6 ms·
Harvey Weinstein Is My Monster Too
- fbgugli 9y agoPeople, dont be fooled by media. He aint the worst. He did not use under age people, like many other in hollywood apparently does. NyTimes, Why your articles are so fake ?
- mfoy_ 9y agoSo much damage done to so many people in so many ways... ugh.
- abritinthebay 9y agoWow. An incredibly frank and honest article from Salma. It underscores that the problem in these situations for women isn’t just assault - it’s a sexualized power that has expectations. It’s disgusting and Weinstein should be rightly vilified for what he has done; let’s not forget that he’s a symptom of a larger societal problem however.
- vkou 9y agoWe do forget it. Half of Alabama voted for a Weinstein as a Senator the other day.
- anon11082016 9y agoSo did half a country https://m.imgur.com/gallery/5kcWk https://m.imgur.com/gallery/5kcWk
- alexashka 9y agoWhat larger societal problem is that? I think if you took 10 random people, they'd give you 10 different answers.
- smacktoward 9y agoThe societal problem that men with power feel that it's acceptable to use that power to pressure women to give them what they want sexually. (And the related problem of bystanders witnessing this behavior and failing to push back hard against it.)
- alexashka 9y agoAlright. Another person comes to you and says, the larger societal problem is that ambitious people will ignore or put up with a world of shit as long as they get what they are after. Who's right? To elaborate - Salma's ambition was to make the movie, she could've quit 100 times, but instead she put up with 100 cases of sexual harassment (100 being an artbirary large number here) Harvey's ambition was to have sexual relations with every woman that needed him to do something for her, that he found attractive. He ignored everyone else's needs but his own in the process of fulfilling his ambition. Seeing it from the angle of ambition, both people could've done things differently but didn't, because they were preoccupied with achieving their goals, more than achieving let's say... harmony in themselves and the world... Is that the larger societal problem? That our ambitions are small and selfish?
- vmnieowan873 9y agoEquating Salma's ambition here (make a movie about an important minority historical figure) with Harvey's and then calling it small and selfish? Seriously?
- owebmaster 9y agoWould you encourage every women to complain about sexual harassment before they get the benefits they're looking for? Sexual services are considered crime for a reason, but it's not really enforced.
- orionblastar 9y agoIt can only be enforced if it is reported to the police and they gather evidence in a timely manner. Like any other crime. If there is no proof or evidence, the trial won't go the way you think it will.
- mkempe 9y agoWeinstein's course of action is a personal choice and responsibility. It is absurd to infer or assert collective guilt, or to ascribe some sort of original/social sin to "society." What he did is his individual vice; it is simply not a "larger social problem." Any other man who raped or otherwise assaulted women is similarly responsible for his own actions, and should be punished accordingly.
- Floegipoky 9y agoHis abuse was a personal decision, but it wasn't made in isolation. The behavior that Hayek described doesn't fit into the traditional model of sexual misconduct. He didn't physically force himself on her, instead he used his power to emotionally degrade and control her. And that's the point- the traditional model of abuse utterly fails to protect victims. There's a reason the word "complicit" is so popular right now; abusers rely on a support network to minimize and cover up their actions. This network begins with knowledgable persons who turn a blind eye (like Tarantino) but extends all the way out to those who victim-shame on social media. And the fact that so many women suffer sexual abuse and so few abusers are held accountable shows that it is absolutely a larger social problem. "Isolated incidents" that affect 1/6 of a population must be viewed systemically. https://www.rainn.org/sites/default/files/Out_Of_1000_Rapes%20122016.png https://www.rainn.org/sites/default/files/Out_Of_1000_Rapes%... http://www.11thprincipleconsent.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Rape-Culture-v4.png http://www.11thprincipleconsent.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/...
- abritinthebay 9y agoYes, absolutely Weinstein made that choice. That he was comfortable making that choice, that it was seen as normal or just something that happened, that women felt their careers would be in jeopardy if they spoke up, that demanding additional sex scenes at the last minute wasn’t laughed off the lot... ... these are all symptoms of the broader social normalization of his abuse of power. This year has been a turning point for pointing out it exists and some consequences for the individuals who do it... but it’s barely scratched the surface
- ashwinpp 9y agoCurious about why this article went missing from the first few pages in a few minutes it took me to read it. Is it by design or intervention and if intervention then the rationale for it. I found the article to be underscoring in detail the modus operandi of sexual harassment in the film industry (and workspaces in general) and adds a fair amount of interesting thoughts to my mind about the functioning of society and inherent oppression within.
- klenwell 9y agoI noticed the same thing. Right now it's near the top of the second page. But at 90 upvotes in less than an hour, it appears it should be solidly on the front page. My educated guess: lots of downvotes pushing it down, a fact (more cruel perhaps than ironic) consistent with the points Salma Hayek is making in her article.
- dominotw 9y ago>My educated guess: lots of downvotes pushing it down, a fact (more cruel perhaps than ironic) consistent with the points Salma Hayek is making in her article. You cannot downvote a submission, just comments.
- dragonwriter 9y agoIIRC, submission flags act like downvotes before reaching the threshold where the entry is killed, so this is essentially a distinction without a difference.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- smacktoward 9y agoIt's now flagged as "[flagged]", so I guess we know the answer to this question. Sigh. HN is so disappointing sometimes.
- vmnieowan873 9y agoAnyone who thinks, "a little nudity in a movie is harmless" needs to read this.
- dragonwriter 9y agoSo, I read it, and it doesn't say anything to indicate that nudity (whether a little or a lot) in a movie is harmful, but that the particular nudity in this particular movie wasn't the product of the creators artistic vision but power plays by a funder, and that the harmful stemmed explocitly from the manipulative personal power dynamics, not the nudity.
- vmnieowan873 9y agoYes, this was probably a very isolated incident. Keep telling yourself that.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Yes, this was probably a very isolated incident. That's not the issue; the harm—and the article explicitly says this—wasn’t the “nudity in a movie”. I’m sure this isn't an isolated incident, either for Wienstein or more generally. But Hayek has done a fair amount of nude work for a mainstream actress, so when she explicitly points to the source of the problem and says it's not the fact of doing nude work for a film, I wonder why your so desperate to recast it as being about nudity in film.
- vmnieowan873 9y agoWe are talking about sexual harassment here. How could nudity not be the problem? The fact that nudity in film is common allowed Harvey the pretense to demand full-frontal nudity, "the senseless scene," as Hayek described it. The point I'm trying to make, apparently too subtly, is, how many nude scenes were coerced just like Hayek describes the one in Frida in order to satisfy the lusts of the male director/producer/writer just like this? It doesn't seem far-fetched, with all the revelations of sexual harassment coming out, that it's a lot of them. Maybe it's so many that we should simply not tolerate nudity in films. If there was some way to certify that the nude scene wasn't "forced" then it would be OK, but if we accept that this was an act of force on Weinstein's part (Salma could have chosen not to do the movie, yet we all seem to agree this was still evil on the part of Weinstein), then how could that certification ever be done?
- JBlue42 9y agoGuy seems to fit every characteristic of a psychopath. Glad he's finally been taken out of power and society.
- agnivade 9y agoWhat is the reason for this to be flagged ?
- gspetr 9y agoSince not everyone regularly submits to HN, I think reposting the link from the footer is relevant: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html "Hacker News Guidelines What to Submit On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity. Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Ideological or political battle or talking points. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic." This isn't anything groundbreaking as Harvey was already exposed, this is just another data point.