Like most things in life, it depends. Just because it didn't work in your case doesn't mean it never works, that it's never a good idea, and that it's always a

Like most things in life, it depends. Just because it didn't work in your case doesn't mean it never works, that it's never a good idea, and that it's always a waste of time. For us, it's turned out to work really well, and we feel like the benefits outweigh the costs. Your mileage will vary. For some reason, though, this is a subject on which many people feel qualified to make pronouncements about the wisdom of what other people are doing. I have, for example, had a candidate come in for an interview, look at the office layout, lecture me for 15 minutes about how we must be idiots because we're killing our productivity with our open layout, and then leave because he'd refuse to work in a place like that. At least it saved me the other 45 minutes I would have had to spend interviewing the guy.