3 ms·
Wow. There are actually laws in place that say the rich are able to do things that poor people can't. This has been discussed many times on HN. The purpose of
by gamblor956 9y ago
Wow. There are actually laws in place that say the rich are able to do things that poor people can't.
This has been discussed many times on HN. The purpose of the law isn't to prevent "poor people" from doing anything. The purpose of the law is to prevent companies from making unregistered sales of stock to people who aren't (1) saavy enough to evaluate the risks of their investment or (2) wealthy enough to survive a financial loss if the investment does not bear fruit.
In a nutshell, the law requires companies wishing to sell to the general public to register with the SEC and meet certain financial disclosure requirements, such as disclosing financials using standardized accounting practices, so that the people buying their stock can judge the financial condition of the company they're investing in.
Startups choose not to register or adhere to these disclosure requirements so they can peddle their BS financial "metrics" to investors using magical unicorn fairy dust bookkeeping.
But to address the direct issue: there are few, if any, Uber stockholders who hold 10,000 shares of the company but would somehow not qualify as an accredited investor. The tender offer isn't intended for small stockholders with de minimis ownership, it's intended for stockholders with enough stock to represent significant fractions of the ownership of Uber.
- ryandrake 9y ago> This has been discussed many times on HN. The purpose of the law isn't to prevent "poor people" from doing anything. The purpose of the law is to prevent companies from making unregistered sales of stock to people who aren't (1) saavy enough to evaluate the risks of their investment or (2) wealthy enough to survive a financial loss if the investment does not bear fruit. This is all true, however laws should be judged by their effect, not by their purpose. This law effectively allows rich people to do things that poor people can't. It also may protect un-saavy investors, although I would argue that an un-saavy investor will inevitably find some other way to lose their money regardless of the accredited investor law. They're probably buying bitcoins right now or something.
- gamblor956 9y agoThis law effectively allows rich people to do things that poor people can't. You're still not getting it. The law does not stop poor people from investing in a private company. It simply prevents the company from advertising its stock to "poor people" unless the company registers with the SEC and demonstrates at least a minimal level of financial controls. A company can sell its stock to poor people as long as it does not solicit them. This is why employees and friends/family can buy stock of private companies. I will repeat again for emphasis: there is no law that prevents "poor people" from buying private company stock.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kodablah 9y agoWould you say the law disincentivizes private companies from allowing their stock to be bought/sold by "poor people"?
- rrix2 9y agoThe only entity buying stock here is Softbank (AFAIK), who is definitely not a "poor person". Outside of the handful of companies who have previously invested in the company (who are surely accredited), most entities who would qualify for this tender would be individual early employees. The accreditation requirement is also being held to those individual stock holders and option holders at the company who want to tender a sale of them to Softbank. Many are random engineers on this forum and other early-ish employees. Many may not meet the requirements for SEC accreditation, rules which specifically delineate around the wealth of the entity.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rahimnathwani 9y ago"But to address the direct issue: there are few, if any, Uber stockholders who hold 10,000 shares of the company but would somehow not qualify as an accredited investor." The article suggests there are folks who exercised 20,000 options (presumably representing one share each), but who had to borrow the money to exercise and to pay tax. Are you suggesting these people probably qualify as an accredited investor, or that their situation is unusual?
- gamblor956 9y agoI would say their situation is unusual, but based on Uber's valuation in 2016, they would have been accredited investors under the asset test if they held more than 20,000 shares. It's unusual because the offer values the stock at significantly less than last year's valuations, so they might not be accredited investors anymore...if the Softbank deal goes through and sets a new FMV for Uber stock. (If the deal falls through, then the $33 offer isn't a useful gauge of current Uber stock value.) The issue becomes when do you assess whether they are accredited investors: before the deal, using 2016 valuations, in which case they should qualify; or after the deal, using the deal's offer price, in which case they do not? I've never actually dealt with this situation before, where the deal itself could change a potential investor's accredited investor status, so I couldn't say what the outcome would be.
- toast0 9y agoAt the end of the day, the investor self-accredits. There's a form to sign that says 'I read and understand the requirements and I meet them' I don't know how much duty the counterparty has to investigate the validity of the declaration.
- mabbo 9y agoThat's a really great counterpoint. I didn't know it was something well-discussed- I had only just read it for the first time today.