4 ms·
I have no problem viewing the scenario "throttle/charge-more-for Reddit specifically" as a nightmare, as an unambiguous violation of NN, and as a bad thing I'd
by SilasX 9y ago
I have no problem viewing the scenario "throttle/charge-more-for Reddit specifically" as a nightmare, as an unambiguous violation of NN, and as a bad thing I'd like to prohibit.
But, per my other comment [1], NN seems to be used in a much stronger sense than that, which covers any arrangement whereby you can pay more for a dedicated pipe.
To extend your electric company example:
Let's say that the mains actually had two pipes (type A and B) bundled together and you could branch off of one or the other to set up a power outlet. Further, in times of brownouts/undercapacity, type A would keep the same voltage, whatever, while type B would die out.
What if the electric company charged more for every type A connection you wanted? That doesn't seem like it's obviously a bad thing, since there are legit usages where you might want the steadier power and be willing to pay for it. It's certainly not on the level of charging by what is plugged into the outlet.
Edit: Also, type A is equivalent (in some sense) to running your own generator that just services your demand. Surely that can't be evil?
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15910272 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15910272
- mr_spothawk 9y ago> What if the electric company charged more for every type A connection you wanted? This actually happens (in some sense). If you want tons and tons of electrical juice, you pay more for it in 1-phase, 2-phase, 3-phase options. (I am not a power engineer, but I live in a warehouse with 2-phase power which we "need" & use for welding, running expensive equipment, etc...)
- SilasX 9y agoWait, there's a system that works like that? Including continuing to draw (while others die) in case of brownouts?
- NickNameNick 9y agoSort of. When generation is unable to keep up with demand, and the generators can't maintain frequency keeping, the grid can go into load-shedding mode. Progressively disconnecting consumer sections until the generators can keep up. The segments that have hospitals will tend to be the last to go.
- SilasX 9y agoRight, but that doesn't sound like (an analog of) the proposal under discussion which would be "anyone, so long as they pay the uniform rate, gets the hospital treatment during brownouts".
- jacoblambda 9y agoWell there are dedicated lines when you need more than a certain amount of power. As for brownouts, they can promise priority in repairing power outages but at that point the client is expected to have backups or UPSes of their own
- lurr 9y agoYou're free to pay for an internet line with an SLA attached, with better support, with redundancy, etc... None of that is a problem under net neutrality.
- SilasX 9y agoHow so? Isn't that effectively the same as the fast lanes everyone is worried about?
- jasonkostempski 9y agoIts faster and more reliable for all internet communications, not just for Netflix as an example. So it's "neutral" about what is being accesed.
- freeone3000 9y agoIt's still neutral. The reliability doesn't depend on the contents that you're transmitting. Cat pictures sent over a 5-9's SLA line are just as reliable as your video conference.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoNo, in this example, I pay my ISP to make my end faster, the person on the other pays their ISP to make their end faster. In the no net neutrality example, the person on the other end pays their ISP to make their end faster and then they also get contacted by my ISP who asks them to pay to make my end faster when talking to them. So instead of agreeing with my own ISP on how fast I need my traffic to be, my ISP cuts me out of the loop and goes and talks to some third party to decide how fast to make my traffic.
- SilasX 9y agoI understand the downsides of extorting specific sites to pay more or be artificially throttled. That is an unambiguous case of NN violation and the kind of thing (per original comment) I'm in favor of prohibiting. But NN advocates (as best I can tell) want it to go further, and prohibit A) the other end voluntarily subsidizing my end on the condition that the funds be used for pipes that they (having partially paid for) have privileged access to. How is that any worse than the paying for a bigger chunk of the ISP's pipes? And it seems economically equivalent to: B) A content provider P subsidizing a mobile data network's increased capacity on the condition that P's transmissions not count toward customers' limits. (I know B drives many people mad as a NN violation, while other advocates are like, "nah, cell data is okay.") Furthermore, B only seems to differ in degree from: C) An ISP spending customer money to interface with content provider P's system for replicating P's content within the ISP's network [1] so that access to P's content is faster an less expensive -- instead of spending that same money to make the network faster for all customers and all remote servers. (Case C is like B, but where the "subsidy" is the expense of making Open Connect-like systems work.) And yet, everyone seems fine with C. If it seems like I'm nitpicking, let me step back and look at the big picture: NN looks like a bundle of good ideas ("don't artificially throttle specific sites"), married to a bunch of economically dubious hate for (the equivalent of) toll roads and desire that there be no downsides to higher usage -- the classic motte-and-bailey[2]. [1] For example, Netflix's Open Connect: https://openconnect.netflix.com/en/ https://openconnect.netflix.com/en/ [2] https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Motte_and_bailey https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Motte_and_bailey
- mundo 9y agoAnalogies only work until they don't. For this one to be applicable, the power company would have to be using the dual-lines to pitch their own (or their partners') ancillary services, or degrading standard service in order to push customers towards the premium service.