5 ms·
Nothing of value is being created, at least not of the magnitude of the apparent “value” of the bubble, so making money off bitcoin is by definition getting mon
by kgwgk 9y ago
Nothing of value is being created, at least not of the magnitude of the apparent “value” of the bubble, so making money off bitcoin is by definition getting money from someone else. Clearly it cannot work forever, and those who are left holding the bag won’t be happy.
- pixelpoet 9y ago> Nothing of value is being created Just like the entire financial services industry, and yet that gets a pass to wreck the world economy on the reg. It's fine to bail out rich bankers, but normal people? Nooo way can we risk that! Smells like the global elite getting scared of power shift, and telling their lawmaker cronies to get on top of it ASAP.
- dqpb 9y agoFor an “infrastructure” that burns dozens of terawatts of power per year I would at least expect fast transactions, and yet...
- ethanwillis 9y agoMFW it takes up to two weeks for an international wire transfer to clear. MFW banks are closed on Sundays.
- UncleMeat 9y agoHow many international wire transfers does a typical person make in their life?
- eberkund 9y agoI've made a few, but ironically they were all to the bank accounts of cryptocurrency exchanges when I was funding my account.
- pjc50 9y agoThere's this thing called the internet which lets you make transactions even when your bank is closed. Also, for most purposes it's safer to do credit card purchases than international wires.
- paulmd 9y agoWhy do you need to send a wire transfer? A giro transfer clears within a few minutes, and a credit card charge is accepted within seconds. What's the use-case that is not acceptably covered by those options?
- milcron 9y agoI'd never heard of a giro transfer. In the states we use ACH and it takes 2-5 days to clear. The ACH numbers are also reusable - your numbers never change, and they can be used for withdrawal as well as deposit.
- paulmd 9y agoMy point is that this a solved problem worldwide, ACH is slow and inefficient, and checking just piggybacks on ACH. It's not normal for bank-to-bank transfers to take two weeks to clear in TYOOL 2017. This is a US problem.
- KasianFranks 9y agoYou mean like stocks and all other derivatives and equities including the US dollar and other currencies on Forex. Smart.
- arcticfox 9y agoExcept stocks represent ownership in real companies making real products. If one person owns 100% of a company and there is zero trading, it's still an extremely valuable property. If one person owns 100% of a crypto, it is worthless.
- KasianFranks 9y agohttps://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/storystock.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/storystock.asp not to mention the public company manipulations, scams and out right fleecing of investors.
- nybble41 9y ago> Except stocks represent ownership in real companies making real products. But what does that mean in practical terms? Sure, if the company gets bought out you might get some cash, and some companies still pay dividends. Aside from those cases, though, shareholders have no direct claim on the company's assets, and only the largest shareholders have significant influence on the company's board. Most profits made by shareholders come from selling their shares to another investor, not from the company itself. > If one person owns 100% of a company and there is zero trading, it's still an extremely valuable property. Assuming the company is solvent... plenty are not, despite a positive stock price. They are trading on the expectation of future improvement, not present value. > If one person owns 100% of a crypto, it is worthless. Every cryptocurrency (every non-commodity currency, for that matter) starts out owned 100% by someone. That doesn't make them all worthless. Say I create a new currency with one million units, wholly owned by myself. If I stop there, no one else will value my currency. However, say I also arrange to sell widgets (standard market value $100) in exchange for 100 units of my new currency. Now my currency has value, and people who want widgets may well be willing to trade other goods or services for it—perhaps not 1:1, due to the lower marketability, but at some discounted ratio. This makes more goods available; people who have no need of my widgets may still transact business using my currency and accept it as payment. At this point I no longer possess 100% of my new currency and it has taken on a life (and market value) of its own. Even if I stopped producing widgets the currency may well remain in circulation as a marketable commodity.
- neuro_imager 9y agoI admire the certainty of the naysayers on this thread. I only wish I could borrow their crystal ball.
- jsutton 9y agoWhen you write a program/app/website and someone uses it, is there nothing of value created?