3 ms·
"Old languages still have great value" The author picked only those old language which still have great value. The author did not include such languages as Al
by eesmith 9y ago
"Old languages still have great value"
The author picked only those old language which still have great value.
The author did not include such languages as Algol, JOVIAL, MUMPS, SNOBOL, or TRAC. There are a lot of old languages with little modern value. (Then again, a lot of new languages have little value.)
Since the author did not include COBOL, should I infer that "great value" doesn't include "getting a job developing legacy systems"?
- coldtea 9y agoWhat the author tried to convey by "old languages still have great value" is that: "Old languages shouldn't be discarded as valueless just because they're old. Some old languages have great value". And not: "Any old language still has great value". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity
- eesmith 9y agoPoint taken. I think, however, that it's at least somewhat of a strawman argument. The argument is "Why learning Smalltalk can never be a waste of time" and #6 is "Old languages still have great value", concluding that "When did “old” ever become a liability, as many opine?" But how many people really say that Smalltalk is a waste of time because it's an old language? My experience is that it's not a common argument against learning Smalltalk. That said, I also object to the use of the starting dates as the date for the language when, for example, the C language from the 1970s is not "very commonly used for systems programming" - at the very least that should be ANSI C. Similarly, I know it's not useful to study the Python of its first release for anything other than historical interest. For one, the __init__ convention hadn't yet been created, so objects were initialized manually.
- coldtea 9y ago>But how many people really say that Smalltalk is a waste of time because it's an old language? I think a lot of people in the industry, especially younger ones in startups and fad-driven cultures, tend to discard older languages with similar criteria. Not just Smalltalk, even something like Java -- "people still use that?".
- eesmith 9y agoI still think the argument "Learning Smalltalk is not a waste of time because people are wrong when they say that old languages aren't worth studying" is missing a step in the logic.