2 ms·
Point taken. I think, however, that it's at least somewhat of a strawman argument. The argument is "Why learning Smalltalk can never be a waste of time" and #6
by eesmith 9y ago
Point taken. I think, however, that it's at least somewhat of a strawman argument. The argument is "Why learning Smalltalk can never be a waste of time" and #6 is "Old languages still have great value", concluding that "When did “old” ever become a liability, as many opine?"
But how many people really say that Smalltalk is a waste of time because it's an old language? My experience is that it's not a common argument against learning Smalltalk.
That said, I also object to the use of the starting dates as the date for the language when, for example, the C language from the 1970s is not "very commonly used for systems programming" - at the very least that should be ANSI C.
Similarly, I know it's not useful to study the Python of its first release for anything other than historical interest. For one, the __init__ convention hadn't yet been created, so objects were initialized manually.
- coldtea 9y ago>But how many people really say that Smalltalk is a waste of time because it's an old language? I think a lot of people in the industry, especially younger ones in startups and fad-driven cultures, tend to discard older languages with similar criteria. Not just Smalltalk, even something like Java -- "people still use that?".
- eesmith 9y agoI still think the argument "Learning Smalltalk is not a waste of time because people are wrong when they say that old languages aren't worth studying" is missing a step in the logic.