5 ms·
Alabama Has the Worst Poverty in the Developed World, U.N. Official Says
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- scythe 9y agoHeadline is slightly misleading: >A United Nations official investigating poverty in the United States was shocked at the level of environmental degradation in some areas of rural Alabama, saying he had never seen anything like it in the developed world. i.e., the worst poverty the official had ever seen in the developed world, not the worst according to some comprehensive study.
- wnevets 9y ago>i.e., the worst poverty the official had ever seen in the developed world, not the worst according to some comprehensive study. Well I'm sure the fine folks of Alabama will sleep better at night knowing this.
- scythe 9y agoWell, the choice would have been for the article to have a factual title or get flagged off the front page. HN seems to have chosen the second option.
- dogecoinbase 9y agoUgh, yeah, what would those United Nations officials whose job it is to investigate poverty know about poverty.
- CalChris 9y agoI would have thought Mississippi but it doesn’t surprise me that it’s in the South. Huntsville has some defense work and I know there’s a Mercedes plant (in Vance, I had to look that up). But I can’t think of anything else in the state. https://www.careerinfonet.org/oview6.asp?soccode=&id=&nodeid=12&stfips=01&from=State https://www.careerinfonet.org/oview6.asp?soccode=&id=&nodeid...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dokument 9y agoRedstone Arsenal/NASA/Aerospace in Huntsville Mercedes in Vance. Hyundai in Montgomery Honda in Talladega Toyota in Madison Airbus Mobile
- rndholesqpeg 9y agoApparently they hadn't made it as far west as Mississippi yet
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tr4cefl0w 9y agoI remember seeing somewhere that they mostly rely on Mountain Dew for hydration and even feed it to the baby, so bad that they have early tooth decay issues. Apparently the amount of people living in trailer parks is huge and constantly growing. Troubling when you think that this is happening in the US. I saw that kind of situation in central america.
- icantdrive55 9y agoI wish California had more trailer parks. Never bought into the stereotype.
- lelandbatey 9y agoFrom what I remember and what I can find, that was something that was particularly found in Appalachia, not Alabama (see this article[0]). A quick check on Google maps shows that Alabama is about as far from Appalachia (in West Virginia) as London, UK, is from Hamburg, Germany. So I think it's a stretch to say they're in the same geographic area. [0] - https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2013/09/12/221845853/mountain-dew-mouth-is-destroying-appalachias-teeth https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2013/09/12/221845853/mo...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- CalChris 9y agoAbout half of Alabama is Appalachian. https://www.arc.gov/images/appregion/AppalachianRegionCountiesMap.pdf https://www.arc.gov/images/appregion/AppalachianRegionCounti...
- ischio 9y agoMaybe in "That Sugar Film" ?
- itronitron 9y agoa former co-worker of mine from there used to say that when a tornado touches down in Alabama it always hits a trailer park, because it can't not hit a trailer park
- patrickg_zill 9y agoI am sure that this news article has absolutely nothing to do with the special election on Dec 12th between Moore and Jones for Senate.
- katastic 9y agoAnd if it is a "3rd world" state, why aren't people jumping to donate and help and aid them? "Cuz 'rednecks." The only group you're allowed to prosecute on TV, media, and public discourse. But if liberals were running in and giving free aid, and helping lives, those people would start to like liberals. I mean, when we help people in Ghana, do we check to make sure they don't have any conflicting political values? When we aid Syria, have we checked to make sure they're there aren't any nationalists and racists? I'd love to hear an actual rebuttal, but I guess I'll have to settle for downvotes from people who can't. I guess bigotry is okay when it's people you hate.
- throwaway613834 9y ago> I mean, when we help people in Ghana, do we check to make sure they don't have any conflicting political values? I think there is a critical difference between Ghana and Alabama, and that is that Ghana does not have representatives in Congress making policy decisions affecting all of America.
- wdewind 9y ago> I mean, when we help people in Ghana, do we check to make sure they don't have any conflicting political values? When we aid Syria, have we checked to make sure they're there aren't any nationalists and racists? Basically, yes. We expend an enormous amount of effort making sure aid gets to the "right" people, and we have a track record of rescinding it when those people change their opinions to ones we don't like.
