4 ms·
Uber isn't publicly traded, so its stock price couldn't have "started crashing." Large investors aren't able to sell because they hold their shares in LLCs. Th
by gamblor956 9y ago
Uber isn't publicly traded, so its stock price couldn't have "started crashing."
Large investors aren't able to sell because they hold their shares in LLCs. They're able to sell because selling rights are part of the terms they negotiated as part of their agreement to invest. The form of ownership has nothing to do with it, and indeed the use of an LLC as a holding company for corporate stock usually complicates the legal and tax considerations for the sale of stock held by the LLC.
Also not sure why you're including a disclaimer? You're not offering any sort of advice so you don't need to disclaim anything.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Uber isn't publicly traded, so its stock price couldn't have "started crashing" "Crashing" is a function of value, not registration status. For example, CDOs "crashed" in the crisis [1]. > Large investors aren't able to sell because they hold their shares in LLCs With all due respect, this is wrong. Selling SPVs (or stakes therein) containing the shares of a single company is a common institutional tactic. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-06-14/goldman-sachs-agrees-to-end-1-billion-lawsuit-over-cdos https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-06-14/goldman-s... Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer. This is not legal nor tax advice.
- gamblor956 9y agoWith all due respect, this is wrong. Selling SPVs (or stakes therein) containing the shares of a single company is a common institutional tactic. It sure is. But that's not why the large investors get to sell their stock of Uber. They get to sell because they negotiated the right to sell, which may have included the right to use an SPV to hold their Uver stock. The SPV could have been a corporation, partnership, or LLC; the choice of the LLC form is not what gives the large investors the right to sell. Though based on your response, you probably meant in your original comment to refer to SPVs rather than LLCs. Disclaimer: I am a lawyer. This is not legal advice, it's legal commentary. The difference: advice applies to a client's specific legal circumstances; commentary applies to third parties.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> But that's not why the large investors get to sell their stock of Uber. They get to sell because they negotiated the right to sell, which may have included the right to use an SPV to hold their Uver stock. Lots of preferred stock does not carry the right to be transferred (or to be transferred free of other restrictions, e.g. a right of first refusal). SPV transfers are a convenient, if mutually-overlooked, workaround. Their existence is rarely explicitly negotiated. Another case, more directly tying power and economics: Some companies require Board approval for transfers. Guess who tends to get Board approval. > you probably meant in your original comment to refer to SPVs rather than LLCs LLCs are a common way to structure special-purpose vehicles (SPVs). This is Hacker News. Most here are familiar with LLCs; fewer with SPVs. Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer. This is not legal nor any other kind of advice.
- gamblor956 9y agoLots of preferred stock does not carry the right to be transferred (or to be transferred free of other restrictions, e.g. a right of first refusal). SPV transfers are a convenient, if mutually-overlooked, workaround. Their existence is rarely explicitly negotiated. Are you assuming that most corporate M&A lawyers don't know a basic holding structure taught the first week of the M&A class in law school? SPVs are not mutually overlooked workarounds, they're usually not worth the hassle in most situations. When they exist, they do so because the use of an SPV to hold the stock of the issuing company was explicitly negotiated as part of the investment because the securities law, tax, financing, and other considerations for stock held through an SPV, especially through a pass-through SPV like an LLC, can be very different from stock held directly. This is especially true for startups or other privately held companies with relatively complex ownership structures. (The use of SPVs is not negotiated for publicly traded companies, because the company's permission isn't required to acquire their stock.)
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoLarge investors bought stock. Small investors (employees) bought stock. Price went up. Price went down. The former could get cash for their shares, the latter could not. Price kept going down. You don’t need to be an M&A lawyer to see why that’s problematic.
- sjg007 9y agoHuh.. the LLC thing is a smart idea.. Seems rational for employees to start their own LLCs for the purpose of buying their options. Maybe the could group together.
- jsjohnst 9y agoAn employee can’t sell their options to an SPV any more than they can sell it to any other investor if their agreement places restrictions on selling (most do now days). While otherwise stating several facts, OP is wrong in his overarching premise that the SPV had basically anything to do with large investors being able to sell their ownership or not.
- sjg007 9y agoI think you can exercise the options and sell the stock subject to whatever rules you’ve agreed to, like right of first refusal etc... at any rate employees should refuse to work at startups with crappy schemes.. even uber.
- jsjohnst 9y ago> at any rate employees should refuse to work at startups with crappy schemes I agree, but not everyone is in a position to do that.
- hkmurakami 9y agoHe/she's offering a disclaimer bc he/she's a IBD person so his/her words are likely a bit more tied wrt professional obligations than your average engineer on these boards.
- gamblor956 9y agoIs there some obligation for a licensed engineer to disclaim non-engineering commentary? It's been my experience that most non-lawyers on HN/Slashdot posting these disclaimers do so because someone once told them they'd be risking unauthorized practice of law charges if they didn't. That was the case once...before the first dotcom boom...Since then, NOLO and others have successfully challenged these restrictions on offering generalized legal advice in most states (including the ones that matter). Nowadays, you're only at risk of unauthorized practice of law if you're applying the law to a specific person's set of circumstances in a manner which clearly indicates that you are specifically providing advice (or other legal services) to them based on those circumstances. This is why NOLO and other guidebooks don't run afoul of these laws--they only provide general advice, it's not tailored to any particular person's legal situation. On a similar note, applying the law to a third-party's circumstances as part of a discussion is not the practice of law, it's commentary. It's different for a lawyer. Lawyers are held to higher standards when it comes to online advice, but the risk there is whether the advisee believes that a client relationship has been created opening the lawyer up to malpractice liability. I could say that "Uber should do [X] to deal with legal problem [Y]" because it's obvious that Uber, as a well-funded company, has its own lawyers and would not treat my commentary as actionable legal advice or as resulting in a lawyer-client relationship. But I couldn't say "somethirdpartyperson should do [X] to deal with legal problem [Y]" because that person could reasonably treat commentary by a lawyer suggesting a specific action to address a legal issue as legal advice they can act on, and this belief is legally treated in most jurisdictions as creating a de facto lawyer-client relationship.
- kodablah 9y ago> but the risk there is whether the advisee believes that a client relationship has been created opening the lawyer up to malpractice liability Getting a bit meta here, but I read "IANAL" caveats not as limiting personal liability but as a "reader beware". Almost as a courtesy to the reader by saying "I may not know what I'm talking about" without saying it. I doubt people discussing things on these boards are really concerned about the liability attached with actions someone takes after reading their comment.