6 ms·
The FCC says Net Neutrality cripples investment, but that's not true
- DiThi 9y agoI keep seeing everywhere comments against Net Neutrality using this argument. And saying that it cripples free market, because new ISPs wouldn't be able to compete having the expense of regulatory compliance. But _nobody_, absolutely no one explained to me _why_ would it cost even a cent to ensure Net Neutrality (that is not part of ensuring a quality service in general). We should ask this more when discussing that argument, because it seems there's a lot of people truly believing this having that notion unchallenged.
- betterunix2 9y agoThe net neutrality order from 2015 did more than just mandate network neutrality. It also requires ISPs to keep certain records, possibly beyond their business needs (and other legal mandates). It also requires ISPs to make information available to the public via their own websites, which costs at least a cent ;). Yes, it's all weak and such costs would be covered by just one month of customer bill payment, but ISPs like to complain and Ajit Pai has made a big show of addressing these costs. For example, the FCC will host information about ISP practices for any ISP that finds it too burdensome to have a website of their own. One bit of irony here is that the ISPs have argued that there is too much uncertainty surrounding the Title II regulations. Today the FCC does not impose rate regulation, for example, but maybe tomorrow's FCC will. Of course, now it is becoming clear that the rules will change whenever the presidency changes parties, so if anything it would seem that there is far more regulatory uncertainty with Pai's approach.
- cvsh 9y ago>Today the FCC does not impose rate regulation, for example, but maybe tomorrow's FCC will. Of course, now it is becoming clear that the rules will change whenever the presidency changes parties, so if anything it would seem that there is far more regulatory uncertainty with Pai's approach. This is also why the health insurance industry was overwhelmingly opposed to the Republican healthcare plan, why the financial industry was opposed to certain Republican regulation rollbacks, etc. All the infrastructure they'd built to refocus their business around the regulations might now be useless, but probably not, because there's a decent chance the Democrats might recapture the Senate and/or Presidency in 4-8 years. Uncertainty is expensive and exhausting. Businesses are desperate for a compromise that lasts. Drastic and potentially ephemeral GOP regulation-slashing really serves no one except their own donor class -- not even big business, let alone small business and the middle class.
- DiThi 9y agoThanks, you're the first person that explain me the costs. Not totally free but almost, and vastly cheaper than a 10% figure I saw in some comments. Where can I read more information about those requirements without having to read the full law?
- twoodfin 9y agoComcast sells digital video services for hefty subscription fees to tens of millions of its customers. Those video services presumably use bandwidth that could be used by Google, Netflix or any of a dozen other competitors if the customer preferred. Under Title II, what stops the FCC from mandating that Comcast “open the box” and allow all competitors access to that bandwidth in a neutral fashion? That’s the argument. Title II is just a framework for regulations that could potentially turn ISPs into true “dumb pipes”. While many have convinced themselves that would be great for everyone, there’s not a lot of money in the dumb pipe business. To put it another way: 10 cent SMS messages built a lot of cell towers!
- raverbashing 9y agoStill, that's "last mile" bandwidth Owning the network it's much easier to cache at the boundary But apparently it's easier and cheaper to lobby instead of doing the smart thing
- twoodfin 9y agoWhat about Title II do you think makes boundary caching untouchable by regulators as well? Remember, this is the framework created to bring Ma Bell to heel. Why should Comcast be allowed to build “fast lanes” for their own NBC content and exclude Netflix, just because the delivery vector is an IP cable box instead of an IP WLAN hub?
- jessaustin 9y agoRemember, this is the framework created to bring Ma Bell to heel. Is this irony? In what sense has Ma Bell been brought to heel? Do you mean that ATT and VZN haven't yet merged? Perhaps you mean that neither of them has yet consumed CenturyLink? notes: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15756334 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15756334
- libertyEQ 9y agoIt was the 1930's, and since that time the baby Bells have slowly re-merged. You mentioned CenturyLink (formerly USWest) ans Cincinnati Bell also still exists, as well as some other remnants elsewhere. Many people make the argument the the Communications act of '96 stifled DSL, which pushed data heavy users to cable internet as soon as it was available. Given how things stand, and who is in power, I think it would be best to be pushing for further deregulation in telecom, since that is the argument they are making. They need to put up or shut up.
