6 ms·
Jeez. I had not thought the Macron government to be so backwards. IMHO there are two issues at place: 1. teachers not adapting to new times. In ye olde days, t
by mschuster91 9y ago
Jeez. I had not thought the Macron government to be so backwards. IMHO there are two issues at place:
1. teachers not adapting to new times. In ye olde days, teachers had the attention of the students basically guaranteed (as the only thing students could do instead of paying attention to the teacher was drawing messages on papers and passing them around). That frontal instruction is bullshit and should be a thing of the past could be ignored. Now, however, teachers have to compete with the Internet for the attention of the students - but instead of embracing the change and throw some rotten traditions over board, they ban phones. LOL.
2. Mobbing/cyberbullying. I can understand that schools want to tackle this problem, but banning smartphones is a symbolic measure. The students will still use closed Whatsapp/FB/whatever groups after school, without the school being able to interfere in any way. Proper prevention measures, like teaching the students what the effects of social media can be, provide counseling, social workers, etc. - all that costs money, a lot of it. And so politicians rather ban smartphones so that the (rightfully) concerned parents shut up without having to spend huge sums of money.
- gruez 9y ago> Now, however, teachers have to compete with the Internet for the attention of the students - but instead of embracing the change and throw some rotten traditions over board, they ban phones. LOL. how can the average teacher compete with social networking sites that have been engineered specifically to maximize engagement?
- 1_2__4 9y agoLOL indeed. Your (poor) argument could be used to justify televisions running in the classroom 24x7 too, just to shake loose that awful "frontal instruction".
- Shivetya 9y agowith regards to point #1, not all students have access to such phones. the only solution to your point I see is to insure they all have them. teachers can not change unless all students can go along for the change, hence how do we remedy that? teachers should not have to compete for a child's attention nor have to prevent a child from being a distraction to others in class. I do think a total ban is ridiculous, play ground time and lunch time should be more than allowable use periods. I don't recall point #2 being covered, perhaps that is elsewhere in French media that was not brought up and should have been.
- bzbarsky 9y ago> as the only thing students could do instead of paying attention to the teacher was drawing messages on papers and passing them around Or playing battleship (or any of a huge number of other pencil-and-paper games). Or reading under the desk. Or throwing spitballs. Or doing their nails. I'm not sure whether you lived through ye olde days, but there were _tons_ of things you could do if you wanted to ignore the teacher.
- ksk 9y ago1. This isn't a eBooks versus dead-tree books thing. The school has certain conditions so that you don't create a disruptive atmosphere. You can't bring a giant boombox and play loud EDM music either. Smartphones contribute to disruption too, as well has reduced attention spans and alertness. This why you don't text and drive. Not because its a "rotten tradition". If a parent thinks a child can do better on their own with a smartphone, then by all means, homeschooling is an option too. Not being sarcastic here. 2. Sounds defeatist. Which solution are you in favor of? Where has it been implemented and what were the results?
- ashark 9y ago> 1. teachers not adapting to new times. In ye olde days, teachers had the attention of the students basically guaranteed (as the only thing students could do instead of paying attention to the teacher was drawing messages on papers and passing them around). That frontal instruction is bullshit and should be a thing of the past could be ignored. Now, however, teachers have to compete with the Internet for the attention of the students - but instead of embracing the change and throw some rotten traditions over board, they ban phones. LOL. What? We had Gameboys. Electronic football, before that. Guess what? You couldn't take them to school, or you'd (at least temporarily) lose them, if anyone saw you.