UBI removes the option to think of things this way. I think a lot of UBI proponents have not fully considered the implications of that.
- skybrian 9y agoPart of the point of UBI is to confront this "if you don't work, you can't eat" attitude head-on, and change it to one where all citizens deserve a certain amount of money (however small, to start) just for being people who stay out of trouble. It's an uphill battle to be sure.
- pdonis 9y ago> this "if you don't work, you can't eat" attitude It's not an "attitude", it's a fact of life. In order for you to eat, a certain amount of work has to be done. Why should someone else do it if you're perfectly capable? We've already made it a lot easier for you by having a huge economy where you can do all sorts of things that can be traded for food, instead of having to grow all your own food yourself. The attitude that really needs to be confronted is that the amount of work that needs to be done by some human in order for that human to eat is fixed. It isn't; technology can reduce it. (And in fact it already has, by quite a lot; that's why only about one in twenty people has to work at growing food today, compared with about 19 in 20 a couple of centuries ago.) But there are huge political barriers to technology reducing it further: governments meddle in all kinds of ways that artificially inflate the cost of getting enough food and other necessities. What we really need to do is stop doing that, so entrepreneurs like Sam Altman can use technology to make necessities so cheap that nobody will have to worry about UBI, because anyone who isn't actually disabled or otherwise incapable will be able to earn a living.