2 ms·
If the coin represents ownership of a resource (or a right to a resource), it can be a security (though it might be a derivative instead, governed by a similar
by gamblor956 9y ago
If the coin represents ownership of a resource (or a right to a resource), it can be a security (though it might be a derivative instead, governed by a similar but entirely separate set of rules).
Being a security does not mean it can't also be something useful; it just means that the security aspects of it are potentially subject to securities laws.
EDIT: Beanie babies aren't securities because you actually the beanie baby. However, a piece of paper entitling you to ownership of a beanie baby could be a security.
- michwill 9y agoAll right, but if the coin is inseparable part of the resource, it cannot be a security. There is a thin line here. Imagine a coin securitizing Bitcoin miners ("cloud mining coin"). Yes, that's a security. Now imagine Ethereum. It was ICO'd, talking in today's terms. Is it a security? (hint: SEC just admitted it's not)
- gamblor956 9y agoAll right, but if the coin is inseparable part of the resource, it cannot be a security. There is a thin line here. True, but then you're limited to things which can be stored in a blockstream in the space allocated to a single coin. There aren't many useful resources that could fit into that space, even fewer that would scale. Now imagine Ethereum. It was ICO'd, talking in today's terms. Is it a security? (hint: SEC just admitted it's not) Unless there is something about Ethereum that I'm not aware of, it does not represent any sort of ownership interest in another asset, it is the asset.
- Animats 9y agoThe SEC's position on the DAO was that they were not going to apply their guidance retroactively to that one. Going forward, though, they're cracking down.
- joosters 9y agoWhere did the SEC say the ethereum ICO wasn't a sale of securities?
- Frogolocalypse 9y ago> Now imagine Ethereum. It was ICO'd, talking in today's terms. Is it a security? (hint: SEC just admitted it's not) I didn't see any admission like that. Quite the contrary. I think the statement pretty clearly places the ethereum ICO (as distinct from the functioning network after) as a security. https://blog.ethereum.org/2014/07/22/launching-the-ether-sale/ https://blog.ethereum.org/2014/07/22/launching-the-ether-sal... There are a number of points in that post that scream security.