17 ms·
I don’t know where the author grew up, but didn’t he get anything in return for his taxes? I’ve had free healthcare, free college education, free libraries, pol
by pavlov 9y ago
I don’t know where the author grew up, but didn’t he get anything in return for his taxes? I’ve had free healthcare, free college education, free libraries, police and fire departments protecting me, occasional grants, a social security network in case I lost my ability to work... I would never say that “taxes limit my options” because the personal record shows the opposite.
Besides, it’s not about just me: the whole point of taxes is that it gives options to everyone, not just those lucky enough to be born to wealthy parents.
I have a hard time believing that a messaging app founder would spend his money on charities more usefully than the government would spend it on basic services. (Assuming he would donate an amount anywhere close to the tax rate, which he certainly wouldn’t.)
- nickpp 9y agoBut wouldn't you have liked to shop around for those free-but-paid-from-your-taxes services? And benefit from competition between providers which drives prices down and quality up? Government are ultimate monopolies: always getting worse and more expensive. Maybe you are thinking about a handful of functioning, high quality governments (US, Germany, Nordic States) but I am thinking about the great majority of the governments on the globe (Africa, Asia, E Europe) which provide really crappy, expensive services.
- fooker 9y agoYou can shop around for products. Doesn't work that well for infrastructure.
- jon-wood 9y agoNo. I really don't want to shop around when I've been hit by a bus and need urgent medical care. I want to know that whatever hospital the paramedics take me to is going to be equipped to handle things, and that I won't be handed a crippling bill afterwards. I also don't want to shop around for roads, police, fire service, garbage collection, or any number of other things provided by my taxes. I definitely don't want people less well off to go without those things because they couldn't pay. The point of taxes, and particularly progressive taxes, is to ensure everyone has access to services while placing the burden for that on those most able to afford it. That isn't particularly well implemented in many cases, but I strongly believe it should be the goal.
- pavlov 9y ago...competition between providers which drives prices down and quality up? Does it necessarily? Corporations are looking for profit growth, and the customer will pay for that. Imagine a service where a public provider is replaced with three private corporations. Superficially there's competition and freedom of choice... But what if the three companies all operate at 80% margin, are constantly squeezing on quality to drive the margin even higher, and they are owned by multinationals that spend enormous amounts on lobbying to prevent new entrants in the market? It's easy to see how both price and quality can be worse in this case than it was with the single public provider.
- ekianjo 9y ago> Besides, it’s not about just me: the whole point of taxes is that it gives options to everyone, not just those lucky enough to be born to wealthy parents. Then how does this thinking fit with the reality of taxes increasing everywhere, year after year? Does that mean that services are getting better? Because you know, it's actually the opposite. It's getting worse: more and more illiteracy in schools, inflation of degrees that don't get you any job, more unemployment (or stagnant at best), healthcare with less and less services... etc.
- Vinnl 9y ago> Does that mean that services are getting better? One part of it is that there's more of it: more elderly people that require and receive care.
- thriftwy 9y agoBeing 32, I fail to understand how it benefits my bottom line.
- Vinnl 9y agoThe theory is that you both a) have relatives/other people that you care about that benefit from this, and b) that you will benefit from it when it's your turn to live even longer. Of course, it's yet to be seen how well b) will play out in practice.
- thriftwy 9y agoMaybe they do benefit from this. I fail to see how it converts into an obligation for me. I care about X. X would like to recieve money backed by my payments. Does that mean I owe them those payments? How well do Ponzi schemes play out in practice?
- Vinnl 9y agoThere is no inherent obligation. Where I'm from, though, we've voted for governments that make it one.
- 7713w1 9y agoYeah, Aaron Swartz and countless others were protected by the caring state.
- addicted 9y agoThe whole private charity stuff also creates perverse incentives. The better people who do donate to charity, are the ones who are left worse off, whereas the bad ones who never do, are the people who benefit. That’s the nice thing about a system of taxation, in that no one is penalized additionally while doing good.