3 ms·
"The thing I see is that the coins the rich community got for the food still have value." I think in your replies you are begging the question, though. The que
by jerf 9y ago
"The thing I see is that the coins the rich community got for the food still have value."
I think in your replies you are begging the question, though. The question at hand is precisely where the value comes from.
"Why it works is because of confidence and agreed upon value of the currency, which is required here in the same way."
The fundamental base of the United States Dollar is that you can use a dollar to buy one dollar's worth of protection from the United States-affiliated men-with-guns from coming and taking you to prison for not paying the United States Government what it has determined to be its fair share. The US Dollar is built upon the confidence that the United States can and will do this to you, not a vague confidence in the currency for currency's sake. (This is why when governments collapse, their currencies collapse; any alternate theories of value are obligated to explain that connection as part of their theory of how currencies obtain value.)
Currency is a unit of exchange, not really intrinsically valuable in itself except inasmuch as it exists in a market for which it can be exchanged. As a UBI proposal, this system very clearly has a mechanism for people to consume resources; the question is, who is going to put them in, and for what purpose?
Even waving at BitCoin isn't enough to answer this question. BitCoin has always been about exchanges, not unilateral consumption.
I think it may help you to ponder this question: Nothing stops you from creating adjkantCoin today. You can simply declare yourself to have a thousand of them. There is a deep and profound way in which that's exactly what this system does. How do you walk down the street and convince your grocer to take any of them in return for his apples? And don't consider it from your point of view... consider it from the grocer's. I am not asking this because it's impossible per se; BitCoin did indeed pull it off to some extent. But it's non-trivial, if you do successfully put yourself into the grocer's shoes, and something that this system will need to be able to answer many times over in order to work. And I don't see that answer right now. I'm not even sure it has a stable answer if you magicked it into existence, I'm deeply unconvinced it has an answer to get from here to there in the real world.
- adjkant 9y agoI completely agree it's non-trivial to convince people to adopt this system. However, once adopted, I don't think the 1 to 1 problem highlighted in this chain exists. If I had to give a very simple argument for why adopt, I think it would have to come from a place of "UBI would work if we all did X and you could still make money that could be exchanged for good and services with a similar inflation rate, so this currency is better than dollars. We should switch to it. Don't believe it will work? Look at Bitcoin!" In that way, pointing at Bitcoin naively can actually have value to validate the possibility of the coin's success. The biggest problem is of course not convincing one grocer, but the whole world at once. > "The question is, who is going to put them in, and for what purpose?" I fully agree with the question and its importance. I think the answer is everyone at once on the premise of "we're all in this together" and for the reason of "pursuit of a better social system". I don't think this will likely happen, but I think that theoretically, it's possible to function (the concept not this specific coin, which would need quite a lot more study to make this claim with). My hope is that given study and time, this idea has the potential to inspire a final system that could eventually be implemented this way in say 100 years, maybe sooner, maybe later. PS: Did not downvote, even if I disagree I appreciate the substance and am sad to see the downvote on such a substantive discussion.
- PeterisP 9y agoThe adoption problem is that it should be expected to be asymmetrical - most of the would-be-net-recipients would join early, most of the would-be-net-donors would join late or never. And this transition period matters a lot. If a system doesn't provide a solid benefit during the early transition, then it's worthless to discuss how it would work once adopted since it won't be, it can't be. See Bitcoin for example - it provides a solid financial benefit to early adopters, early investors. Without that benefit, it wouldn't get widely adopted and would be worthless.
- adjkant 9y agoThe transition does indeed matter a lot. I think there are other transition methods you are missing though. Look at how the US switched quite quickly to chip readers. I could also imagine a system where US dollars (or insert currency here) and UBICoin exist together for some time, but dollars are only valid if you were born after year X. Merchants would accept both during this transition time with an exchange rate. There is a ton to discuss in terms of transition. I don't think the transition being another unsolved problem invalidates the entire idea, particularly when virtually no time has been spent examining the transition options.