4 ms·
Has this become standardized yet? I've got a bunch of multi-drop CAN stuff that I would LOVE to move over to single pair ethernet with multi-drop a la 10BASE2.
by bsder 9y ago
Has this become standardized yet? I've got a bunch of multi-drop CAN stuff that I would LOVE to move over to single pair ethernet with multi-drop a la 10BASE2. Unfortunately I haven't see a 10BASE2 compatible PHY in 20+ years.
IEEE had a working group on this but I hadn't seen any actually shipping chips that mortals could get their hands on.
(Edit: Apparently still vapor. Still can't find a source for the Marvell 88Q1010 & 88Q2112.)
(Edit: Only thing available seems to be this which is almost certainly some gigantic FPGA solution ... https://beyondstandards.ieee.org/connected-vehicles/intrepid-rad-supermoon-first-1000base-t1-media-converter-avbtsn-support/ https://beyondstandards.ieee.org/connected-vehicles/intrepid...)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- voxadam 9y agoWhat are your bandwidth and latency requirement? More than once I've pondered 6LoWPAN over RS485 using token passing.
- bsder 9y agoMy biggest problem is software stack performance--not physical layer performance. Most protocol stacks in the embedded space other than TCP/IP are mind-blowingly bad. Being able to obliterate USB, CAN, and RS-232 (to a lesser degree--RS-232 is really reliable but the problem is generally in frequency drift if you don't have a crystal anywhere) in all of my designs and replacing it with ethernet will dramatically improve the reliability of my hardware. The only places I don't currently have ethernet in my designs are where I'm limited to a single pair of wires. As for RS485, it doesn't really offer me anything that I don't already get with CAN.
- IgorPartola 9y agoWhat do you work on?
- bsder 9y agoLots of industrial stuff related to various types of testing. Performance matters some, but I'm not hard real-time. However, everything has to work, reliably, in less than ideal environments--mostly high-voltage spikes caused by differences in ground potentials. USB is a PITA because while data is differential, connection detection is not. So, spikes cause USB disconnects and drivers never cope with that. CAN is a PITA because it is limited to 8-bytes per message. Good for transducers and 8 bit microcontrollers--not so good for complex control and 32-bit microcontrollers. Ethernet hits a really great sweet spot of fully-differential and nice single packet size for a 32-bit microcontroller--program like it's 1989, baby.
- voxadam 9y agoI absolutely agree that Ethernet is ideal and the correct solution for modern systems. Have you worked with EtherCAT at all?
- zbrozek 9y agoIf you're OK with 100 mbps point-to-point over a single wire pair, there's stuff like the TJA1100[1]. 10Base-T1 might be a real thing someday. You might just want RS-485. [1] https://www.nxp.com/docs/en/data-sheet/TJA1100.pdf https://www.nxp.com/docs/en/data-sheet/TJA1100.pdf