3 ms·
> It included inability to travel, participate in the political process, no significant right to dissent, the constant risk of losing one's livelihood (and 'per
by rdtsc 16y ago
> It included inability to travel, participate in the political process, no significant right to dissent, the constant risk of losing one's livelihood (and 'perks) for purely political reasons, severe restrictions on the ownership of private property, etc, etc, etc
That did not include engineers only. It was true for everyone. But that doesn't mean people were crying on the streets and committing suicide.
Engineers that never participated or cared to participate in dissent or political activities didn't have it bad. No homes with 2 car garages but a decent standard of living. A good apartment, healthcare, 1+ month seaside resort vacation, health care, education for your children. All those thing were included.
> Did Soviet engineers and scientists enjoy a fairly reasonable standard of living? Many did. But the comparison to the US and health care is ludicrous on its face.
They had a significantly better health even if they became unemployed than someone in US would have if they became unemployed (which is none at all).
> But the comparison to the US and health care is ludicrous on its face.
Why is it ridiculous? I will take ex Soviet health care rather than no health care or healthcare that results in you having to sell your house and live on the streets. They had good doctors and stressed preventive care just as much as emergency care (which is the case in US nowadays for many who cannot afford health insurance).
You can bash the political system all you want. I am with you with that. But I don't think you know what you are talking about when it comes to other stuff.
If you don't mind me asking, have you lived there or are you just taking an wild guess?
> Did Soviet engineers and scientists enjoy a fairly reasonable standard of living? Many did.
I thought that is the whole point of this discussion thread...
- jacquesm 16y agoIt's funny how even more than 20 years after the fact there can still be such misunderstandings about the realities on the ground. You'd say that the days of having to misrepresent the situation 'on the other side' of the iron curtain were long over but it's far from that. Let me try to give an outsiders perspective: - crime: - nearly non-existent, except when perpetrated by officials - education: - not quite as good as the top schools in the west for many subjects but *very* good in some, such as math, engineering and such - unemployment: - non-existent. For everybody, no matter how low on the totem pole there was a job, even if it meant bad pay and long hours. But bad pay and long hours are to be found in plenty of places, the USA and Canada are no exception to this - health care - free. And of a reasonable standard. Ok, you wouldn't be able to get some fancy surgery so your life expectancy wasn't quite up to it from that point of view, but on the whole I would say it was simpler, more humane and in many ways better than some of the more extreme cases in the west (Terri Schiavo anybody?) - happiness: - difficult to gauge. People that I knew when living in the east block compared to the west before the fall of the wall and the 'iron curtain' were on the whole as happy or happier than those that I knew in the west. Friendships were real and lasted a lifetime in many cases, family ties were fairly closely knit and children were on the whole loved and safe, much safer than those 'free' children in the west. Again, officials would occasionally mess things up for the people but in this respect people did form a block. - information - Even though the punishments were severe there was a lively underground in the form of samizdat (sp?) and 'culture houses' were movies from the west were shown to friends. And not just the Hollywood movies, also those from other countries. So the people there had a limited view of what was going on in the rest of the world through the official channels, which mostly read like 'good news' and 'motivational' stories. (I recall one front page article about a girl that had broken the record in nursing her kid or something to that effect), it was seriously delayed but between the drip feed of information from travelers, radio free europe, the bbc world service and a whole pile of other channels people were remarkably well informed. - standard of living - about the same as in the west 25 years earlier. So colour tv's were fairly common but so were b&w sets relatively few people with a quality car, plenty of two-strokes (trabant, wartburg, syrena, polonez zil, dacia and other brands that you may have never heard of) Plenty of stuff only available by waiting for years, lots of stuff that you'd take for granted in the west inexplicably unavailable, not unexceptional for 'hamstering' behaviour of a few individuals to cause shortages in for instance toilet paper, light bulbs and stockings. Very lively black market. For the most part people had fairly healthy food on the table, but they were structurally short on things like fruit and fresh vegetables out of season. - your job - your job is, unless you are a lucky person and you're in some prestigious place probably terribly boring tons of layers of bureaucracy slow everything down to a crawl. Procuring the simplest of items required to do your job require endless forms and always at least three signatures and two stamps. Promotion is hardly ever, and when it happens it tends to ignore your proficiency in favor of someone with better connections. On the whole the 'general workforce' takes work for granted and produces enough to get by but stellar performances are the exception. If you want to advance there is a path, but it leads through the 'party', and if you're good at something then doors can be opened provided you dance to the tune. If you're in to sports then you can go quite far too. - mentality - there is a low-key paranoia that pervades society, don't let you guard down in front of strangers, you never know if they're taking names or informing. Everybody knows somebody that knows somebody that disappeared, but hardly anybody knows somebody that disappeared (and why), but it definitely does happen. Anybody from Poland, Russia or one of the other former SovBlock countries is welcome to correct this.
