4 ms·
It's curious to see someone who describes himself as "over a decade into my training as a professional scientist" commit the most basic of logical fallacies: G
by tome 16y ago
It's curious to see someone who describes himself as "over a decade into my training as a professional scientist" commit the most basic of logical fallacies:
Gladwell: When we look at any kind of cognitively complex field ... you are unlikely to master it unless you have practiced for 10,000 hours.
Author: This rule reduces achievement to quantity: the secret to becoming great is to do a great amount of work
Err no. Gladwell says that to be great (A), you must have done 10,000 hours (B), i.e. A implies B.
The author then restates this as if you've done a great amount of work, you'll become great, i.e. B implies A. This is not a valid deduction!
- kenjackson 16y agoAdditonally Gladwell is talking about mastery or expertise. Not immortal fame. A kid who becomes good enough to play basketball in the NBA, and maybe make the all star team one year, certainly has developed a level of mastery in the game few ever achieve. But he's the forgotten player, compared to Lebron, Kobe, Magic, Larry, or Michael. There's a difference between being the best among the masters and simply being a master.
- kylemathews 16y agoPerhaps Gladwell never said 10,000 hours = mastery but plenty of other people have made that leap of logic so I think we can forgive the OP his mistake. Logical mistake or not, it shouldn't detract from what IMO is a great article with important, little discussed, insights.
- pchristensen 16y agoGladwell says that people who have mastery all put in at least 10,000 hours to get there, not that everyone who spends 10,000 will be a master.
- alexkiwi 16y agoCal has got some pretty great articles and has written a lot for students. I wonder if he's going to graduate.
- harscoat 16y ago"Cunctis Diebus quibus nunc milito expecto donec veniat immutation mea" Job 14:14 - quote that could illustrate (depending on translation interpretation http://www.biblestudytools.com/job/14-14-compare.html http://www.biblestudytools.com/job/14-14-compare.html ) this idea: "work! (at least 10kh) and maybe(!) one day the big change you have been longing for (mastery) will come to you"... this is a "grace" not a necessary consequence