5 ms·
Near-miss math provides exact representations of almost-right answers
- tectec 9y agoThis page is referenced in the article, but I didn't see a link provided: http://www.orchidpalms.com/polyhedra/acrohedra/nearmiss/nearmiss.htm http://www.orchidpalms.com/polyhedra/acrohedra/nearmiss/near...
- vumgl 9y agoIt's always fascinating to think about how few people realize the near miss (better called lucky approximation) of 2^7/12 ~ 3/2, which is the basis of the equal-temperament musical system, i.e. music as we know it.
- endymi0n 9y agoA great further read: "The saddest thing I know about the integers" https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/roots-of-unity/the-saddest-thing-i-know-about-the-integers/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/roots-of-unity/the-sadd...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- GuB-42 9y agoInteresting, Does it makes sense to do statistical analysis on near-misses like it is done in experimental science in order to find if it is just a coincidence or if it warrants more attention? For example: estimate the entropy of a formula and compare it to the error margin.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI'd say it doesn't, and that's precisely why it might be a fertile ground for new mathematics. Like it was with e.g. complex numbers, aka. "let's assume that this thing, which clearly doesn't make sense, exists, and let's consider how it behaves".
- jfaucett 9y agoHow can any irrational number x be close to a rational number y? as long as x is irrational it seems to me it would still be infinitely far away from y. What notion of proximity are they talking about?
- jtolmar 9y agoPi is within 1% of 22/7. Edit: Another way of putting it, pi is not infinite. It's a number between 3.14 and 3.15.
- tgb 9y agoThat's not entirely what they mean either, because then every irrational number is "close" to a rational (just take its decimal expansion out to 200 digits - that's rational and very close to the irrational number). You also have to consider the size of the denominator of the rational you are comparing to: i.e. you want to say that irrationals are close being ration if they're close to be a "nice" rational. Where 1/2 is clearly nicer than 22/7 which is clearly nicer than 257/139.
- jfaucett 9y agothank you! That makes sense.
- asddkk 9y agoI think there's some information-theoretic ideas about compressibility or codelength that are relevant. The appeal, I think, is in being able to succinctly represent a random or irrational mathematical object with some other object that's not exactly the same, but is simpler to describe and equivalent to some high degree of similarity. Normally these ideas are applied to things that are thought of as random in a physically stochastic sense, but you could apply them to things that are random in an information-theoretic irrationality sense also. I'd say the polyhedra they discuss are kind of examples of this, maybe in reverse or something: they are simplified constructs that work as representations to some close extent. There's some interesting ties here to pseudorandom numbers, in that usually we think of them as approximating true randomness, even though they're entirely reproducible and predictable. This seems similar to me at some level.
- strictnein 9y agoThe two triangles and blocks are kind of mind bleep, before it's explained to you. Check it out here, without the spoiler: http://static.nautil.us/12472_4c78f7b58f4de12ed2cab9bcb9ec0ba0.png http://static.nautil.us/12472_4c78f7b58f4de12ed2cab9bcb9ec0b...
- GlenTheMachine 9y agoIs there a body of literature that one can use to bootstrap yourself into these ideas? I've seen it written up in the popular scientific press a couple of times over the last few months, but I've never found a tutorial or textbook or body of papers accessible to AI researchers or engineers. Pure math papers are often not written to be understandable to dabblers.
- mangix 9y agoUhhhhh I'm pretty sure near miss is the wrong term. Near hit sounds about right.
- raattgift 9y agoClose call?