6 ms·
Twitter was filled with screenshots of people removing their $1 pledges. It wouldn’t surprise me if the rollback of the new model was motivated more by economic
by minimaxir 9y ago
Twitter was filled with screenshots of people removing their $1 pledges. It wouldn’t surprise me if the rollback of the new model was motivated more by economics than PR, where the forecasted revenue under the new model (accounting for loss rate of subscribers) was lower than the forecasted revenue under the old model.
- pjc50 9y agoWell, those things are inseperable in this day and age, especially for a company that depends on internet communities. It's astonishing how a company with one product could misunderstand its own market so badly, but given the troubles of Twitter and to a lesser extent Etsy perhaps it's less surprising.
- amluto 9y agoEspecially Patreon. Patreon more or less takes people's money in exchange for warm fuzzy feelings. If they piss off their users, the users get less warm fuzzy feelings, and they'll stop buying.
- xfkechyk 9y agoin exchange for warm fuzzy feelings? wtf are you talking about?
- omegaham 9y ago"I'm voluntarily contributing a small piece to a body of work that I love and want to see more of." I suppose that can be construed as a warm fuzzy feeling.
- xfkechyk 9y agothat's a weird way to summarize the purchase of art and entertainment, but i guess it's technically accurate.
- AndyNemmity 9y agoIt isn't a purchase of art and entertainment. At least all the Patreons I supported were free content.
- zimpenfish 9y agoThere's many which aren't free content or which have content locked off for higher tier patrons. There's many which are "exclusive for patrons for [X time]" too.
- manigandham 9y agoYou're not purchasing anything, Patreon is about patronage, as in donating/supporting with no expectation. Whether you get something is completely up to the creator to do.
- duncan_bayne 9y agoYou're most definitely purchasing something. It's just not a tangible good or service.
- alexeldeib 9y agoWarm fuzzy feeling, one might contend :)
- hrktb 9y agoThat’s the warm and fuzzy part ? I read you want to put weight on how the very fact of giving or retracting donations messages an expectation to the creator and creates a kind of defacto commercial relationship. But honestly I see it the other way round, where creators on patreons have already put something out in the world, and donations come after the fact. There is an expectation that they go on creating, but if they said “fuck it I can’t do it anymore” I won’t be running after them to ask for my money back; I already got my warm and fuzzy feelings, the deal is closed on my side.
- aninhumer 9y agoIt's more than that though, you're paying for that artist to be able to create. In most cases, if people stopped paying, the artist would have to stop creating, or at least reduce the time they spend creating, so they could find alternative income sources. Just because there's no defined benefit or exclusivity doesn't mean all you're paying for is "fuzzy feelings".
- rockarage 9y agoNot so astonishing, when you understand the business of venture capital. When you raise too much venture capital and try to grow faster than the market dictates, this sort poor decision making tends to happen.
- stcredzero 9y agoWell, those things are inseperable in this day and age, especially for a company that depends on internet communities. "Voting with your wallet." Or to paraphrase the way Polonius put it in Hamlet, one of the key differences between sane and insane is what people do with their money.
- sombremesa 9y agoVine actually died because of this.
- thinkloop 9y agoInteresting, how is that?
- tdsamardzhiev 9y ago“Misunderstand”? Yeah, right. They knew most donations are $1, and just wanted a bigger part of the pie. If they were out to solve a problem, they’d just do this for transactions say $10 and above. Nay, Patreon knew very well what they’re trying to do, and seeing it fail, decided to use the “play dumb” card.
- fleitz 9y agoYeah the pool of people who believe $1 is somehow a significant source of rev
- jopsen 9y agoThey certainly can't say they didn't have time to think this over.. so yeah.. On the other hand, it's possible that most of thevø revenue does come from 1$ donations, and they didn't understand how much creators desired having many pateons vs. few high paying patreons.
- gbhn 9y agoThis is what I told them in the survey. I'm a newbie to the platform, and I understand the value proposition better than the owner?! That's really screwed up, and it will take quite a while before I trust them. I still kind of think creators should take their accounts elsewhere. How can a group of people just not understand their own product so thoroughly? Baffling. Is there any precedent for people so badly confused able to learn which end is up? It really makes me suspect the company and its users just have irreconcilably different ideas about what is going on.
- _fool 9y agoIs there an elsewhere for creators to take their accounts? I give via patreon because it is the only platform I'm aware of that exists that anyone really uses in this way. I give to some creators via their own systems - but as far as a generally accepted mass market solution - I'm interested in hearing about others but don't know them yet.
- asdjasldkjkljd 9y agoWhy not both
- arkades 9y agoI wonder how many creators they lost, too. At least one guy I follow, who makes rpg scenarios, said “screw it” - all future scenarios would go to drivethrurpg, and patreon backers would get discount codes appropriate to their backing level. He kept patreon as a notification platform, and drove —all- his revenue to an alternate channel.
- vanderZwan 9y agoSame with a webcomic creator I know. He basically stated "I do this as a side-job and have a steady income, please move your pledges for me to the creators you support that depend on Patreon for their income." Wonder if he's still leaving.
- XR0CSWV3h3kZWg 9y agoNothing like voting with your wallet.
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 9y agoAbsolutely. I told anyone that would listen to cancel everything because I feared that would be the only effective method.
- razster 9y agoLike the new Coke recipes? Then the introduction to the original recipes.