2 ms·
> I have thrown a dozen or so darts, and my rate seems to be around 80%. The odds of that happening by chance are <50% but still quite high, about 6-7% dependi
by lisper 9y ago
> I have thrown a dozen or so darts, and my rate seems to be around 80%.
The odds of that happening by chance are <50% but still quite high, about 6-7% depending on exactly how you reckon it. So one person in 15 will get this result purely by chance.
There are studies that show that very few (like <<1%) professional money managers can beat the market consistently. You may well be one of those rare people, in which case you could make billions on Wall Street. But until you amass a much longer track record than you have, the odds are much higher that you are just one of the lucky ones. There are a lot more lucky people out there than most people realize.
- Simon_says 9y agoYea, all that's true, but Eli has a significantly easier job. A professional manager has to make a lot of decisions and still has to invest money even if they don't have any insightful ideas. On the other hand Eli will only invest if he gets a good idea, and if not, then no investment.
- lisper 9y agoThat's no excuse. Eli can always park his undeployed capital in an index fund. So if he can consistently pick winners 80% of the time he'll still beat the market even if he has fallow periods.
- Simon_says 9y agoExcuse for what? Of course Eli can do that, and it has nothing to do with my point.
- lisper 9y agoExcuse for not taking his (alleged) talent to Wall Street and making billions of dollars. > it has nothing to do with my point which was: > A professional manager has to make a lot of decisions and still has to invest money even if they don't have any insightful ideas. Implying that Eli's talents could not be deployed on Wall Street because he could not operate under the constraints on which professional money managers have to operate. But that's not true.
- EliRivers 9y agoAs long as people don't mind me waiting 18 months between trades, and not trading amounts remotely large enough to have any effect on the market, sure. Professionals do have a much harder job of it. As Simon says, they can't sit on their hands for 18 months like I do. I expect if they parked most of the money in an index fund, their customers would start asking why they're paying managed fund rates for an index fund. Might as well go on the record here, and come back in a year to see how I did. I'm considering UK pizza chains and the like; as the UK gets poorer, and people have less money to spend, the money that used to go on eating out drifts downwards into takeaway pizza and the like. All the signs are that the people of the UK are going to have less money and be faced with higher prices, so I'll look for a pizza chain or similar to invest in.