- drieddust 9y agoUnregulated Capitalism in the very reason monopolies are created. Founder of Capitalism favoured an economy where a lot of small companies competed together to the benefit of consumers. He also recommended regulations where natural monopolies arise due to limited supply. As an example, he recommended heavy taxes on rent seeking[1]. This is a case of American Capitalism taken to its logically conclusion where any regulation makes it anti competitive. American psyche is so attuned to "Free Market" that anything lazy argument will be invoked. On the contrary we have Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) in India which has done wonders for us. Our market is highly regulated, yet we enjoy cheapest ISP services. We have also favoured Net Neutrality by opposing Facebook[2] when they came knocking on our door and now its part of our regulations after a year long deliberation [3]. [1] https://www.prosper.org.au/about/geoists-in-history/adam-smith-on-the-rentier/ https://www.prosper.org.au/about/geoists-in-history/adam-smi... [2] http://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/technology/internet/TRAI-rules-in-favour-of-Net-neutrality/article14068029.ece http://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/technology/internet/TRAI-ru... [3] http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/trai-differential-data-pricing-regulations-net-neutrality/1/1104985.html http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/trai-differential-data-pr...
- rdtsc 9y ago> We have also favoured Net Neutrality by opposing Facebook[2] Interesting, wonder if Indians see it as a tiny bit ironic that Facebook then turns around and campaigns for net neutrality is US. Once were in the position to be the ISP (effectively), they had no issue taking Verizon's side.
- drieddust 9y agoCompanies will be opportunistic. OT but I am not sure why AntiTrust is not invoked against Facebook. They don't have any competition and have done things which can be considered abuse of position.
- eropple 9y agoThey have lots of competition. Twitter, LinkedIn, Snapchat (especially among younger sets), etc. They don't have vertically-integrated competition, granted, but they have enough competition to point at to be left alone.
- rectang 9y agoSupposedly "anti-regulation" forces energetically oppose Net Neutrality -- but don't expect them to follow through and remove the regulations that protect the telco monopolies. "Anti-regulation" rhetoric against Net Neutrality is either sock puppetry or useful idiocy.
- betterunix2 9y agoActually, I and a number of other engineers submitted comments on this proceeding to that effect. Pai's argument is, in part, that ISPs provide access to information services (social networking sites, email, video streaming, etc.) and should therefore be considered information services. Of course, any form of communication, even carrier pigeons, can be used to communicate over the Internet, so in theory what he is saying is that nothing can be regulated under Title II. The FCC's draft rules respond to this objection by simply dismissing it. The draft rules basically dismiss all commentary that did not come from ISPs as "not persuasive." The only reason any of those comments were cited at all is to prove that all submitted commentary was considered, something that is legally required of them.
- Delmania 9y agoOn multiple occasions, Pai has indicated he is going to roll these rules back regardless of what anyone says. He did claim that he would entertain a sound argument proving that Title II hasn't hurt investment, but the only way to prove that is with the cooperation of the entities that stand to profit. This is why there is a good chance this will be tied in the federal courts. The comment process is supposed to prevent an "arbitrary and capricious" decision by a federal agency. Pai's comments could be used to make a persuasive argument that this is arbitrary (says we're desperate doesn't help). Capricious is a much harder thing to prove. I think the fact that data shows the comment period was tainted by foreign entities, false entries, and that 98.5% of the valid comments were in support of NN could use to show this is capricious in that his actions show a disregard for the consumer.
- jswizzy 9y agoNice Ad Hominem
- Crontab 9y agoIn my opinion, FCC chairman Ajit Pai is corrupt as hell. The only reason to make this change is corporate donors.
- guest 9y agoEqual chance to compete stifles investment and hampers the market - didnt you know? Trust the rich and currently powerfull.powerfull.
