4 ms·
I think that it’s a job that the soldier chooses to do, and were I to do that and suffer injuries (mental or physical) I’d expect to be treated by the NHS in th
by robin_reala 9y ago
I think that it’s a job that the soldier chooses to do, and were I to do that and suffer injuries (mental or physical) I’d expect to be treated by the NHS in the same way that I’d expect an industrial accident to be treated, or a first respinder’s PTSD to be treated. It shouldn’t be held apart, because holding apart leads to hero worship, which leads to the wrong kind of nationalism. It’s insidious.
- chrisseaton 9y agoI don't agree with any kind of hero worship or 'thank you for your service' either! It makes me cringe. But it really doesn't make any sense to argue that 'it's just a job'. That's simply technically wrong. A soldier is subject to a whole additional legal system to civilians. They can go to prison if they don't do the work they're told to do. They can go to prison if they leave before their contract is us. They can be told to do something that they know will get them killed. None of these things are anything like any other job.
- robin_reala 9y agoThat’s reasonable, but maybe the answer is to dismantle the additional legal framework about that industry? I’ve not seen any desire to do so, but that doesn’t mean the conversation isn’t worth having.
- gaius 9y agoI’d expect to be treated by the NHS in the same way Except that a soldier can't even expect that (yes RAF I know but still) http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/defence/11892935/RAF-sergeant-in-uniform-moved-by-hospital-to-avoid-offending-other-patients.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/defence/11892935/RAF-...
- DanBC 9y agoWe know that UK veterans get relatively poor treatment from the NHS, especially for mental illness. This is partly because there's often comorbid alcohol problems, and removing alcohol services from the NHS and dumping them in public health (eg, underfunded LAs) has been catastrophic. And there's often lack of clarity about what gets treated first - the mental ill health or the alcohol misuse, so people get ping-ponged between services. You mention PTSD: Soldiers find it hard to engage with NHS mental health services because their experiences are so far out of the mainstream. I know that staff at 2gether NHS Foundation Trust[1] needed extra support because they were being told stuff that was so distressing they were getting sub-threshold PTSD themselves. For these reasons the Armed Forces Covenant is a good idea. We're not yet giving veterans equal treatment to the rest of the population. [1] who provide MH services across gloucestershire and Herefordshire