7 ms·
Not to disagree with any of the other points, but it's always worth remembering that any physical utility in the US has approximately 16x more land to cover tha
by falcolas 9y ago
Not to disagree with any of the other points, but it's always worth remembering that any physical utility in the US has approximately 16x more land to cover than France. Not to mention the greater variety in climates (which do impact utilities).
Some cities only have one existing fiber line even coming into them, usually owned by one of the local duopolies (typically phone, since they originally were required to offer phone service to everybody).
This gives incumbents an immediate advantage in terms of reaching customers with physical infrastructure, before counting any of the (admittedly fucked) politics involved.
- AndyMcConachie 9y agoThen why do Americans in large urban centers not have greater choice of ISPs? If it's all about physical distance, why is there still no competition in dense areas? I live in Washington DC, in the city, and I only really have one choice where I live, Comcast.
- pmorici 9y agoCities grant franchise rights and determine rates charged for access to city poles and cable vaults.
- parenthephobia 9y agoIncumbent ISPs lobby local govermment and sue would-be competitors to ensure the competition are only offered access on less favourable terms.
- philjohn 9y agoLet's not sugar coat the language by referring to them as franchise rights, they're state-sanctioned monopolies.
- pmorici 9y agoWell, sure if they decide to only grant a single franchise which is what happens in a lot of cases. There is no reason they can't allow several competing operators in a given city though.
- nerdponx 9y agoIt's spotty. I know in DC they have RCN in some areas, which is a high-quality option. In NYC, in one apartment I had 3 or 4 differennt ISPs to choose from, RCN included. In my current place, I only have one.
- amigoingtodie 9y agoBack in my day, we rented Ricochet modems and shared the bandwidth between 4 users.
- BrandoElFollito 9y agoThe solution to this problem in France was to say "if you put some infrastructure to provide a service you have to share it with others, and get some costback". The costback is regulated. The idea is to make it better for people, not corporations (which are not starving either)