- philamonster 9y agoI live in a small-ish market in the Northeast that has been under Time Warner's thumb (now Spectrum) for some time. Since moving here ~2012 there has been the promise of fiber to the home by a small local ISP. To everyone's surprise, and even TWC, expansion started really happening in 2016 and has exploded since for this same small ISP. They're relying on actual order fulfillment with payment once property easements are settled and engineering completes in what they designate as individual districts. With packages promising 100mbit/10mbit as base for $50/month and up to 1gbps/100mbps for $100 ($110 for static IP) TWC couldn't come close (30mbit/5mbit for $70+ at the time I was able to switch in spring 2016). This expansion prompted TWC to expand their packages after the Charter merger but they still cannot deliver what this now growing ISP can promise at similar cost. This is what Net Neutrality means to these large ISP's. Giving equal footing to consumers and small businesses they have been fleecing for so long though nowhere near actually being equal. It's clear people are fed up and can express that. Pai & his FCC removing any semblance of voice to that public is shameful and unethical and clearly, as has been stated over the previous months, not based in fact.
- Simon_says 9y agoWhich city? I'm moving there.
- swozey 9y agoChattanooga, TN has municipal broadband provided by the utilities company. They have 10gig connections for $300/mo. https://epb.com/home-store/internet#pricing https://epb.com/home-store/internet#pricing
- shmageggy 9y agoHi neighbor. After the Charter merger Spectrum dropped my grandfathered $35 plan, so now I'm switching to <small local ISP> since I'm lucky enough to have enough interest in my neighborhood to have service from them. Glad to FINALLY have some competition around here.
- philamonster 9y ago
- kjrose 9y agoWhile I agree it doesn’t cripple some investment. I can see how it can cripple other investments. It’s essentially choosing a winner and declaring the other folks to be utilities without actually calling them utilities.
- tzs 9y agoWho is the winner and who are the other folks? I've seen some similar language from some politicians, but they have been confused over the difference between an ISP and a web site. To use a meat space analogy, they can't tell the difference between a taxi company and Walmart, and think that they both should fall under the same regulatory framework and have the same rules.
- kjrose 9y agoThe roads are still privately owned in the net neutrality analogy. So the government isn’t paying to maintain or upgrade them. However the taxi companies also don’t have any direct payments or influence since the roada must remain neutral. If we want net neutrality than make the roads a public good. To do this FCC political play is just silliness.
- Kadin 9y ago> If we want net neutrality than make the roads a public good That would be nice, but unfortunately the same corporate interests that are presently disassembling net neutrality rules already prohibited public-sector projects that might compete with them and interfere with their monopoly rents. There is no feasible route to public ownership of the infrastructure at the moment; ensuring reasonable and non-discriminatory access to it, on the basis of that infrastructure only existing due largely to license and permitting agreements (use of public land, pole leases, etc.), is -- or rather was, until last November's election -- a reasonable step in the right direction. I wouldn't mind a public conversation, though, about seizing last-mile infrastructure and making it a public good, just as a sort of Overton Window-shifting maneuver. Right now the momentum favors the ISPs, and they are going to continue to consolidate their monopoly positions and extract maximum rents from consumers while the regulatory environment favors them. Blunting the momentum and inevitability of their regulatory takeover would be good, although I'm pessimistic about being able to do it in the near term.
- perlpimp 9y agoNet neutrality cripples rent extraction by semi-institutionalized quasi monopolies and tapestry of highly bureaucratic resistant to instant competition environment.
