6 ms·
In as much as you seem to be making any point with your comment, that points seems to be a veiled threat that has no place in this discussion.
by shkkmo 9y ago
In as much as you seem to be making any point with your comment, that points seems to be a veiled threat that has no place in this discussion.
- stevew20 9y agoNope, no veiled threat. For example, when someone chooses to go diving with sharks, they've made a decision that puts them in harm's way. Being a public servant (as all government jobs are), and refusing to acknowledge the will of the people you serve, is similarly dangerous. You put yourself in a place that has no social protections, by violating trust.
- cmurf 9y agoNot all government jobs are intended to serve the public, many of them exist at the request of businesses, in particular regulatory agencies. Some of them work better than others, the FAA has a contrary agency in the NTSB that I think keeps it more honest than some of the other agencies. Ajit Pai's position on net neutrality is not news. It was not news when he was nominated by Trump, and confirmed by the Senate. And sufficient numbers of the public got those people elected despite their position on net neutrality. By being single issue voters, they are getting punished on everything else they might value.
- stevew20 9y agoI agree that some agencies are not intended to serve the public; I believe that many government agencies in our current regime are designed to keep the public sedentary and docile, at the tax expense of the public. In this case, the FCC attempted to placate the people by asking for comments to aid in the decision making process, then generated massive numbers of fake comments that supported the repeal of net neutrality. And I wholly agree with your second point.
- cmurf 9y agoWe don't know the source of the fake comments, the FCC is expressly not cooperating with the NY AG on this issue and I suspect that it'll take a court order to get that information from the FCC. The question is why not cooperate, especially in a criminal investigation? It's very weird, and at a minimum looks bad.
- stevew20 9y agoMy statement that the FCC generated the fake comments is conjecture. Between the refusal to cooperate that you pointed out, and that the outcome of those comments is exactly in line with the intent that Pai has indicated (since well before his appointment), I think my conjecture has a high probability of being correct. I've worked on election campaigns and the like (software dev and sys administration), and observed the use of bot generated comments in EVERY one of them. Based on my experiences, it seems highly unlikely that they refrained from using them in this instance. It would be a deviation from standard operating procedure.
- bovermyer 9y agoWhether it was intentional or not, the way your comment is worded implies that Pai should be or will be killed for his actions. Come on, we're more civilized than this.
- moretai 9y agoI don't know if we are.
- stevew20 9y agoIf only Vulcan had survived.
- stevew20 9y agoMy comment states that government officials have, in the past, been irreversibly shortened for choosing to disregard the will of the taxpayers whom they serve. I imply that he will be violating the social contract of trust between himself and the public if he chooses to go through with this. If you get the idea that "Pai should be or will be killed for his actions. " from this, you ignore the way political corruption is handled in the modern day USA. If he were to harm another people in another time in such a manner, the results would likely be much less in his favor. In our current political climate, there is very little action against any public "servant" of sufficiently high rank (example: Hillary's criminal negligence of handling TS/SCI intelligence)
- bovermyer 9y agoI'm surprised that this was downvoted. I guess HN is more bloodthirsty than I thought.
- dang 9y agoPlease don't react to comments that break HN's guidelines by breaking them yourself; we all need to be more disciplined than that. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dosgonlogs 9y agoI think it is a fair warning. Pai is going to get himself killed by someone if he isn't careful. He is being irresponsible with his own life at this point. I think it is good for people to put that out there. Might save a life.