3 ms·
There isn't enough good science. If you look at the historic record (a million years or so) you'll see glaciations and interglacial periods. One thing we should
by phkahler 9y ago
There isn't enough good science. If you look at the historic record (a million years or so) you'll see glaciations and interglacial periods. One thing we should expect is a new round of glaciation if nothing changes. But it's not time for that yet. A simple google for "interglacial high water mark" yielded this:
https://www.amnh.org/exhibitions/climate-change/changing-ice/high-water-mark https://www.amnh.org/exhibitions/climate-change/changing-ice...
Which indicates that sea levels have historically been several feet higher than they are today during the interglacials. There is no data on the exact temperature profile over short (100 year) historic time scales.
We have evidence of data tampering - i.e. a climate model that showed the "hockey stick" regardless of what the input data was. It's a highly politicized thing.
And lastly, if I accept climate change as a result of human activity I say we still don't have decent models. We need to accurately account for the effect of contrails. There is significant evidence that this matters. There is correlation between temperature rises and the increase in air traffic. It may not be "carbon" but "water vapor" that is the cause.
I find these things interesting, but the headlines and stories are all very alarmist. Look at this fine article we're talking about. The data isn't all that interesting, it's just that it tripped a plausibility check someone implemented, and we don't know what the stated requirements for the check were.
- gerdesj 9y ago"There isn't enough good science." ... and yet you quote some rather good science wrt glaciation periods etc (I doubt you did it yourself) The thing is that we live at the moment as we are with the world as it is. For example if the sea level rose say 1m (4 feet), what would that do to say FL which is rather low lying? The weather will continue to get wilder and wilder. I happen to live on the side of a hill in Yeovil, Somerset, UK (I'm alright, probably). Somerset has a low lying region called the Levels and recently they flooded badly - that will happen more often. We have a lot of data and a lot of papers and a lot of models that predict a nasty end. Your "hockey stick" example is bollocks - the paper was sound but the interpretation by some was not. The ridiculous thing is that although no one with a scientific bent has mentioned it, have you noticed just how odd the weather has been over the last decade? Records for hot and cold and wet etc are being broken "since records began" quite often. "And lastly, if I accept climate change as a result of human activity I say we still don't have decent models." Have you done any research on this whatsoever?
- apple4ever 9y ago> Have you done any research on this whatsoever? Have you? The models are all terrible. They can't even output matching observed data!
- xupybd 9y ago>Have you done any research on this whatsoever? I think it's fair to say climate models are modelling a very complex, near chaotic, system. One of the difficulties with this subject is understanding and verifying these models is simply impossible for the lay person. I don't think it's fair to accuse someone of a lack of research. It's possible to study this very in depth and still lack the ability to assess if the models are correct.
- gerdesj 9y agoYou get a UV for diving in and being reasonable. I'll put money on you being one of my compatriots and probably know rather more than me on this subject.
- StanislavPetrov 9y ago>I think it's fair to say climate models are modelling a very complex, near chaotic, system. That's exactly the point. I don't think we should be pumping carbon (or any other adulterants) in to our environment. But remaining skeptical of the claims of climatologists who can't reliably predict the weather 5 days into the future while claiming the ability to definitively predict the weather 5 years (and longer) into the future does not make you a "climate change denier". I have very little doubt that the destruction we are wreaking on the environment (of which carbon pollution is a tiny part) will end poorly for us. Its fine to speculate on how exactly this blowback will manifest itself but hubris to claim to know with certainty.
- greglindahl 9y agoThere were claims of evidence tampering; later research using different methods of measuring global temperature showed ... a hockey stick. That's the nice thing about science: there are often multiple ways of confirming many results. For example, see the post-2010 studies mentioned in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hockey_stick_graph#2010_onwards https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hockey_stick_graph#2010_onward... ... hockey sticks galore.
- phkahler 9y agoOther models showing the hockey stick does not negate the fact (??) that someone else made a rigged model to show a hockey stick. The point of bringing up the bad model isn't to refute climate change, it's to show that people will go to great lengths to "prove" climate change regardless of the data. It's a statement about politics invading science. Something we need to be acutely aware of when trying to address problems at a global level. note: the ?? above is to indicate my own uncertainty about the rigged model. I didn't see it myself. It's unfortunate that "truth" is so elusive.
- Oletros 9y ago> Other models showing the hockey stick does not negate the fact (??) that someone else made a rigged model to show a hockey stick I hope you will provide links to back the claim that it was rigged, isn't?
- greglindahl 9y agoThese are observations, not models. Given that the hockey stick turns out to be observed in other datasets, in fact all datasets, and no misconduct was found after an investigation, you're really not going to convince anyone that there was a "rigged model" unless they already thought that.
- phkahler 9y agoPerhaps it wasn't deliberate and I was reading from a source with an agenda, but the model did suck: https://www.technologyreview.com/s/403256/global-warming-bombshell/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/403256/global-warming-bom...
- Oletros 9y ago> We have evidence of data tampering - i.e. a climate model that showed the "hockey stick" regardless of what the input data was. It's a highly politicized thing. This is not true > And lastly, if I accept climate change as a result of human activity I say we still don't have decent models. This is also not true