4 ms·
> The point is, we will need to figure out how to keep society going (economically, or specifically from a population welfare point of view) despite declining p
by emodendroket 9y ago
> The point is, we will need to figure out how to keep society going (economically, or specifically from a population welfare point of view) despite declining populations.
Nobody has that figured out. For now the answer for developed countries involves allowing in immigrants to make up for the deaths.
- mc32 9y agoThat happens to be the easy answer, but it's not necessarily the only answer. What happens when China enters pop decline? Pump more people into an already overpopulated country --that does not scale. Or when that hits India?
- emodendroket 9y agoIn what sense is China "overpopulated"? They have a large population but they also have a tremendous land mass, much of which is only sparsely populated.
- mc32 9y agoMost of the west of the country is not arable at all. Like Japan, they are relatively poor in terms of arable land. As people become wealthier, they consume more resources and want bigger houses --taking up more resources, including land (suburbanization). So even while suburbanization of China will be much more muted than in western countries, there is still a demand and expansion into previously arable lands.
- emodendroket 9y agoThere is no particular reason to think American post-war suburbanization is the natural way things would roll out, given that it is a result of specific policies and cultural tastes. And what's more, it's hard to see why people have to live in arable land in a world where no country produces all of the food it consumes.
- mc32 9y agoNever said American style suburbanization --that's your inference. If you ever travelled there you'd know farmland is being developed into housing. I'm sure you can do your own searches and verify[1]. [1]http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.2747/0272-3638.21.3.205 http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.2747/0272-3638.21.3.20...
- jackvalentine 9y ago> Never said American style suburbanization --that's your inference. Considering the cultural context of HN and the phrasing of your post I consider that a fair inference.
- PopsiclePete 9y agoAfrica seems to be the answer. Sub-Saharan Africa has a pretty high birth-rate. Countries like Ireland are already having issues with wonderful “culture” imports like female genital mutilation. Europe circa 2050 should be a pretty interesting place.
- alexasmyths 9y ago"Nobody has that figured out. For now the answer for developed countries involves allowing in immigrants to make up for the deaths." No - this is false. There's nothing to 'figure out'. We simply don't need as many people. We'll have to deal with it a some point in the future, but there is no imperative for America to keep adding more people willy nilly. The 'we must add bodies' ideal is just an extension of national corporatism.
- emodendroket 9y agoBesides elder care and pensions we also live under an economic system predicated on endless growth.
- alexasmyths 9y ago"we also live under an economic system predicated on endless growth." Yes, but it does not have to be this way. It's just the way it's designed for now.
- emodendroket 9y agoOf all the reasons you might seek a post-capitalist economic order "maintaining ethnic homogeneity" is among the least compelling to me.
- alexasmyths 9y agoThat's great. I suggest it's probably not a huge factor for most people. But there's a huge amount of information embedded into culture - ideas, mannerisms, forms of education, language, social strata - it goes far, far beyond 'language and cuisine'. Large scale immigration wipes that out and does not replace it with a new culture, rather, a 'globalized' set of values - and a Starbucks on every corner. So in the interests of having actual 'diversity' on planet earth, because as of today we are witnessing an 'extinction event' of culture, we might want to consider the impact of some of our policies. Immigrants (and FYI I've been an immigrant at stages of my own life) are mostly just regular people, and so we don't want to play into the hands of xenophobes or 'racial purists' or whatever, but at the same time, we have to recognize the imperative of culture itself. Is all.