3 ms·
> nobody should be trying to remember all their passwords, or using a memorable scheme that is adapted based on requirements I strongly disagree with this. Us
by gpm 9y ago
> nobody should be trying to remember all their passwords, or using a memorable scheme that is adapted based on requirements
I strongly disagree with this. Using a password store guarantees that it is technically possible for someone to recover a complete list of my passwords without me being aware. And means I am either storing my passwords online someone which makes it far easier for that technical breach to happen, or I am relying on a piece of hardware not failing to maintain access to my account.
Remembering a unique password for each site (that I actually care about, I can write down passwords for sites that I don't) is simply more secure. Sure the passwords will be easier to reverse if you get a hash of them then a real random string, but it would still be extremely difficult/beyond most cracking software (it's easy to increase reversing difficulty by using a long hard-to-reverse suffix shared between all your passwords), and you'd have to steal and reverse a lot of hashes to find useful patterns.
- lotyrin 9y agoMy credential management tool has ~300 credentials in it, of which I use roughly 10% frequently, there is no way for me to remember these, without creating a scheme which someone could eventually reverse given enough of my leaked credentials (so far about 15% of services I use have had breaches using weak hashes, and these tend to end up in public). Such a scheme would also have to support password rotation (for services which are breached, or which expire credentials) If I am going to store them somehow, an encrypted blob seems to handily beat pen and paper. The only scheme I can think of that would be strong would be one that is tool-assisted and given a set of password requirements (length, allowed characters, etc.), a domain, a master key, and an incremental counter, derived keys and formed passwords on the spot, but I'd still need to remember the criteria for each site, and the counter positions, and keep those secured... so whats a few more bytes?