3 ms·
> Republicans have been very united in opposition to net neutrality Does it indicate all of them are corrupt? Because only corrupt shills oppose it willingly.
by shmerl 9y ago
> Republicans have been very united in opposition to net neutrality
Does it indicate all of them are corrupt? Because only corrupt shills oppose it willingly.
- jopsen 9y agoEven if they are not all bought, it's unlikely that none of the Democrats have been bought. I'm not saying the two parties are even. Both are influenced by money, one probably significantly more than the other. But combined, it's probably more than 50%.
- tptacek 9y agoIt's self-evidently not the case that only "corrupt shills" oppose FCC-mandated net neutrality.
- shmerl 9y agoThe core of the opposition to it comes from monopolists who don't want their abusive monopolistic practices to be held in check. Who else, besides those who are paid off by said monopolists, would willingly side with them?
- tptacek 9y agoThis is just the same thing you said in your last comment, reworded. No.
- shmerl 9y agoAnswer the question please. Who else supports monopoly (besides obvious shills)?
- wmf 9y agoRobert Graham, for example: http://blog.erratasec.com/2017/12/libertarians-are-against-net-neutrality.html http://blog.erratasec.com/2017/12/libertarians-are-against-n... (He's an admitted troll, but I think this mostly represents his true opinions.)
- tptacek 9y agoHe's a bit of a troll, but he's also a libertarian. Lots of libertarians don't support Title II NN. I'm not a libertarian --- I find Graham's rhetoric barely tolerable --- but I think Title II NN is a silly issue to lobby over. (I'm not "against" it; I just don't care.) If you want to find people of all political spectra opposing Title II, talk to backbone engineers that don't work for content companies.
- shmerl 9y ago> But the never mention the most simplest: that broadband monopolies can just charge customers more money. They already do. Comcast and Co. simply charge users extra, if they want to avoid data caps. They only can get away with it because they are monopolists. What it means in practice, that they basically make competing services more expensive, giving edge to their own which they obviously don't count against those caps. So why would libertarians support such garbage behavior? The answer is, they wouldn't. So I don't buy his argument that he is a libertarian. > The answer is that the claim "monopoly" power is a deception. Yeah, right. Ignoring reality won't change the facts.
- tptacek 9y agoWhy would anybody tell you they oppose NN if you will brand them as bad-faith interlocutors by definition for opposing it?
- shmerl 9y agoI've never seen a single argument against NN, which explained how repealing it won't allow current monopolists run amok with all the anti-competitive garbage they are known to engage in. So you don't need to explain anything, but I'll treat those who hold such position as corrupted shills or those who are manipulated and don't put any thought into the matter.
- oelmekki 9y agoAs a side note, you may also consider that between those who act for lobbies and those who want to defend net neutrality, there's a huge amount of people who just don't care. And actually, I kind of understand them. While I would prefer net neutrality to be registered as a regulation, I'm not sure it's that much of a big deal if it's not : those decisions are not about forbidding net neutrality, it's about not forbidding to not enforce it (sorry for the double negative). We had a big case of net neutrality violation here in france at the beginning of the decade: a few ISPs would slow down data transfers from youtube to try to extort money from google. My ISP of the moment ("Free" is its name) was among them, and I was mad at them at the time. Then, OVH launched their ISP services, with their main selling point being their respect of net neutrality. I switched to them and never had a problem again. Now, I say it was "a big case" because it's pure net neutrality violation at its worst, but nobody really cared. This did not caused mainstream national debate, just a few consumer groups suing the companies. I think those practices were ultimately rolled back when EU moved in favor of net neutrality. But here is the fact (and I'm totally aware I'm playing devil's advocate, here): if we care about net neutrality, why not see it as a feature, and to hell with those who don't care? If tomorrow a company spends big marketing budget on ad campaigns explaining how they don't slow down "your internet" while all others companies do, it may actually have more impact on the masses than something seen as a political debate.
- untog 9y agoPeople who do not understand tech. It's quite easy to sell the repeal of net neutrality as "pro competition" to someone who doesn't understand the issues. Unfortunately this includes a lot of people.
- rhino369 9y agoCan you point where I can get my shill pay out. I'd love some extra X-mas gift money.
- shmerl 9y agoTry Comcast, Verizon, AT&T and Charter. They spend millions on this.
- tptacek 9y agoAnd Google, Facebook, and Netflix are spending millions against. Why should I be excited to be a pawn in a battle between billion dollar multinationals?
- shmerl 9y ago> Why should I be excited to be a pawn If you aren't using Internet, you don't need to care about it. If you are, you either care about gatekeepers not abusing their ownership of the network, or you are paid off by them not to. Other option is clueless bystander. Pick yours.
- tptacek 9y agoI'm using Internet right now and strangely don't find myself excited. This hostile, content-free rhetoric you're deploying isn't very persuasive.
- shmerl 9y agoI don't find your support for monopolies to be something that can't be criticized. If you can't defend your position - too bad.
- tptacek 9y agoYou asked upthread why I wasn't "answering your question". This response is why. Who would discuss anything with you when it's so clear you aren't discussing in good faith? Not everybody agrees with you.