2 ms·
There is a difference between "responsibility" in the form "you are now liable for the damages caused by the other party" (which is what you are looking at, I t
by saurik 9y ago
There is a difference between "responsibility" in the form "you are now liable for the damages caused by the other party" (which is what you are looking at, I think?) and "people can come to you and demand you take down more content and you will end up in a position where they can force you to do that with injunctions" (which is what I am looking at).
I should verify, though, if your point here is partially that this would be different from ALS Scan v Cloudflare, as the latter involves "infrastructure level caching"? That said, in the case of AOL, the content wasn't just cached: it was being hosted. Is it that one was an awkward case of defamation and this one is more about copyright? But then I would say that Section 230 has severe limitations.
I guess let's look at this from another direction: why do you feel Section 230 is a protection that is relevant here but isn't helping Cloudflare on their other fronts? It would seem to me that the actual issue of concern (that Cloudflare can and likely will be asked to block DNS for domain names that happen to host or advertise things like The Pirate Bay) is not affected by the existence of Section 230.