3 ms·
I completely disagree with this for several reasons. The main reason is that the article, sells short engineers abilities. Let's look at software engineering,
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
I completely disagree with this for several reasons. The main reason is that the article, sells short engineers abilities.
Let's look at software engineering, because that is what I am most familiar with.
First, not every problem has a well defined solution. For example, trying to decide what is the best way to pack a truck for deliveries is essentially the knapsack problem and has no solution that we could actually implement. Instead, what is done is to use heuristics to find an approximate solution.
In addition, in software engineering, there is such a thing as a desire to write beautiful and elegant code and design. Those things don't have an objective definition, but a subjective definition. Software engineers will try to write that kind of code and will discuss and debate the various methods of achieving that (look at the whole functional programming debates).
Finally, the article makes it seem like everybody's morals and values are so different. It over exaggerates the differences. The vast majority of people want things according to Maslow's hierarchy of needs https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow%27s_hierarchy_of_needs https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow%27s_hierarchy_of_need.... They generally want government to make sure the lowest 2 levels (physiological needs - ie clean drinking water, food, etc and security - low crime, rule of law, etc) are provided while being allowed to pursue the things higher up the pyramid.
What was described above is an optimization problem. Sure, there is no feasible and probable perfect solution. However, engineers deal with this all the time. Most code that is written does not have formal proofs. Often heuristics are used and measurements of performance in common scenarios bare taken. The same approach can also be used with social issues. Experienced engineers are also good at communicating to the rest of the team why a certain approach is a good one. This communication skills can also be used in the social arenas.
Thus don't let this article discourage you. Engineers do have the ability to deal with ambiguity and tradeoffs and communicate about them and can be excellent leaders.
- ubersoldat2k7 9y agoI agree with you. The best managers I've had have done software before or keep doing it, as I hope someday too.
- paraschopra 9y agoAuthor here. > First, not every problem has a well defined solution. For example, trying to decide what is the best way to pack a truck for deliveries is essentially the knapsack problem and has no solution that we could actually implement. Instead, what is done is to use heuristics to find an approximate solution. But even if optimal solutions are not to be found, you can state it objectively and know it's an unsolvable problem and so you interpret results in the same light. In human system, you cannot even state the problem objectively. >Finally, the article makes it seem like everybody's morals and values are so different. It over exaggerates the differences. If I was overexaggerating, we wouldn't have ISIS, Korea and many other cultures that pose threat to human existence every now and then. The difference of opinions is all around us, just open any news website.
- QAPereo 9y agoJust to a reminder that there are two Koreas, and one of them probably doesn’t deserve to be lumped in with ISIS.
- naasking 9y ago> But even if optimal solutions are not to be found, you can state it objectively and know it's an unsolvable problem There are plenty of problems in computer science where even the existence of a solution is unknown. > If I was overexaggerating, we wouldn't have ISIS, Korea and many other cultures that pose threat to human existence every now and then. All terrible ideologies employ the same mechanisms to encourage otherwise good people to do terrible things: they dehumanize "others". They simply differ in who they classify as the out group. Disagreements are then driven less by opinion than prejudice. Even bleeding hearts leftists employ these tactics. Take a pill and see how many would sit down and have e a civil meal with Trump.
- jakelazaroff 9y ago> For example, trying to decide what is the best way to pack a truck for deliveries is essentially the knapsack problem and has no solution that we could actually implement. NP-Complete problems can't be solved in polynomial time, but they can still be solved algorithmically, and the solution to an instance of a problem is perfectly well-defined.