- CodeWriter23 9y agoI’m pretty sure I can explain the decline in investment in 2015. The tl;dr version: Time Warner cooked the books by cutting spending on essential maintenance during the proposed acquisition by Comcast. Here’s why I come to that conclusion. In early 2015, I had TWC Business Class installed at our Downtown LA warehouse. One day, the time between scanning a shipment to print the shipping documents and the acknowledgment beep from the system grew from sub-second to 15-30 seconds. The scanning would trigger access to an internet-hosted database to update the order, and would initiate a label request to our postage provider. The label requests would time out. It was huge headache for us. I begin my investigation by pinging my local router. Nice 1-2ms responses. Pinged the modem, again 1-2ms responses. Tried pinging 8.8.8.8 and WOW! 1200-15000ms response times. FIFTEEN SECONDS for an ICMP request/reply! And a lot of packet loss to boot. I worked around the problem by using my phone as a hot spot for the computers in the warehouse. I called TWC and since it was Business Class, they rolled a truck within 4 hours. The tech was from a third-party contractor and was very competent by all appearances. He was astonished by my observations. He put his scope on the line in my unit and saw a minor deviation in signal loss. He replaced the drop from the pole to my unit, and said the female receptacle on the pole looked a little worn so he moved the new drop to a new location on the terminal. And the ping times went back. But the story doesn't end there; in fact this went on for nearly 2 months. During periods of the day, the lag and timeouts would occur. I improved the software to add some retries to the postage provider if the label request failed. I started pinging 8.8.8.8 on a constant basis so I could show the patterns of packet loss and high latency. About the third visit from the same tech, he told me that card in my local node was oversubscribed. He said a single card was intended to serve about 250 customers and that my card had about 600 customers on it. I hammered on TWC for weeks. I coordinated with my neighbors who understood what "oversubscribed" meant and spoke decent English to do the same. After about 8 weeks, the same tech came knocking and told me the node had been upgraded and wanted to check in. Ping times were great. We had no problems after that. Sounds like a one-off just bad luck, right? Not so fast. Fast forward about a year. The TWC/Comcast merger is off. I'm sitting at home one day, using my TWC consumer service. Something took to long to load, so I looked a little further, and what do you know? Long ass ping times to 8.8.8.8 and packet loss. I call. I have to wait days for the truck to arrive because I'm not Business Class at home. One tech comes out and observes a few db of signal loss and decides to replace the drop from the pole. I point out the drop was only about 2 years old and was replaced due to a different problem. It's now a two man job, and we wait for the second tech. Once he arrives, they cheerfully install a new drop, and then the problem didn't go away. I told them based on my experience I thought the local node was oversubscribed. They punted and said someone else would come the following day. They arrive with two techs and a lead or engineer. The lead calls various plays to rule out numerous things. After about an hour, they have ruled everything out. He confirms my local node has an excess of subscribers on it but they had not seen it causing this kind of problem before. He pulls up a network schematic on his ToughBook, and isolates the identifier of my local node. Then he switches to - THE SMOKING GUN - a list of about 25 or 30 node identifiers, each with a date in the second column. It's a maintenance schedule to upgrade the nodes that they let languish during the TWC/Comcast acquisition phase. He tells me my node will be upgraded in about 3 months and they leave. About 3 months later, I got a follow up call. Things worked fine, case closed. I filed a story tip with Ars Technica about this. They never got back to me.
- nkkollaw 9y agoI'm European so I have no idea, but does the FCC not exist to protect you from things similar to what themselves are proposing!?
- Kadin 9y agoIt used to, but the current administration is intentionally handing the control of various regulatory agencies over to the industries that they regulate. There is little reason in trying to argue with those in charge of the FCC, EPA, etc., because they very obviously don't care about arguments based on public benefit or their agencies' traditional mission. They are interested in creating a regulatory environment that is more profitable for the entrenched players, that is all. And they are going to do that, as long as they have the power to do so, and damn what anyone has to say about it. Ajit motherfucking Pai doesn't care what anyone in the public sphere thinks about him; he's almost certainly doing what he's doing, in full knowledge of how hated it's going to make him, in exchange for some sort of payback on the back end that he believes is worthwhile. Presumably "fuck you" money; enough that he thinks he can live comfortably and ignore the people he pissed off to get there. I do not think that there is much that can be done, presently, to stop these people. However, I do think there is, or rather will be, an opportunity once they leave office to discourage anyone from doing it again, by doing all that is possible to prevent them from simply retiring comfortably from the public eye and enjoying their ill-gotten wealth. Anything that can be done to disrupt their lives on a personal level, keep the public aware of their doings and whereabouts, and prevent them from knowing peace, will be a good warning to others who might consider doing the same. I have no faith in the legal system to do this, so it will need to be done extralegally through the press and social pressure.
- nkkollaw 9y agoThanks for the ELI5.