- rdtsc 16y ago> Friendships were real and lasted a lifetime in many cases, family ties were fairly closely knit and children were on the whole loved and safe, much safer than those 'free' children in the west. That is what I miss. We used to spend more time together. It is not that we didn't work hard, we did, but there was just more time to spend with the family and friends. Then after the collapse for some reason people, even in my extended family, changed. They started hating each other more. There is less sencerity and closeness. It is hard to explain. Interesting that you noticed that as well. I thought it only happened to my family....
- jacquesm 16y agoI was wondering if I should write that all out, I wrote it a few hours ago, then decided not to post it because it's overlong but then changed my mind because I think this needs to be said. I hope you find the picture on the whole accurate, it's from my no doubt faulty recollection, I hope I haven't romanticised or glossed over the bad parts. There are plenty more paragraphs that I could add about for instance the army, the jokes, the police, the drinking and so on, but I think it's enough like this.
- rdtsc 16y agoThank you for posting that. All those points resonated with me. It made me think of the past and remember.
- othermaciej 16y agoMy family lived in Poland when I was young. We ended up leaving when my father was imprisoned for his political activities (he was involved in the Solidarity movement). Two points of comparison I can give: (1) In America, members of my immediate family have political views that are in some way wacky or out of the mainstream, and we've never worried for a second about prison being a consequence. (2) When we first came to America, we were literally on welfare and lived in a poor/ghetto neighborhood, until my parents learned enough English to get good jobs. Yet this was still a much higher standard of living than what we'd had in Poland, where both of my parents worked as engineers. Much larger apartment, more food, better clothes. No more ration cards for meat and chocolate. Stores that, instead of tiny and half-empty, are giant and piled high with goods. Oranges and bananas just lying around in stores as if they are everyday things, not rare exotic luxuries. (3) On health care - there were many extremely well-trained and competent doctors in Poland. But availability of equipment and medicine was very extremely poor and hospitals were not well maintained by US standards. Also, medical knowledge among typical doctors, especially on rare diseases or chronic conditions, seemed far behind the US. (4) I've been back to Poland a few times since the fall of communism. Conditions have very visibly and vastly improved. Apartments are still tiny, but there's plenty of stores piled with goods, bustling cafes and restaurants, and so forth. Construction going on everywhere. Cars are now mostly quality European, America, Japanese and Korean brands. No more Communist-era junkers. Poland now meets the usual European standard of fresh produce that is substantially better quality than what you can get in the typical US supermarket. Western media is everywhere. Many of the cities look quite lively and vibrant. The city that I think most bears the scars of past suffering is Warsaw - it was completely destroyed by the Nazis (particularly including any historic or cultural buildings) and rebuilt by the Communists. Check out the Palace of Culture and Science for another marvel of Soviet engineering: <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warsaw_Palace_of_Culture_and_Science> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warsaw_Palace_of_Culture_and_Sc.... (5) In the US, where I work in the computer industry, I believe I have a higher standard of living overall than probably even the top party leaders in Communist-era Poland. (6) Math and science education was quite good compared to the US, at the elementary and secondary level, but not at the college level. I think this is a European cultural thing, not a Communist thing, it remains true today, and is true in most European countries. American math & science education in elementary school and high school is a joke, excepting special magnet schools or AP classes. (7) My impression is that the Communist era is somewhat more romanticized in Russia than in other former Eastern Bloc countries. Particularly the more Western-oriented countries like Poland, Czech and Hungary see that period as one of being imperialist vassal states. Overall, there's no way, not even the slightest chance, that I'd trade the "free" health care and "non-existent" unemployment for the freedom and wealth of America, or even for the way Poland is now.