44 ms·
Updated part: Note added later: Some people have pointed out online that if MINIX had a GPL license, Intel might not have used it since then it would have h
by signa11 9y ago
Updated part:
Note added later:
Some people have pointed out online that if MINIX had a GPL
license, Intel might not have used it since then it would
have had to publish the modifications to the code. Maybe yes,
maybe no, but the modifications were no doubt technical
issues involving which mode processes run in, etc. My
understanding, however, is that the small size and modular
microkernel structure were the primary attractions. Many
people (including me) don’t like the idea of an all-powerful
management engine in there at all (since it is a possible
security hole and a dangerous idea in the first place), but
that is Intel’s business decision and a separate issue from
the code it runs. A company as big as Intel could obviously
write its own OS if it had to. My point is that big companies
with lots of resources and expertise sometimes use
microkernels, especially in embedded systems. The L4
microkernel has been running inside smartphone chips for
years. I certainly hope Intel did thorough security hardening
and testing before deploying the chip, since apparently an
older version of MINIX was used. Older versions were
primarily for education and newer ones were for high
availability. Military-grade security was never a goal.
Second note added later:
The online discussion got completely sidetracked from my
original points as noted above. For the record, I would like
to state that when Intel contacted me, they didn’t say what
they were working on. Companies rarely talk about future
products without NDAs. I figured it was a new Ethernet chip
or graphics chip or something like that. If I had suspected
they might be building a spy engine, I certainly wouldn’t
have cooperated, even though all they wanted was reducing the
memory footprint (= chip area for them). I think creating
George Orwell’s 1984 is an extremely bad idea, even if Orwell
was off by about 30 years. People should have complete
control over their own computers, not Intel and not the
government. In the U.S. the Fourth Amendment makes it very
clear that the government is forbidden from searching
anyone’s property without a search warrant. Many other
countries have privacy laws that are in the same spirit.
Putting a possible spy in every computer is a terrible
development.