5 ms·
Is there any reason to believe that this will ever even make it out of committee and come up for a vote? He's a Democrat. Democrats are a minority in the House
by tzs 9y ago
Is there any reason to believe that this will ever even make it out of committee and come up for a vote?
He's a Democrat. Democrats are a minority in the House of Representatives (193 Democrats vs. 239 Republicans), and Republicans have been very united in opposition to net neutrality. Getting rid of the 2015 rule is even part of the party platform adopted at the 2016 convention. It seems very unlikely that enough Republicans can be convinced to go against their party position and flip on this.
They would also draw the ire of President Trump, who is on the record as strongly opposing net neutrality. Not that he actually knows what net neutrality is [1]...
At best, Republicans might let this go to a vote, and allow up to about 20 Republicans from moderate states where Democrats might use net neutrality to flip seats vote in favor of it to help keep those seats Republican.
[1] Trump: ""Obama’s attack on the internet is another top down power grab. Net neutrality is the Fairness Doctrine. Will target conservative media." https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/532608358508167168 https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/53260835850816716...
- tptacek 9y agoIt has no chance. I can at least applaud the fact that it puts the spotlight back on Congress, as opposed to the FCC. The FCC is a Republican regulatory agency. Like every regulatory agency, it's only minimally accountable to voters. The expectation that loud public outcry from Internet nerds would lead it to regulate like a Democratic agency is crazymaking.
- shmerl 9y ago> Republicans have been very united in opposition to net neutrality Does it indicate all of them are corrupt? Because only corrupt shills oppose it willingly.
- jopsen 9y agoEven if they are not all bought, it's unlikely that none of the Democrats have been bought. I'm not saying the two parties are even. Both are influenced by money, one probably significantly more than the other. But combined, it's probably more than 50%.
- tptacek 9y agoIt's self-evidently not the case that only "corrupt shills" oppose FCC-mandated net neutrality.
- shmerl 9y agoThe core of the opposition to it comes from monopolists who don't want their abusive monopolistic practices to be held in check. Who else, besides those who are paid off by said monopolists, would willingly side with them?
- tptacek 9y agoThis is just the same thing you said in your last comment, reworded. No.
- shmerl 9y agoAnswer the question please. Who else supports monopoly (besides obvious shills)?
- wmf 9y agoRobert Graham, for example: http://blog.erratasec.com/2017/12/libertarians-are-against-net-neutrality.html http://blog.erratasec.com/2017/12/libertarians-are-against-n... (He's an admitted troll, but I think this mostly represents his true opinions.)
- tptacek 9y agoHe's a bit of a troll, but he's also a libertarian. Lots of libertarians don't support Title II NN. I'm not a libertarian --- I find Graham's rhetoric barely tolerable --- but I think Title II NN is a silly issue to lobby over. (I'm not "against" it; I just don't care.) If you want to find people of all political spectra opposing Title II, talk to backbone engineers that don't work for content companies.
- shmerl 9y ago
- rhino369 9y agoCan you point where I can get my shill pay out. I'd love some extra X-mas gift money.
- shmerl 9y agoTry Comcast, Verizon, AT&T and Charter. They spend millions on this.
- tptacek 9y agoAnd Google, Facebook, and Netflix are spending millions against. Why should I be excited to be a pawn in a battle between billion dollar multinationals?
- shmerl 9y ago> Why should I be excited to be a pawn If you aren't using Internet, you don't need to care about it. If you are, you either care about gatekeepers not abusing their ownership of the network, or you are paid off by them not to. Other option is clueless bystander. Pick yours.
- tptacek 9y agoI'm using Internet right now and strangely don't find myself excited. This hostile, content-free rhetoric you're deploying isn't very persuasive.
- shmerl 9y agoI don't find your support for monopolies to be something that can't be criticized. If you can't defend your position - too bad.
- tptacek 9y agoYou asked upthread why I wasn't "answering your question". This response is why. Who would discuss anything with you when it's so clear you aren't discussing in good faith? Not everybody agrees with you.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Is there any reason to believe that this will ever even make it out of committee and come up for a vote? In the absence of activism, no; OTOH, there's an interaction between activism and a concrete legislative proposal to rally around; enough grassroots support in the districts of enough people who aren’t as strongly.committed to backing the anti-neutrality position as they are to their own re-election, and it could happen. Moreover, even if it fails, the more attention that is drawn to it the more it helps raise the potential of net neutrality legislation being an platform issue in the 2018 elections; policy fights are rarely once-and-done battles, they are long wars, and some battles are more about preparing ground for the next battle than winning the war outright.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoThis is being advanced to create more populist hay for Democratic challengers to use for 2018. It isn't intended to pass.
- qwerty456127 9y agoDoesn't he have a tech advisor of a sort who could possibly explain him the thing so he won't make comments this funny?
- drewmol 9y agoProbably, however he has continually demonstrated unwiliingness to allow others to censor, edjucate, or have much of any effect his comments. Cringeworthy as it may be, it's viewed a feature to a large minority.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThey are only funny (in a.negative way, at least) to the segment of the population who both has knowledge to know how badly inaccurate they are and who are not ideologically committed to the agenda the statements advance. Those people are not the audience they are designed to manipulate.
- curiousgal 9y agoI honestly don’t understand how people can mention this with a straight face. Party loyalty goes above the public’s interest? This is crazy.