4 ms·
For all of the times that I've had to work from home and forgot my charger at work, I'm glad that Apple didn't decide to use the power vampire configuration in
by busterarm 9y ago
For all of the times that I've had to work from home and forgot my charger at work, I'm glad that Apple didn't decide to use the power vampire configuration in the MBP.
Intel dropped the ball here. There are battery life expectations in the prosumer market and Apple would not have come close to them withing sticking to the low power configuration.
It's also not even remotely the only laptop brand that made that same decision.
- mschuster91 9y ago> There are battery life expectations in the prosumer market That's what the MacBook line was supposed to cover, and MacBook Pro, like the name said, was the professional line. > It's also not even remotely the only laptop brand that made that same decision. But from those brands which cater to enterprises, there is always the ultra-high-power lineup that power users can choose from. HP has the EliteBook range, Dell the XPS range and Lenovo the ThinkPad P. Some of them I can even order with 64GB RAM. Apple leaves me at a quarter of the RAM. Apple has left power users like me standing in the rain. The problem is that it's really hard to switch, because Windows 7 nears its end of business and I won't touch anything above it with a 10 feet pole due to privacy and UI problems, and Linux is way too buggy when it comes to energy efficiency, new hardware support or proper support for Optimus and friends. Of course Hackintosh would at least solve the UI problems but it's difficult enough on a desktop platform, and I would never dare to use a Hackintosh for work stuff due to the legal issues.
- busterarm 9y ago> That's what the MacBook line was supposed to cover, and MacBook Pro, like the name said, was the professional line. That ship sailed away pretty much right around when Intel Macs started shipping. Stop clinging to the past, honestly. That market is deader than dead in every brand. Even Thinkpads. Especially Thinkpads. The only strong market (read: at the scale that Apple sells products) that exists for performance (read: 17") laptops is in gaming. It's also _tiny_.
- mschuster91 9y ago> Stop clinging to the past, honestly. Not much to cling for, actually - I jumped ship from Windows only three years ago and back then, it was fine. The problem is that software seems to have evolved as if RAM is an infinite resource (hello, Electron apps, especially Slack). Windows ecosystem has kept up with the demand, Apple... not so much. > That market is deader than dead in every brand. But it nevertheless exists in every major brand, and big companies buy them en masse, or at least: enough of them to make the manufacturing of these models worth itself. Only exception is Apple, and that's part of why professionals are highly afraid that Apple has lost its track.
- busterarm 9y ago> The problem is that software seems to have evolved as if RAM is an infinite resource (hello, Electron apps, especially Slack) This is a point I'm 100% in agreement with you on! :) > But it nevertheless exists in every major brand, and big companies buy them en masse, or at least: enough of them to make the manufacturing of these models worth itself. I used to be in a role where I had purchasing information for computers for a nationwide big-box retail chain. You would be surprised at how low the order quantity on some of those 17" laptops is. I'm not talking about for the stores but for the manufacturer. Often it's in the low thousands (per market, of which there's really only 4 and for those laptops really 2). Those big laptops are a price anchor to sell more mid-range laptops that have higher margins. Big laptops get the least amount of hardware design engineering effort/QA. Their volume is low enough that the support costs are minimal, even if many of them malfunction or fail. Toshiba in particular is notorious for this. Apple sells north of 5 million Mac computers a quarter. A freakin' quarter! It is absolutely not profitable for them to divert attention to low volume products. The opportunity cost lost is enormous. They could spend their efforts making the existing inventory a fraction of a percent cheaper or more successful and it would dwarf any profits made from a 17" laptop. Most of those other brands can afford to sell 'performance' laptops mainly because they have to: they aren't selling 20 million laptops a year. Keep in mind, PC sales have _cratered_ and Lenovo is bleeding money. So is HP, but this year they had an up year...mostly off of selling Chromebooks.
- dahauns 9y agoWhich brand in this market actually made the same decision? I honestly can't think of one.
- busterarm 9y agoAre you kidding? Every single laptop brand with a thin model went for the low-power 16GB, long-battery life configuration. Look at Lenovo!
- dahauns 9y agoRemember, we're talking about MacBookPro class here: ~2kg, 45W TDP Quadcore, dedicated graphics. Lenovo T-Series: DDR4. HP Zbook: DDR4. Dell XPS/Precision: DDR4. Asus Zenbook Pro: DDR4. Or did you really want to compare with an x1 carbon? Apples and oranges.