2 ms·
Okay, in the example of the poor community, the rich community can trade some of the coins back to the poor community for labor. Assuming that the farmers aren'
by PeterisP 9y ago
Okay, in the example of the poor community, the rich community can trade some of the coins back to the poor community for labor. Assuming that the farmers aren't as poor, the poor people have no flour or eggs to sell, but they can sell off some labor.
However, let's assume the third community, who are homeless and permanently unemployable for mental health reasons, and (for the sake of argument) will never ever earn a coin from anyone else. Since this system enforces a 1-to-1 exchange rate, can you name any practical difference whatsoever between Alice trusting one of those people for 1 coin (i.e. they'll be able to trade with someone in a scenario where that someone will get 1 AliceCoin and Alice will get 1 Homelesscoin) and simply gifting 1 AliceCoin as charity? IMHO there is none, except Alice would be able to "keep score" of how much she has given to charity.
This is a key issue here, that with this system trust isn't simply "Bob is who he claims to be", in this system trust means "I'm willing to guarantee that Bob's coins are as good as mine by agreeing to an automatic 1-to-1 trade", in essence you're willing to co-sign any purchase Bob makes since sellers will happily take your coins instead of Bob's; and in any environment where's an innate disbalance (i.e. your coins actually are more valuable than Bob's because more people will trust your coins) this arbitrage will be exploited up to your trust limit, resulting in you losing your coins and gaining Bobs coins instead.
The same applies with community coins; no matter what happens, the coins of some communities will be de facto more valuable than others, so any link of trust between these communities will be arbitraged by that built-in 1-to-1 trade option until that trust runs out and trade between those communities stops. If someone makes a 1-to-x trade reflecting the actual difference of market power, then again people can exploit the built in 1-to-1 trades - so there's a strong disincentive for anyone to make that trust between those communities, since you have to bet (and spend!) your resources in keeping the different currencies linked. The system doesn't provide for "partial trust" of say, 1-to-0.8; you have to be totally sure that Bob's coins are as good as yours, since by making the trust link you're willing to trade all your coins for Bob's coins automatically (with no confirmation or refusal possible) at a 1-to-1 rate. There's a lot of theory and experience for national currencies pegged to each other - and how it can get exploited for financial gain (e.g. Soros had some profitable deals).
- adjkant 9y agoI see what you're saying, but you haven't convinced me of this disbalance. What incentive do sellers have to accept AliceCoin over HomelessCoin if everyone adheres to this 1 to 1, even though de facto this is not the case if you consider economic resources? > Since this system enforces a 1-to-1 exchange rate, can you name any practical difference whatsoever between Alice trusting one of those people for 1 coin (i.e. they'll be able to trade with someone in a scenario where that someone will get 1 AliceCoin and Alice will get 1 Homelesscoin) and simply gifting 1 AliceCoin as charity? The key difference is that she has lost no value if everyone holds to the 1 to 1 always. This is an important distinction, you're right. However, I don't see any incentive to break from 1 to 1 if everyone is holding to it. If the grocery store accepts HomelessCoin, I have no preference for AliceCoin. If everyone breaks from 1 to 1, then you suddenly have to calculate and consider the value of billions of currencies now. Who wants that? What value do I get out of that change? This coin is inherently built upon the idea that we are not tying individual coin value to someone's economic value. The seller should just want more coins, and it doesn't matter who they come from.
- PeterisP 9y agoThe "... if everyone holds to the 1 to 1 always. " part is a lot of wishful thinking. As I said, look at the real world examples of currency pegging failures, many of them artificially engineered by large scale market activities. 1) There is an innate difference in practical value, initially even if some coins have just a bit more liquidity i.e. wider range of acceptors as others. 2) If everyone holds to the 1-to-1 agreement forever, then there's no difference between the coins and everyone can freely make the trust deals. 3) If the 1-to-1 does not hold forever, then the people who were betting on the link failing can earn a lot of free coins in this arbitrage, taking them off of people who have made the 1-to-1 trust deals - draining their resources until the assigned trust limits run out. 4) Thus, there's a strong incentive for skilled, resourced people to try to break any 1-to-1 peg between any arbitrary communities, since they can earn a lot of coins if this trust breaks. Especially since it's an automatically enforced 1-to-1 without fees, it's a safe bet - if you fail, then there's no effect, if you succeed, you win a lot. Someone will eventually do so, and the 1-to-1 will break. This system design contains rewards for would-be exploiters of trust, so this design will be exploited.