3 ms·
At least Nikon has offered a similar idea for awhile: http://imaging.nikon.com/lineup/software/img_auth/index.htm http://imaging.nikon.com/lineup/software/img_
by acdha 9y ago
At least Nikon has offered a similar idea for awhile:
http://imaging.nikon.com/lineup/software/img_auth/index.htm http://imaging.nikon.com/lineup/software/img_auth/index.htm
The catch is that it has been hacked before:
https://blog.elcomsoft.com/2011/04/nikon-image-authentication-system-compromised/ https://blog.elcomsoft.com/2011/04/nikon-image-authenticatio...
The Secure Enclave helps a lot but the Nikon hsck illustrates a hazard of needing devices to be updated, especially since there’s an obvious opening for someone to use a plausible old vulnerable device – and it seems like, say, a compromising photo of a politician would spread a lot further and faster than the observation that the older phone has been compromised.
One other challenge is that you might be able to prove that a device took the photo but not that, say, it was a real scene rather than a high quality print or that the time stamp wasn’t subject to a manually set clock. Again, I’d expect countermeasures but worry that nobody would see them in time for the most damaging cases.
- nickparker 9y agoThe time stamp is handled on receipt of the hash by third parties in my mind, not by the originating device. Ideally the position component of the data would also be verified by 3rd parties, eg cell towers receiving the data add their own signatures so you know it was at least in the region it claims. The high quality prints problem is more interesting. I’d hope that sort of trick would be detectable by inspection, but then we’re back to cat/mouse games with AI. If we all switched to crypto verified light field photography, we could at least force hoaxsters to build dioramas :)
- acdha 9y agoOne risk: all of that could make a forgery more persuasive. Imagine some James O’Keefe style operative preparing a fake but not uploading it until they drive by the victim’s house, rent a room in the same hotel or near their office, etc. How many people would see the extra metadata and decide it proved accuracy?