- futhey 9y agoUnfortunate headline. Would expect to see it changed. Growing up I spent a few years in Alabama. Not at all surprised by any of this, but it's not "the worst in the United States", or the developed world, by any stretch. Not that it's a competition, but census data would put a couple of states (I believe consistently Louisiana, West Virginia, & Arkansas) below Alabama in median household income.
- c2h5oh 9y agoIt's not about how poor or rich the state is, but what percentage of people live in poverty. The poverty definition used is living for less than 50% of median income in the area (in this case state) so it's more of an income inequality measure.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- prostoalex 9y agoThat seems like a gameable metric. Encourage the 5/10/50/100 highest-income individuals to establish their primary residence someplace else (in this case other state) and things will look very positive comparative-equality-wise.
- Spooky23 9y agoAs the GOP slashes federal spending, you’ll see that.
- Jesus_Jones 9y agoHah, being from Arkansas, we always said "Thank god for Mississippi". Arkansas was often 49th in many scales of poverty, MS was 50th. I'm sure Alabama has issues too.
- mythrwy 9y agoArticle has a picture of a falling down house. But guess what, it's a house! Go look under an overpass in San Francisco to see even more dire poverty and even less chance of self obtaining minimum standards of living (i.e food and basic shelter) as cost of shelter is so far removed from potential income. But probably stating California has worst poverty in developed world doesn't support the underlying motive of the article. Incidentally, Alabama does have a lot of poverty and isn't a place most of would be comfortable living due to social climate. Which is a real shame because I find it to be quite a beautiful state, at least the areas I've seen.
- gumby 9y agoSome data from the study mentioned in the Newsweek fluff piece: https://qz.com/879092/the-us-doesnt-look-like-a-developed-country/ https://qz.com/879092/the-us-doesnt-look-like-a-developed-co...
- marcoperaza 9y ago>The US has the second-highest rate of poverty among rich countries (poverty here measured by the percentage of people earning less than half the national median income That is a preposterous way to compare poverty between countries. By this definition, an American can make more money than a Frenchmen, but the former will be counted as poor and the latter not. And I reckon that we'd fair much better than the EU as a single entity under this standard. Measuring food security by obesity rates is also dumb. Americans are fat because food is incredibly abundant, we have a cultural preference for junk food, and we are physically lazy. That says absolutely nothing about the availability of healthy food. We are unhealthy individuals, but our health care system is the absolute best at treating diseases. We pay a lot for it because we’re the only developed country where the health care industry isn’t a monopsony (single or oligarchic purchaser). Our child mortality and life expectancy are conflated with a large immigrant population and the existence of an underclass. If you equalize the results for diversity, America does just as well as the other developed countries. And it is absurd to compare the entire US to tiny countries like Denmark or even medium sized ones like France. If you broke the US into regions, you’d probably get different results. I bet New England and the Pacific Northwest would be at the top of many of those categories. Basically, this data is framed with a conclusion in mind and doesn’t account for how big, diverse, and unique the United States.
- gumby 9y ago> We are unhealthy individuals, but our health care system is the absolute best at treating diseases. I have not seen evidence that this is correct, either statistical survey or personal experience (France, Germany, Australia, USA in my case). Do you have a citation?
- deleted 9y ago
- lewis22 9y agoIs it not to be expected that the part of America that is most predominately black has conditions that resemble other predominately black areas?
- RickJWag 9y ago<sigh> More politics on Hacker News. Tiring.
- Tempest1981 9y agoAlthough the "signal to noise" of HN political discussions is so good compared to everywhere else. Question: is there another community that has high-quality discussions on political issues? Would love to find one.
- thrden 9y agowell thats clearly untrue, because when adjusted for cost of living, California has a higher poverty rate[1] [1]http://www.politifact.com/california/statements/2017/jan/20/chad-mayes/true-california-has-nations-highest-poverty-rate-w/ http://www.politifact.com/california/statements/2017/jan/20/...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]