2 ms·
> The Daily Stormer army deserves little sympathy, and using them to invoke a slippery slope argument full of straw men is somewhat sloppy and escalates this di
by saurik 9y ago
> The Daily Stormer army deserves little sympathy, and using them to invoke a slippery slope argument full of straw men is somewhat sloppy and escalates this discussion to a place where criminal actors are victims and a company trying to do something good is told they're lackeys of a police state.
I agree that The Daily Stormer deserves no sympathy, and will note I did not apologize for them (I even chose to call them "Nazis" instead of "neo-Nazis" or "alt-right": let's call a spade a spade, after all).
However, I also did not make a theoretical argument to which you can try to play your dismissive cards of "slippery slope" or "straw man": in fact, I pointed to an ongoing case playing out right now, in court.
https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2017/10/11/cloudflare-ceo-neo-nazi-piracy/ https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2017/10/11/cloudflare-ceo-n...
> If Cloudflare Can Block Neo-Nazi Sites, Why Can’t They Block Piracy Sites?
> In a recent filing, lawyers for the adult entertainment company demanded a 7-hour deposition. Using Prince’s own words against him, ALS Scan wrote,
> “By his own admissions, Mr. Prince’s decision to terminate certain users’ accounts was ‘arbitrary,’ the result of him waking up ‘in a bad mood,’ and a decision he made unilaterally as ‘CEO of a major Internet infrastructure corporation’.
> “Mr. Prince has made it clear that he is the one who determines the circumstances under which Cloudflare will terminate a user’s account.”
The reality is exactly as I claim it to be, and the stakes are just as high as I argue. If you disagree, I implore you to respond to the evidence, not simply dismiss the argument out of hand.
- vr46 9y agoFair enough. Clumsy handling by Mr Prince - and certainly suggests that we need more due process everywhere - but an emotive issue that most people could sympathize with. The company has basically decided that Nazis don't get service but porn-pirates do. It's not very black and white, though. Morally, it's a minefield. "Porn producers pissed-off at pirates not being given the same treatment as Nazis" I bow to your observations, but I'm not convinced that the stakes are as high as you argue...