4 ms·
"Your comment is basically "You're being too informative. Could you break it down for me further, again, one more time?"" I have no stakes or position in the a
by roel_v 16y ago
"Your comment is basically "You're being too informative. Could you break it down for me further, again, one more time?""
I have no stakes or position in the argument, but this line of reasoning can basically be applied to anything one can debate about. We could just add a first post to all threads that says 'go to scholar.google.com' and look for yourself!' but I don't think that's the point. The point of these (informal) threads is to break vast quantities of information down into specific chunks that a few people in the thread care about at this moment. In that context I don't think it's too much to ask from commenters to reference specific items, facts or studies, and not resort to 'read 300 page book xyz'.