7 ms·
This -- "One of those former employees paid about $100,000 to exercise more than 20,000 incentive stock options (ISOs), plus a tax bill of over $200,000. The ot
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
This -- "One of those former employees paid about $100,000 to exercise more than 20,000 incentive stock options (ISOs), plus a tax bill of over $200,000. The other paid about $70,000 to exercise about 5,000 ISOs, and then about $160,000 in taxes. Both former employees took out loans from family members to make the payments, and requested anonymity to discuss their personal financial situations."
Is how many many Silicon Valley horror stories begin. In the dot.com days it was "How working for a startup bankrupted me, and ruined my relationships." All because some situation forced a person to make the bet of whether or not their illiquid asset (stock in a private company) would ever become liquid. And that when it did, selling it would be more valuable than what you paid for it.
Clearly not everyone is as out there as the person mentioned in the article is, although I knew many people who had anywhere from $5K - $50K at risk because they had exercised and were holding. I had stock losses from the dot com implosion that I wrote off for over 10 years (at $3,000 a year) and it would have gone on for the rest of my life if we hadn't had a bit of long term gains to offset it later.
- hkmurakami 9y agoYeah this just looks like poor/risky financial calculus on the part of the former employees. Also I always incorrectly think that these sorts of option traps are public knowledge, but then every now and then I'm prove wrong by even very smart people I personally know, not being aware of these traps. Not sure how we fix this situation tbh. For starters "don't join a company without an extended option exercise period" is a decent first order heuristic, but not everyone has that luxury.
- rconti 9y agoI'd say "risky" rather than "poor". They probably knew it was "risky" in the sense that they were extending themselves but perhaps underestimated the tax consequences or risk of the company's fortunes turning. Many people just stick it out with their employer hoping that their options become liquid; in some ways that can also be risky/poor decision making. Maybe it's an unhealthy work environment or you've stopped learning/advancing in your career, or there's a real opportunity cost where you're foregoing a higher salary. Maybe these people left because it was the better life decision (or maybe they were terminated), but regardless, most of us would think long and hard about giving up, say, millions of dollars in potential value. Hell, even at $300k in debt it might be a good or worthwhile gamble. It's easy to dismiss this all as poor decision making, but there are real risk/reward calculations to be done here, and "walk away from millions of dollars" is not always the smart answer, even if it kills in the comment threads.
- gfodor 9y agoif you are optimizing for regret minimization I'd probably argue that it's way less regrettable to end up in $200-300k in debt due to a crazy, unexpected snafu occurring (like an economic crash or company crash) than have to know for the rest of your life you could have been a millionaire if you just had bet on the (at the time) reasonably high probability event of eventual liquidity, by exercising options that you worked hard to earn. especially because in the crash scenario, you are surrounded by commiserating peers who also got burned, but in the upside scenario you missed out on, all of your peers except you are living the high life shaking their heads at your "foolish" (in hindsight) risk aversion. edit: not sure why the downvotes. if you are interested in a treatment of peer-based utility functions that affect risk premia, see https://www.amazon.com/Missing-Risk-Premium-Volatility-Investing/dp/1470110970 https://www.amazon.com/Missing-Risk-Premium-Volatility-Inves... -- in other words, risk may not be best measured as volatility but instead as the expected relative wealth gain/loss to your market peers. for private employee equity, those peers are other optionholders.
- xapata 9y agoPlus, in the event you have $300k of debt and no assets, you can file for bankruptcy.
- cityzen 9y agoIsn’t this how we ended up with people like Donald Trump? Risky behavior pawned off on everyone else?
- lovich 9y agoits not really moral, but its incentived behavior
- xapata 9y agoIn this case, the bank that gives you a loan is the one taking the risk. Theoretically. The trouble is that the government doesn't like to let banks fail. Trump is special. The fact that Deutsche Bank was still willing to lend so much, despite his repeated bankruptcies is very interesting. If I recall correctly, he was involved in a lawsuit with one department at Deutsche over missed payments while a different department was signing over $700 million.
- caseysoftware 9y agoRisky? Yes. Poor? That's yet to be seen.
- abalone 9y agoYeah, this always existed but the magnitude is so much greater for so many more people now because companies are staying private longer. I think it's healthy to just let vesting mean you get to take it with you, period, no catch. But it's worth noting this means there will be fewer options returned to companies in comparison to the last boom. Scott Kupor made this point although he framed it in a poor way.[1] He notes that it will in theory result in more dilution for employees that stay. [1] https://a16z.com/2016/06/23/options-timing/ https://a16z.com/2016/06/23/options-timing/
- caseysoftware 9y ago> I think it's healthy to just let vesting mean you get to take it with you, period, no catch. This sounds great in concept but in practice acquiring the shares is the taxable event. So if a company just gives you shares, that's the taxable event. And since you get taxed on the delta between your strike price and the "fair market value" (even though there isn't one), it would happen on the company's schedule, not your own. If you extended the exercise window for N years, that would mitigate most of it because you could wait to execute until it's liquid. Or not execute at all if it goes under. * I've been through two IPOs in the last couple years.. good planning shielded me from having major tax liabilities.
- astura 9y ago>So if a company just gives you shares, that's the taxable event. Unless they put them in your 401k, which is exactly what many (most?) companies do.
- Eridrus 9y agoI have literally never heard of this...
- astura 9y agoMaybe not in a startup? I have company stock given to me in my 401k. https://www.fidelity.com/viewpoints/personal-finance/company-stock https://www.fidelity.com/viewpoints/personal-finance/company... >More than 15 million people own about $400 billion of company stock in Fidelity-administered workplace retirement plans alone
- dionidium 9y ago"Both former employees took out loans from family members to make the payments" This isn't the point of the story, but it may be a good bubble-check for some to hear that the idea of having family members in a position to lend this kind of money is mind-boggling to this reader of working-class roots.
- caseysoftware 9y agoThey may not have the money but they may have equity in their homes to borrow. (I still wouldn't do it but it's possible.)
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoIt seems like this is a kind of a loophole in the SEC's accredited investor rules. These people aren't accredited investors, yet a private company like Uber is able to take an investment from them by giving them options beforehand. Perhaps private companies should be forbidden from allowing the exercise of options for non-liquid stock by non-accredited investors, and then also forbidden from requiring un-exercised options that they have granted to non-accredited investors to be forfeited at the end of an exercise window so as to not be ludicrously unfair to the people holding unexercisable options.