4 ms·
> But the never mention the most simplest: that broadband monopolies can just charge customers more money. They already do. Comcast and Co. simply charge users
by shmerl 9y ago
> But the never mention the most simplest: that broadband monopolies can just charge customers more money.
They already do. Comcast and Co. simply charge users extra, if they want to avoid data caps. They only can get away with it because they are monopolists.
What it means in practice, that they basically make competing services more expensive, giving edge to their own which they obviously don't count against those caps.
So why would libertarians support such garbage behavior? The answer is, they wouldn't. So I don't buy his argument that he is a libertarian.
> The answer is that the claim "monopoly" power is a deception.
Yeah, right. Ignoring reality won't change the facts.
- tptacek 9y agoWhy would anybody tell you they oppose NN if you will brand them as bad-faith interlocutors by definition for opposing it?
- shmerl 9y agoI've never seen a single argument against NN, which explained how repealing it won't allow current monopolists run amok with all the anti-competitive garbage they are known to engage in. So you don't need to explain anything, but I'll treat those who hold such position as corrupted shills or those who are manipulated and don't put any thought into the matter.
- tptacek 9y agoI think perhaps the reason you never see arguments against NN is that you participate primarily in forums where people who oppose NN get shouted down as "shills" before they can make a point. Even I engage this topic gingerly on HN, and I took the other side on "NSA vs. Snowden" here.
- shmerl 9y agoA simpler reason is, that no one of NN opponents have any good arguments to present. And shills' arguments are easily debunked. That's why shills don't like public debates and avoid answering direct questions.
- monkeywork 9y agoI'm pro nn but maybe the reason no debates or enters discussions is that you poison the well before they get the chance. If this was a topic we differed on I'd skip talking to you as well since you come off as someone who is fanatically locked to their mindset anyway (so why waste the effort) as well given how you chose to start the engagement of question if I really want to deal with your attitude. don't expect ppl to debate or discuss with you if you belittle them and don't enter the discussion in good faith.
- shmerl 9y agoI don't expect debates with shills indeed. As above, they can't even have a debate because their whole argument is based on lies. Calling out liars is not belittling.
- wglb 9y agoThis and your other commentary in this thread is against the guidelines. Calling commentators who don’t agree with your position is not civil discourse.
- shmerl 9y agoMy remark wasn't about commentators, but about those who oppose NN in general without any valid arguments. And I'm not afraid of criticizing that, instead of whitewashing as just another opinion.