3 ms·
UBI is at its essence a resource redistribution system. It can't be solely opt-in (at least not in the near future) to achieve the value necessary for the "basi
by PeterisP 9y ago
UBI is at its essence a resource redistribution system. It can't be solely opt-in (at least not in the near future) to achieve the value necessary for the "basic" part (i.e. being sufficiently large to cover basic needs), it requires either a large external source of capital or (more likely) a sufficiently strong organization (such as a government) to enforce participation of the top 1% / 0.1% / all local companies, i.e. taxation.
An opt-in redistribution system is called charity. We know how much resources our society is willing to spend in that way, and that's not sufficient for universal basic income.
- adjkant 9y agoIn this case, opt-in is playing double meaning. But you're right, in order to work, a significant number of people and business must opt-in and treat it like a currency to be spent. I don't think that's a prohibitive problem inherently, though obviously still a tough one.