4 ms·
So hey, what would have happened if you hadn't responded right away on Sunday but waited until Monday, talked to your boss, and then replied to Famous Company?
by eesmith 9y ago
So hey, what would have happened if you hadn't responded right away on Sunday but waited until Monday, talked to your boss, and then replied to Famous Company?
They wouldn't have known. Their message didn't say "you are obligated to keep this secret". And even if it did, you have no such obligation.
If you want to make the seduction analog - which I don't think is the right one - then Famous Company flirted with you, you responded, and now they are using your response as blackmail to control what you do.
Why do you even need to tell Famous Company that you have talked with your boss?
I think you should say that you just signed a contract for all of 2018 so you need to talk with your boss to get an idea of what free time you have during the 2018 period before taking on other work.
They want to do things under NDA, so your argument might be that you want to figure out your availability before signing the NDA, to help limit needless information disclosure. (Eg, if they have a project which requires 6 months of work but you only have 3, then there's no reason for them to tell you about it.)
BTW, I'm a Westerner. Don't read all that much into those infographics. For example, stereotypical German punctuality ("the West" in those graphics) is not the same as stereotypical Latin punctuality.
In my experience it isn't uncommon for employees to use poaching attempts like this for negotiation power. That is, you could go to your current boss and say that Famous Company is looking to hire you, in hopes that your current boss would raise your pay or promote you. And if that happens, then go back to Famous Company to see if you can get an even higher offer.
This can be done in both good and bad ways. You should be aware that some people play this game, so bosses on either side might be sensitive either to you playing that game, or them thinking that that's what you are doing.
But I don't think that telling your current boss - who already lets you do some part-time work - that you have the opportunity to do more part-time work for Famous Company, is part of playing that game. That won't start until they ask for more time than you have to give them. And you don't know how much time that is unless you talk with your current boss.
- peterburkimsher 9y agoThank you for sharing your thoughts! My boss isn't punctual with his emails. My reply to Famous Company said that I just signed a contract for 2018, but they still wanted to meet during a business trip in January. I'm busy during working hours, obviously, but I'm confident that I can ask my boss and get permission to leave the office to go and meet them. I feel uncomfortable not telling my boss though, because he's a friend. BTW, I grew up in Geneva and my parents are British, but I've had more work experience in Asia. Ironically, the person pursuing me is an Asian-American. The Famous Company isn't trying to blackmail. They didn't actually say "NDA", they said "significant legal paperwork... protects both parties". I don't care about a promotion, I just want a stable job. I know that in 2019, my boss wants me to move on (he already told me). I want to make sure I do this honestly, maintaining friendship with my boss, instead of sneaking behind his back and slipping out of the office unannounced.
- eesmith 9y agoMy use of the term "blackmail" was related to them expressing possible negative consequences for you telling your boss about your conversation, and in the context of "seduction". When they sent their first email, they had no idea of if you would immediately go to your boss/friend to discuss things. Only when you told them of the possibility did they want to control what you did. It's best not to think of this as seduction, or in the context of a pretty girl flirting with you. It's a company looking to hire your services, when you already have obligations. Tell your boss. Don't tell Famous Company. If Famous Company asks you if you talked with your boss, say "of course I did - I want to make sure that I could take time off to meet with you without disrupting things at work." The only reasons I can think of for Famous Company to have you not talk with your boss are 1) they are poaching you so they can compete with your current company, and 2) they don't want your boss to offer a raise. Yes, you say you don't care about a promotion. But they don't know who you are or what you want. It's to their benefit for someone like you to be left in the dark about what your options are.
- peterburkimsher 9y agoThank you. I'm so happy that there's opposite advice coming from you and siamtheman's top-level comment. Whatever I finally choose to do, I'm pleased that there's a variety of perspectives here on HN. Cultural diversity is a wonderful thing.